[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Undefined array key 6700829 [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Trying to access array offset on value of type null Mod Error Mafia [TM2015] - Game Over - Mafiascum.net
Post
Post #71 (isolation #4) » Wed Apr 01, 2015 1:48 pm
Postby xRECKONERx »
I just got home, was out all day with family. I was mobile posting all day.
Cabd is actually scum, though, because of that policy lynch + HEY YALL LETS TALK ABOUT PRIOR ROLES BECAUSE UHHH MOD META ANYTHING TO STOP ME FROM HAVING TO TALK ABOUT REAL THINGS
And Cephrir's insistence that I'm scum based on (???) and then refusal to explain/elaborate when I pressed him further is bad, too.
Post
Post #78 (isolation #6) » Wed Apr 01, 2015 2:29 pm
Postby xRECKONERx »
I don't think we have any history or reasons to hate each other so I'm not sure where that came from.
I meant it in a way that your team and my team and in all four of our games together and your team repulses me with how lovey dovey you are so I want to kill you so I hope you're scum.
Post
Post #104 (isolation #10) » Wed Apr 01, 2015 6:38 pm
Postby xRECKONERx »
In post 98, notscience wrote:This doesn't make sense. First off, he posted it so early in the game that there wasn't even anything else for him to try and avoid talking about. Second, something something starting a policy lynch is a null tell.
Driving the conversation towards theory/setup/speculation allows scum to not contribute anything to the game. I've hidden behind it several times as scum. It's not about what he was avoiding THERE, it's about the direction he was heading. We have now had several pages of people claiming roles and wondering AHHH WHERE ARE THE OLD ROLE CLAIMS and it's just silly.
Advocating a policy lynch is pretty bad, unless the player is truly horrendous -- IE, not Who. Additionally, if it was really that bad that Cabd doesn't like playing with him, his team had the option to swap.
Post
Post #143 (isolation #11) » Thu Apr 02, 2015 8:16 am
Postby xRECKONERx »
In post 106, notscience wrote:Also to note: There was board game mafia a while back, and I don't know the current validity of this or not, but Morph (him/ffery) made a comment about how the pro-town charter that was presented (essentially, it was like "be protown! we agree to be protown and have fun!') and their comment was "If we were scum, we would just spend the majority of day 1 outlining this contract." so yes, I do see why that might be an issue, but I think it's only an issue if thats all he does today. ie, you might have jumped the gun a bit on that.
I'm not very good at waiting around. I do things. Then I do more things based on the results of the things I did. Perhaps I did jump the gun, but I saw something that struck me as scummy, and I did things.
Post
Post #144 (isolation #12) » Thu Apr 02, 2015 8:18 am
Postby xRECKONERx »
In post 110, copper223 wrote:@Reck
I don't think what Cabd did there was setup speculating for the sake of it there, when he pulled the setup spec. card in Poe he tried to influence what we believed about it whereas here he made it an open discussion, the PL I am not so fond of because I've seen scum hide behind it to avoid having to find legit reasons to scumread players they know are town, so if that's all he does I'll reconsider, for now this seems, tonewise as well, more like the Rome town Cabd rather than the Poe scum Medea.
I haven't decided if your push is legit town or scum finding something to push on, I think I am biased on this read cause I didn't appreciate your playstile the first time we played so I want to scumread you, which might funnily enough make me overcompensate towards town when I shouldn't if that makes sense.
What's the pro-town benefit of setup speculation discussion? It's not even current setup spec -- it's setup spec from a completely unrelated game. It is not productive, it's anti-productive. It's a distraction. I don't particularly give a shit about meta or anything, so that piece of the argument falls flat for me. For me, analyzing that within the context of this game alone, it's sketchy.
Because there was obviously no intent to avoid engaging this game by cabd and you made it seem like there was. You seemed to be pretty certain in your read but now that there's resistance to your read you try to justify it with even more bullshit ('it was just about the direction he was heading') which is put forward more as an excuse for scumreading him than as a read you believe in. Town don't need to make excuses for reads, they believe in reads.
Seriously, people, read 104 and see it's a fucking excuse.
"Obviously no intent"? How is it obvious? He brought up setup speculation about a completely unrelated game that has no actual impact or anything on this game and asked for EVERY PLAYER IN THE GAME to engage in said useless bullshit setup speculation. How is that "obviously" not engaging?
