Newbie 2077 : The Curse of a Blue Diamond!! - Gameover

[Save The Dragons]

sup nerds

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: salsa

[Save The Dragons]

i, too, have played mafia on greylaberynth approx 15 years ago

[Save The Dragons]

his play is really not all that uncharacteristic for how people used to play here.

my first newbie game was over in 5 pages

[Save The Dragons]

ooooh i have a fan!

[Save The Dragons]

catboi, what does your scum game look like?

[Save The Dragons]

Not like this.

[Save The Dragons]

@ save the dragons: Why the vote on salsa?

gut. i feel like the multiple votes for kennyk are over the top.

And on a sidenote: did you use the same name on GL?

save the werewolves

[Save The Dragons]

uranus, do you have any guesses as to who might be town or scum?

[Save The Dragons]

you need to write "vote: X" in bold, or use the vote tag

Code: Select all

[v]X[/v]

[Save The Dragons]

i think kennyk is town

[Save The Dragons]

i think kennyk is town

Do you have thoughts on the arguments made by radical and others?

i think he could be scum trying to harp on something wacky that a newbie is doing to get a mislim.

[Save The Dragons]

wooo let's catch some baddies

[Save The Dragons]

who do you want to vote

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: radical rat

want more pressure here

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: radical rat

want more pressure here

What does your PoE look like? I kinda want to work with you and Kenny this game.

scum
salsa
radical

null
lq
ent
floo

town
kennyk
uranus
cls

[Save The Dragons]

mostly just gut at this point, i would like more information

i'm wary i might be getting pocketed a little bit though

[Save The Dragons]

i meant by cls

[Save The Dragons]

does it

[Save The Dragons]

....what

[Save The Dragons]

....what

Actually, I feel like this is really Scummy that StD isn't tracking with me here.

me - posts unintentional ambiguous post
you - you were talking about me!
me - no i wasn't
you - you meant to post that to make me look bad!!!!
me - what

[Save The Dragons]

....what

Actually, I feel like this is really Scummy that StD isn't tracking with me here.

me - posts unintentional ambiguous post
you - you were talking about me!
me - no i wasn't
you - you meant to post that to make me look bad!!!!
me - what

You should have been tracking with my reasoning and you weren't, so...

your reasoning makes no sense so...

[Save The Dragons]

don't use the l word please

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: salsa

[Save The Dragons]

i don't come from a different site meta, i've played hundreds of games on this site

[Save The Dragons]

i think kennyk is town

Can you explain?

it's a lot of a gut read just based on how he posts, he seems like town that scum can easily push for an easy mislim.

[Save The Dragons]

i think kennyk is town

Can you explain?

it's a lot of a gut read just based on how he posts, he seems like town that scum can easily push for an easy mislim.

Yeah, I agree about the easy push now.

you were one of the ones pushing him tho

[Save The Dragons]

rr why do you trust salsa

[Save The Dragons]

rr why do you trust salsa

Because her posting has consistently read as genuine scumhunting, and while I was initially iffy about her kenny tunneling, after coming to my own conclusion that kenny is almost certainly scum, her being there first reinforces that townlean into a firmer townread.

is she your scumpartner

[Save The Dragons]

rr why do you trust salsa

Because her posting has consistently read as genuine scumhunting, and while I was initially iffy about her kenny tunneling, after coming to my own conclusion that kenny is almost certainly scum, her being there first reinforces that townlean into a firmer townread.

is she your scumpartner

Is she yours?

i thought you thought she was town

[Save The Dragons]

...interesting...

[Save The Dragons]

rr why do you trust salsa

Why do

you

not trust me?

cuz i just think you're scum here

[Save The Dragons]

salsa will you post a readslist

[Save The Dragons]

@mod V/LA until monday evening

[Save The Dragons]

Will catch up tonight or tomorrow morning

[Save The Dragons]

Townread: STD, Radical

why am i a townread?

