Newbie 1463--Game Over!

[Purple Bananaa]

UNVOTE: Hannah26

VOTE: notscience

I guess the more notscience speaks the more he looks scum. It does seem as well that more people suspect him than any one else.

[Guyett]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: notscience

[notscience]

Shocker.

[Guyett]

[penguin_alien]

Final Day Three Vote Count 3.09:

With six alive, it takes four to lynch!

Hannah26 (L-4):
Purple Bananaa (L-4):
Majiffy (L-4):
notscience (L-0): Hannah26, Bulbazak, Purple Bananaa, Guyett
Guyett (L-3): notscience
Bulbazak (L-4):

Not voting: Majiffy

V/LA:

Deadline in (expired on 2014-02-15 14:06:42)

Flip incoming...

[penguin_alien]

Day Three Lynch Flavor:

The pressure to find a Roman mounted. Groups coalesced and disintegrated as time marched on. With the sun nearing the horizon, a decisive shift in momentum put the noose on notscience. Not science, not Sicilian, it's close enough, right?

...apparently not.

notscience,

Vanilla Townie

, was lynched Day Three!

Night Three begins now. All actions are due in (expired on 2014-02-12 19:06:48)

[penguin_alien]

Night Three Flavor:

The surviving Italians had only just retreated into their homes when a shot rang out in the night. Back out on the street, a body lay sprawled across the threshold of a house.

In the light of the moon, two figures remained with guns. Squaring off against the two defenseless Sicilians, the massacre was total.

Sicily has fallen to Rome...

Bulbazak,

Vanilla Townie

, was killed Night Three!

Purple Bananaa,

Town Cop

, was endgamed Day Four!
Majiffy,

Vanilla Townie

, was endgamed Day Four!

Hannah26,

Mafia Goon

, and Guyett,

Mafia Roleblocker

, have won the game!

Mafia QT
Dead QT

Night actions:

Night One:

Aloke protects Bulbazak (successful)
Purple Bananaa investigates Bulbazak (successful; result: Not Mafia)

No actions submitted from the Mafia

Night Two:

Aloke protects Purple Bananaa (successful)
Purple Bananaa investigates Hannah26 (fails due to roleblock)

Guyett kills Aloke (successful)
Guyett roleblocks Purple Bananaa (successful)


Night Three:

Purple Bananaa's investigation is a moot point

Guyett kills Bulbazak (successful)

[Guyett]

Forgot to submit night actions N1 but we were going to kill bulba anyway I think

[Bulbazak]

Good game. I went back through everyone's ISOs, and I still couldn't see Hannah-scum. The only thing I caught was a relational tell between her and Guyett (when Guyett quickly backtracked in regards to her meta and experience), but that was not enough to convince me she was scum over NS. I'll try to get some final thoughts ready soonish.

[Guyett]

Dont think I said anything about meta on her? I have meta on pb which I discarded start of D2 to push his lynch

[notscience]

>.> I did what I could to try and avert the wagon

[Majiffy]

Lesson learned: Always trust the JiffyStinct

^TM

in LYLO.

[Bulbazak]

Dont think I said anything about meta on her? I have meta on pb which I discarded start of D2 to push his lynch

Yeah, it was the PB meta that you backtracked on. You did comment on Hannah, and it was the only possible link I saw between you two. However, it really wasn't much and didn't leap out to me as a scum connection.

Hannah is a little harder to read as her scum game is similar to her town game.

[Guyett]

And that meta on her is true, she plays similarly as town and scum

[Purple Bananaa]

Even if we did lynch Hannah instead of NS we probably wouldn't have lynched Guyett. They played a good game.

[Hannah26]

What's an ISO btw??

I quite enjoyed that, didn't think I played too bad for a newbie but some feedback would be nice...

[Guyett]

an iso is all of your posts together, you can see it beside the #540 in your last post. FF.net should have that feature imo.
you played quite well... Bulba's a pretty good scum hunter and to get a town read from him as scum is impressive for your first game. I think the only you were getting caught was by process of elimination.

[Majiffy]

Even if we did lynch Hannah instead of NS we probably wouldn't have lynched Guyett. They played a good game.

Well, if NS is scum, he's scum with [Guyett].

E.G. I would have kicked and screamed against an NS lynch with a Hannah scumflip

[cxinlee]

Damn majiffy flipping town was a big shocker.

[notscience]

Majiffy you had Guyett as a more likely scumread why didn't you help me lynch him ;-;

[Majiffy]

Preferred Hannah first.

Why were you so sticky with your vote? I was confirmed town by the end there.

[notscience]

Because in a 1v1 with me and hannah I still didn't think she was scum

[Hannah26]

Really who did you think was then?? Guyett and Jiffy??

[Bulbazak]

Okay, I'm going to start with the SEs.

Majiffy: You were pretty obv. town, although I did get paranoid about you at a few points. I think my biggest criticism of your play is that you were not proactive. I can understand why you were not playing according to your usual aggressive playstyle, but that doesn't mean that you should be passive. When you did sink your teeth into something, it ended up being something of little consequence, such as whether we should mass claim. You were able to talk sense into me at the end, but if you were a little more forceful with your reads, maybe you wouldn't have had to.

Notscience: You did replace into a slot that wasn't the best as far as pro-town motivated behavior. But what you don't do upon replacing into such a slot is double down on such behavior. Bankai fell into too scummy to be scum territory, and you continued that trend, which is what ended up getting you lynched. Instead of trying to WIFOM the town to death, why don't you just hit the ground running in regards to scumhunting next time and don't comment on your predecessor.

Guyett: You did a good job this game. There were a few associative tells, but really nothing that pointed to you as scum. You made some smart plays, and you worked with the stronger town at the right moments, which made it seem as if you were inquisitive and willing to consider all angles when scumhunting. If it wasn't for PoE, I'd never have ended up on you.

Now for the newer players.

Hannah26: You played a good game. I really couldn't see you being scum. You might want to scumhunt a little more, but otherwise, you did a good job.

Aloke: You are a very competent scum hunter. My only criticism is that you protected way too many people. Instead of being everyone's guardian angel, just push your scum reads a little more forcefully. I understand that there will be times when you'll want to let it be known that you have a townread on somebody, but only do that for your strongest townreads. Leave the nulls be, and above all, push for scum lynches first and foremost.

LightOfAngel: You were very survivalistic this game, and that's what ended up getting you killed. Worry less about people who may be wanting you dead or reading you as scum, and focus more on finding scum yourself. If you do this, people will end up coming to the conclusion that you're town all on their own.

Cxinlee: Participate. If you don't put yourself out there and are proactive, you will always get lynched.

Purple Bananaa: You are a pretty good scumhunter. Continue working on this in future games. And may I advise making that purple banana picture on page 1 your avatar?

[Majiffy]

Majiffy: You were pretty obv. town, although I did get paranoid about you at a few points. I think my biggest criticism of your play is that you were not proactive. I can understand why you were not playing according to your usual aggressive playstyle, but that doesn't mean that you should be passive. When you did sink your teeth into something, it ended up being something of little consequence, such as whether we should mass claim. You were able to talk sense into me at the end, but if you were a little more forceful with your reads, maybe you wouldn't have had to.

I have a massive issue being as aggressive as I usually am in newbies due to the nature of the game, so I understand. I should definitely work on it; but I wouldn't expect any serious results until the next year or so. You know where to find me, elsewhere.