Bringing that up dictates the course of the early phase of this game and that course is shitty and not productive and bullshit. It's scummy enough,
Post
Post #146 (isolation #14) » Thu Apr 02, 2015 8:23 am
Postby xRECKONERx »
In post 121, Cephrir wrote:You should have held on to this, if you're town. He made one post about it. If he continued to harp on setup spec for 10 pages, you might have had a case, but one post is one post. Did it look like he might continue to do more of it? Yeah, it sure did, but that didn't actually happen. It really is silly, though; we've learned exactly one thing and that's that the mod can be expected to try to fuck with our heads, but you should always expect good mods to fuck with your head anyway.
I didn't like you calling him "actually scum" without waiting to see if things would really play out that way. On its own, that one post is a pretty flimsy reason, and I don't think anyone should have strong beliefs based on it alone.
I'm constantly baffled by the idea of policy lynches, but I haven't noticed one alignment as more likely to advocate them, especially Day 1.
I don't wait around, sorry. And I don't want fifteen pages of people rambling about setup speculation before I go "AHA! NOW THAT WE'VE WASTED ALL THIS TIME, YOU'VE ACTIVATED MY TRAP CARD!". Not my style, and not something I'm interested in doing this game. Read my above post for more context.
It's early D1. I'd say pushing for nonproductive setup speculation + a weak sauce policy lynch is better reasoning to vote someone than stupid fucking RVS bullshit. Like it was strong enough that I didn't feel like engaging in RVS and wanted to get straight to meat & potatoes.
Re: policy lynching-- I don't know the numbers on whether one alignment does it more than another. I do know that unless it's a very SPECIFIC situation (like, Nobody Special), then it usually lacks any sort of pro-town motivation behind it. It's super easy for scum to just go RABBLE RABBLE TUNNEL TUNNEL POLICY LYNCH and not really engage with the game. I have done it pleeeenty of times.
And now Cabd hasn't posted in 24 hours after the shitstorm kicked up, despite being around the site yesterday evening and late last night.
In post 144, xRECKONERx wrote:What's the pro-town benefit of setup speculation discussion? It's not even current setup spec -- it's setup spec from a completely unrelated game. It is not productive, it's anti-productive. It's a distraction. I don't particularly give a shit about meta or anything, so that piece of the argument falls flat for me. For me, analyzing that within the context of this game alone, it's sketchy.
At least you can admit your bias.
You don't know if there is a correlation between the roles of the prior setup and the new ones, from the roles you all said you received I suspect there is one so the discussion is not useless, there are other ways where discussion of past roles can be useful as well.
I could make the same argument for RVS you just mad for Cabd proposing that discussion, it's not productive because all of us here know how it goes, it's anti-productive, it's a distraction, it's scum indicative that you RVS voted ... (if you space the logical jumps from A to D by putting in B and C to make it look reasonable it still is absurd when you connect the dots).
I do think it's possible you are strirring things up as town and some pressure on Cabd is fine by me.
If a complete reroll of the game means "oh yeah btw we're using the same roles and shit" then the mods fucked up and I quit
In post 145, xRECKONERx wrote:
"Obviously no intent"? How is it obvious? He brought up setup speculation about a completely unrelated game that has no actual impact or anything on this game and asked for EVERY PLAYER IN THE GAME to engage in said useless bullshit setup speculation. How is that "obviously" not engaging?
Bringing that up dictates the course of the early phase of this game and that course is shitty and not productive and bullshit. It's scummy enough,
especially so early on D1
, to warrant a push.
Your defense of him is really cute though
I know cabd as a very thorough player. Wanting to understand the previous setup suits him. He wasn't doing it in a way to avoid commenting, he was just doing first things first. I've seen scumhim lurk and not contribute, but it's too early to tell if that is what he's doing,
especially so early on D1
.
"dont try to make plays or apply pressure on d1 bc it's d1"
makes sense. Do they have any ruling on the more active players? Tiershift, LLD, etc?
No, the only things that have been said are that they think I'm on the right track applying pressure to Cabd/Cephrir and that they believe shos/T-Bone are town. That's it.
My PT is pretty dead with regards to this game, mostly because it started so late.