[Save The Dragons]

rr why do you trust salsa

Why do

you

not trust me?

cuz i just think you're scum here

Because I 3 times voted your

gut

townread? Don't you think it's also an interesting fact?

actually yeah

I'm disappointing with you actually atp If you can read

kenny

properly here out of the blue, then you should read me accurately too, at least I accept that.

why? you play differently

Btw, when I'll flip green, will you still townread

kenny

? I want to know your thoughts after my flip basically...[/color]

yes i think i still tr kenny at that point.

[Save The Dragons]

chances are your partner is StD

[Save The Dragons]

Entel probably Town on a Salsa Scum flip.

wait why

[Save The Dragons]

StD probably not SvS with Salsa here.

didn't really feel this way: there may be some partner equity but it might be too on the nose: StD blatantly asking RR if salsa is their scumpartner feels odd, plus they're slightly less hostile to salsa compared to you

on second thought it's probably poor play to try and do smtn like this in a newbie game, that's 2 condemns you gotta plow through, and also the fact that solo mafia has a reallly hard time dealing with certain power roles (JK, tracker come to mind)
it's not something that i can be confident on, StD does a lot of naked voting so i might be inferring things that he might not even have thought of but i'm feeling that non-zero chance

why do you think i would be bussing my partner out of nowhere d1

[Save The Dragons]

@Salsa

Why do you townread StD so strongly? I can't really make up my mind how I feel about the slot, but I think I'm leaning scum more often than not, largely vibe-based.

[Save The Dragons]

StD have you finished rereading the Day?

not yet still going through it

[Save The Dragons]

Quick reads list. This isn't a solid read list, but this is generally how I feel about who is town and who is not.

RegRider
-----
Kennyk
Salsa
StD
LQ
Null

I am open to any Elim thats not these people.

why salsa so high

[Save The Dragons]

i like regrider, would like astronomyfortwo to post something, still thinking it's just salsa here.

[Save The Dragons]

uh ok

i mean i could but it'd be a lot easier as scum to not do that

[Save The Dragons]

what specifically about salsa seems all over the place and why does that make you want to vote them

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: astronomyfortwo

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: astronomyfortwo

going after LHF. Not a fan.

What makes them LHF? What makes Uranus not LHF?

[Save The Dragons]

LHF

i've seen this abbreviation so many times and i don't know what it means yet

low hanging fruit i believe...?

Do you think you are LHF?

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: astronomyfortwo

going after LHF. Not a fan.

What makes them LHF? What makes Uranus not LHF?

I think Uranus has enough experience in Mafia to not be LHF.

so newbies can't be scum?

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: astronomyfortwo

going after LHF. Not a fan.

What makes them LHF? What makes Uranus not LHF?

I think Uranus has enough experience in Mafia to not be LHF.

so newbies can't be scum?

You're moving the goalpost. Are we talking about LHF or are we talking about Scum?

what are you talking about

why do you think i'm voting astronomyfortwo

[Save The Dragons]

i did acknowledge it with a vote

i think they're scum

[Save The Dragons]

mostly just A Vibe from various posts...

mostly an attitude thing

i hate the tone it sounds fake

[Save The Dragons]

so you don't think it sounds believable?

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: Uranus

that's e-1

[Save The Dragons]

let's flip someone

[Save The Dragons]

What's different about the Uranus case?

we're approaching a deadline and i want to flip someone

VOTE: salsa

[Save The Dragons]

i'm not convinced he's scum

[Save The Dragons]

StD/kennyk scumteam, calling it now.

i like how your case is against LQ but you don't think he's scum

[Save The Dragons]

We CAN no lim, but in most cases we should NOT do that.

Anyway, this Uranus wagon is really bad, and StD is super scum for it, more when I get home.

apparently i'm super scum because i started the wagon except no i didn't that was LQ and he's not super scum for it

[Save The Dragons]

i always had doubts on uranus

i think astronomyfortwo and salsa are the scum here

but if we get the game moving i'm okay with that

[Save The Dragons]

this Uranus wagon is really bad, and StD is super scum

for it

nani?

