That was a tense game tbf, was hella fun playing with everyone! Hope I get to play with you all again! Although I don't think anyone is ever gonna trust me ever again! Aha
In post 364, Corwinoid wrote:A big part of this is realizing that Turtle/Rhett don't make that night kill, so there's at least one scum in {Spartan, Bella, EE}. That kill instead of you or me suddenly makes a lot more sense if you and/or Bella are scum. If you or EE have read through my other town games you might be hoping me to tunnel into day 2 and keep driving or just go for a low activity kill (I don't have a lot of town games recently to debunk that idea), and Bella could get there also or just keep me alive to keep me alive. You not dying makes a lot more sense if you're scum too.
The night kill avoids the lowest activity posters day 1, but still hits finds a low info kill that can't be NKA'd. There's no god-tier PR read here, ST just picked a really good kill and got a hit inside the mason team.
POE on the night kill keeps me alive to drive the elim, EE alive as a possible mislim target or scum, and turtle and rhett alive as low activity targets or as one of the partners. Rhett's still a possibility, but turtle doesn't need to ask why he looks scummy coming out of day one. That leaves you, Bella, Nek.
In post 272, Corwinoid wrote:Also possible, though I still have reasons to think not.
Actually this comment is a little WIFOMy now that I'm thinking about it. It's just as likely it was a random kill and got a lucky hit in the masons team; it would be real easy to paint that as "an SE with an inhumanly good read." More likely it doesn't point to SE / not-SE, I think the scum team just got an early hit.
In post 330, Corwinoid wrote:I see now. That pairing wouldn't make that NK. It would have been me or Spartan.
So, Bella, why aren't you scum and why should I believe you?
Also, I should have rolled harder on this. She played it almost exactly how I would have played it, and just ignored it... it burns... it literally burns.
Also, there were a couple of points in D3 I was worried I was town tunneling Spartan, but every time I just kept coming back to "No, these are the exact things I'm thinking being dropped before I say them, and that is completely town."
I personally like to go for a less active slot that I think could be hiding as a PR and I had early suspicions on a Mason team of Princess and EE (i mentioned this in the scum chat), didn't expect turtle tbh. But the claim day 2 made it easy with the NK as then there aren't the questions of why none of the SEs were night killed as we elimed the masons so I felt able for us to get by even tho we did still get a lot of heat being SEs aha
In post 272, Corwinoid wrote:Also possible, though I still have reasons to think not.
Actually this comment is a little WIFOMy now that I'm thinking about it. It's just as likely it was a random kill and got a lucky hit in the masons team; it would be real easy to paint that as "an SE with an inhumanly good read." More likely it doesn't point to SE / not-SE, I think the scum team just got an early hit.
That happened to me recently with lukewarm, he kept saying everything I was thinking and he was scum!! It really messed with me because those were my legit thoughts. It's made me think more about just playing 'as town' as scum, and I feel I did well day three at least.
Spartan was really hot on mason hunting in the PT too.
In post 587, Corwinoid wrote:Also, there were a couple of points in D3 I was worried I was town tunneling Spartan, but every time I just kept coming back to "No, these are the exact things I'm thinking being dropped before I say them, and that is completely town."
Bah, now I'm just mad at myself.
I just try and play a strong town either way, and as EE analysed very emotive in general so it's hard to get a read on it being AI
Also we had Geek claim VT which made the odds better, I dont see people bringing up roles if they are a PR as they want to stay under the radar. My response to him was somewhat genuine frustration if I had been town in that position, as I wouldn't want someone making the odds of hitting PR easier but yeah just a newbtown slip