Post
Post #259 (isolation #24) » Fri Apr 03, 2015 8:44 am
Postby xRECKONERx »
UT clarified that he feels T-Bone scum is more spamposty and frenzied whereas this feels like T-Bone just trying to make some lobbed baskets just to stay in the game
I'm under contractual obligation to post this and inform you all that you're going to be overrun by the mighty armies of cute. Can you handle the swee-- ugh, never mind, this script is disgusting. *burns script*
Can you handle these FEROCIOUS ANIMALS?
Look at that cat. He wants to tear your faces off, scum, and feed them to you.
How about the fox? He looks cute on the outside, but just look at how he's manhandling that stick. Fierce.
The warthog is a fucking warthog. You really shouldn't fuck with warthogs, they will fuck you up. He also moonlights as a raging demigod fire wizard so yeah.
And MASTER FUCKING SPLINTER? Yeah, he's so awesome, he doesn't even need to destroy you himself. Hes so much better than you, he can TEACH OTHERS TO BE BETTER THAN YOU.
So watch out scum, these pissed off adorable woodland creatures are gonna take you down.
Post
Post #494 (isolation #39) » Mon Apr 06, 2015 8:27 am
Postby xRECKONERx »
Go read through Cabd's iso then come back to me and with a straight face tell me "yeah that's a town iso"
like it's just bad. it's terrible. half of it is the stupid early game distractothon and half of it is awful reads with very little in the way of reasoning
seriously, after pages of content, he fires back with blanket town reads on me/mollie/Ceph. And his reasons boil down to LOL REACTIONS. Mollie had only been in the game for like one page and Cabd engages in Who WIFOM to explain his read. It's terrible. It's fucking terrible.
"copper fading on me makes sense" turns into "SLEPT ON IT, HE'S SCUM, REASONS LATER"
Post
Post #655 (isolation #43) » Wed Apr 08, 2015 2:30 pm
Postby xRECKONERx »
I dunno what else I can do with Cabd. I'm like, "here's a few reasons why he's scum". And Cabd isn't posting so it's not like that read can develop at all
Post
Post #672 (isolation #45) » Wed Apr 08, 2015 5:29 pm
Postby xRECKONERx »
In post 668, Iecerint wrote:This game in general has a big lack of anything regarding you tbf. You rival me in that regard, and you weren't even on vacation, though you do seem to have had a few fun nights. ^^;
Post
Post #787 (isolation #47) » Fri Apr 10, 2015 7:09 am
Postby xRECKONERx »
It's really annoying to me that this mini theme has as many D1 posts as some large themes. It's making it hard to really keep up. The worst part is that, from looking through it, none of it is obnoxious spamposting. All of it is content, but it's making the game dense and hard to get into for me.
I have some town reads: mollie, Iecerint, copper, T-Bone, shos.
Everyone else is rather null-to-scum but all in one big grey goopy pile atm and I don't particularly see it getting any better.
Post
Post #803 (isolation #49) » Fri Apr 10, 2015 11:22 am
Postby xRECKONERx »
Oh I forgot my team thinks notty is town too so add him to the pile. Yeah.
Don't want to lynch: mollie, Iecerint, copper, T-Bone, shos, notty. LLD is an off-town read so I'd prefer other people as well due to earlier interactions that icba to find right now.
Would consider Cabd, Cephrir, Katsu, Rhinox, Tiershift.
well, I attempted to help you with cabd by voting him with you, I was waiting around for you to push more (and I get that is hard to do when he is being a lurksack) so i support you and follow-up and i sent you a message so yeah I wld say that I have!
we do great with board games and f2f I just don't understand why it doesn't translate to forum mafia. I am not giving up tho COS SOMEDAY IT IS GONNA HAPPEN.
I don't
really
understand why you were asking this question in the first place. cos it is kinda apparent that I have!
are you doing that thing you do where you only look up your name in a thread and those are the only posts you look at
yes im only reading posts with my name in it atm
and idk what you want me to say do that? I pushed Cabd. I gave my reasons. Most people ignored them, then Cabd continued to lurk his way into irrelevancy. I can't do much else.
Post
Post #863 (isolation #56) » Sat Apr 11, 2015 7:58 pm
Postby xRECKONERx »
In post 860, Cabd wrote:xRECKONERx: "hey guys cabd role sounds like it could be scum i dunno, but hell it justifies my vote on it" Yeah, okay, no. If reck was like "omg guys cabd is the scummiest fucking scum ever" that wouldn't have been his reaction/statement. Such a halfhearted move on who he defines as his primary scum suspect AND has been voteparking? Nope.