[Save The Dragons]

so was I scum for starting the wagon or not before you realize i didn't start the wagon

[Save The Dragons]

because you literally said i was scum for starting the wagon

[Save The Dragons]

i don't know if you saw but i highlighted the words "for it" for a reason

[Save The Dragons]

for it

[Save The Dragons]

oops

[Save The Dragons]

Yes, you were scum for starting the wagon in my mind at that point.

so why isn't LQ when he actually started the wagon

[Save The Dragons]

what a lame ass semantics argument

someone tell me why salsa is mafia real quick

over eager attack on kenny

[Save The Dragons]

We CAN no lim, but in most cases we should NOT do that.

Anyway, this Uranus wagon is really bad, and StD is super scum for it, more when I get home.

apparently i'm super scum because i started the wagon except no i didn't that was LQ and he's not super scum for it

StD/kennyk scumteam, calling it now.

i like how your case is against LQ but you don't think he's scum

It wasn't against LQ, it was specifically about your defense of kenny as being new player awkwardness pounced on by scum, followed by a flashwagon on Uranus for what I see as Actual new player awkwardness, as opposed to blatantly scum thought processes.

I do still think it's very sketchy that you hopped on, and off, the wagon so quickly, but I do at least somewhat understand the deadline pressure affects things.

LQ's take on kenny was different, so I don't think there's really that same level of hypocrisy there, and as such don't scumread him for it.

yeah that has nothing to do with how LQ interacted with uranus

[Save The Dragons]

k thank you i got it now

[Save The Dragons]

hi norwee i think you are scum and people should vote for you

[Save The Dragons]

blatantly false but okay

[Save The Dragons]

i think kennyk is town

Can you explain?

it's a lot of a gut read just based on how he posts, he seems like town that scum can easily push for an easy mislim.

what a lame ass semantics argument

someone tell me why salsa is mafia real quick

over eager attack on kenny

[Save The Dragons]

why

[Save The Dragons]

if it's down to those two then i'd lim uranus but i'm not convinced yet we have to limit ourselves to those two

[Save The Dragons]

i think he's scum trying to pocket you with a fake tr

[Save The Dragons]

we're not limming kenny today

[Save The Dragons]

astronomyfortwo, uranus, any thoughts?

[Save The Dragons]

like salsa/norwee?

[Save The Dragons]

was more curious if uranus still is happy with his vote

[Save The Dragons]

if it really is norwee and we let him go i'm going to be sad

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: astronomyfortwo

[Save The Dragons]

probably lean town?

[Save The Dragons]

probably lean town?

Why?

honestly just gut at this point, don't really want to consider him today when there's scummier options on the table

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: uranus I think e-1

[Save The Dragons]

that was E-1 because LQ unvoted

right?

[Save The Dragons]

a cobra!

hey guys

let's kill someone today

killing someone is our only way to get rid of scum, so it's best to kill someone than not unless it's a specific situation that probably won't apply

VOTE: Astronomyfortwo

[Save The Dragons]

killing someone is our only way to get rid of scum

[Save The Dragons]

rr do you think scum posts that take

[Save The Dragons]

do you still think kenny and i are scum

[Save The Dragons]

damnit

[Save The Dragons]

i don't think it's ever a good idea except in melo philosophically because it's the only way we can get rid of scum so it's often better to take a chance than wait and see.

i don't really remember a time because it's just not really done. i could see it if you had vigs, or a lot of investigative roles you wanted results from

[Save The Dragons]

i'd much rather have had astronomy go too but i'd rather lim someone than no one

[Save The Dragons]

Well, maybe it would have gone through if people weren't throwing out distracting new wagons so close to deadline.

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: Norwee

[Save The Dragons]

still suspicious from yesterday

[Save The Dragons]

scum would have to be pretty ballsy to be like "hey, let's not kill again, right guys?"

