Here's through page 20:
In post 310, Cabd wrote:Oh also forgot to mention this in my first posts but I have a role that I will likely never use barring consensus from people I have down as town, so I will be full claiming it when and if it becomes applicable.
I was entering the reread expecting that I would find Cabd scummiest, but this kind of thing makes me think town.
I have no idea who Chandra is.
I've had you as relatively certain town since like page 2 due to your implied information on the mod list things. I imagine people are cagey about it because they don't want to highlight it. This is also relevant to Cabd treating you and Tier differently.
I figured out that Chandra is Cephrir.
Mollie's 349 is scummy, since it suggests she hasn't erad NS's posts earlier on the page particularly carefully. Weaker because it's Mollie.
Copper and Cephrir had different impressions of Cabd's activity level before he returned to the hgame (363).
I do not really understand everyone thinking that Shos is scum. Shos had been kind of a non-entity up to this point (379).
TierShift is not scum with Shos, because contradicting so many players' read on Shos would be too risky for the sense I have of him this game so far (381).
[I'm drinking a white russian now mmm.]
I think copper is town (389).
Shos always seems a little phlegmatic in games I play with him, re: Ceph's summary of his POV in 399.
Mollie is having fun. This makes me think she might be town after all.
T-Bone may be scum (409-411). EDIT: But 413 was townier. Meh.
@ Rhinox - Lack of participation is probably a relative scumtell for me, but the deal in this case is that I would have had to read the game on my phone, which I wasn't really prepared to do the way I needed to, because my computer was running some stuff for work during the whole break.
If scum have daytalk, Cephrir is not scum with Katsuki (430).
She hasn't said anything about her. She was suspicious about NS, but hasn't mentioned it again, she said that LLD was town, and on Saturday she said that Shos was scum (though I personally don't get it). She's been out of it for the last few days due to a pet dying.
[Is mollie ever being added to the points charts?]
Katsuki's specificity on shos is nice (458).
In post 485, Cephrir wrote: In post 483, Katsuki wrote:And me not reading is apparently scum.
Please demonstrate how it is alignment indicative.
You don't care if your reads are accurate.
P.S. You're also scum for having a shitty reaction to your wagon.
FWIW, as much as I would hate to admit it, Katsuki not reading the game is actually not really all that alignment-indicative.
As town he regularly fakes investigative claims, fucking up games in the process. He also does the same I'M SMART YOU'RE DUMB thing without reading that he appears to be doing here as town. I think you should know this, come to think of it, because the example I was going to provide for you was D1 Inuyasha mafia. The context there was that scum had badly fucked up their fakeclaim and were obviously scum, but AP and I had to corral everyone into voting them, and Katsuki came out to try to grandstand on their behalf while showing that he had no idea what was going on in the process.
I remember that he was town that game because after we were killed N1, AP and I played 20 questions from the scumlist that AP received from a Mod, and I cackled for a long time when I realized that Katsuki was literally just fucking around.
(This is the sort of thing that makes Katsuki the preferred policy lynch by a landslide. Not that a policy lynch is necessary or advised really.)
I agree with Reckoner about Cabd tbh (494). But will revisit this if one or both of Shos and Katsuki flip scum later.