[Save The Dragons]

we're gonna no lim again aren't we

[Save The Dragons]

why does scum!uranus kill regrider

[Save The Dragons]

i could do uranus

VOTE: uranus

[Save The Dragons]

where did i say that

[Save The Dragons]

i was more curious what lq's answer would be

[Save The Dragons]

did i vote for your partner?

[Save The Dragons]

are you?

[Save The Dragons]

me either

[Save The Dragons]

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: norwee

[Save The Dragons]

RR are you tring norwee

[Save The Dragons]

Spoiler:

[Save The Dragons]

haha funny joke

[Save The Dragons]

salsa was scummy and you haven't made me think you're town

asking about a rr wagon is scummy as hell RR is pretty town and you're just fishing for wagons

[Save The Dragons]

it's my playstyle. if people want to know they can ask questions

[Save The Dragons]

uranus do you think this comes from town

I'm here and just see the VC. I'm still recovering, don't have energy for catching up yet. Are we agreeing to eliminate

Uranus

here? If so then I'll hammer right away. If not then I've to catch up which I don’t want to atm...

[Save The Dragons]

if you're town i think she was trying to mislim you there
if you're scum i think she was trying to bus you

[Save The Dragons]

my poe is exactly the same

[Save The Dragons]

it's the same people

[Save The Dragons]

:<

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: astronomyfortwo

[Save The Dragons]

i just don't think it's CLS

[Save The Dragons]

that's what i think

[Save The Dragons]

i dunno if it's true

[Save The Dragons]

UNVOTE: for now

[Save The Dragons]

no i missed it

[Save The Dragons]

sorry, other way around, meld of the mind variety

i dunno if it's true

can you talk a bit more abt your doubts, std? assuming this is about me being town, you had me at a "scum probably doesn't say this sort of thing" for a while and it's understandable that it isn't exactly reliable. if you're looking for more specific questions, do you find that you're questioning my tone more or my content?

my doubts are about my solve being right in general, i always have doubts but i try to be confident because otherwise i'd never progress the game if i let my doubts take over.

VOTE: Norwee

[Save The Dragons]

STD voting me for no reason is pretty annoying.

hey look here's more

[Save The Dragons]

UNVOTE: for now

Can I ask why you are treating Pavowski differently than Norwee here? You were Scum reading Asto, but now all the sudden you feel Pav has done enough to change your read on them? That doesn't really line up to me.

1. I wanted to give Pav a little bit of time to post i'm still wary of the slot
2. Norwee has gone after the slot pretty hard
3. I'm way more convinced that salsa/norwee is scum than the revolving door slot is

[Save The Dragons]

my activity level is NAI it was because i was playing an LSG

[Save The Dragons]

i still think norwee is scum

same

[Save The Dragons]

well this game's over lol

who got jk'd

[Save The Dragons]

happy birthday!

[Save The Dragons]

they could have held for the lolz, but i'm not sure it could be a save

[Save The Dragons]

i don't think it's uranus/strangematter due to the offer to hammer

[Save The Dragons]

i don't think it's kenny either for the way she went after him

[Save The Dragons]

i don't think it's uranus/strangematter due to the offer to hammer

i don't think it's kenny either for the way she went after him

Who do you think it is then?

Pavowski

[Save The Dragons]

i don't think it's uranus/strangematter due to the offer to hammer

i don't think it's kenny either for the way she went after him

Who do you think it is then?

Pavowski

Why? The main point against Astro was just the lurking, wasn't it?

i got scummy vibes from astronomyfortwo when they did post

[Save The Dragons]

hmm

[Save The Dragons]

@Mod: V/LA 9/15-9/20

[Save The Dragons]

I still exist

I still think Kenny is town but I'm willing to be wrong if I'm wrong

[Save The Dragons]

Nah go for it

[Save The Dragons]

mod your vote count is incorrect in terms of who's alive

[Save The Dragons]

thanks for the game!