Newbie 1769: Happy New Year! (Post-Game)

[gigabyteTroubadour]

rc i swear to god if i'm just having a really fucking awful game and 921 was actually a town post i really hate you right now

if you're scum you're fine and i still like you but????????????

[Raskolnikov]

If there's a counterclaim to GBT they should claim now.

UNVOTE:

Is this rolefishing?

[gigabyteTroubadour]

can we stop fucking talking about it oh my fucking god

[gigabyteTroubadour]

Code: Select all

[img]http://i.imgur.com/nBDesE7.jpg[/img]

^also bbcode for schadd_ since i'm like 100% he'd use this reaction picture too

[RadiantCowbells]

I mean you could call it that but GBT is just a scumlord anyway.

[Raskolnikov]

Is there any particular reason you voted cass rather than GBT?

[Raskolnikov]

Or just because she already had a vote on?

[RadiantCowbells]

Because Cass is 100% scum whereas GBT is like 85% scum.

The question you should be asking is why GBT voted Cass when she thinks that scum is both of us and I already had a vote on me.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

creature beat me to the pedit and i didn't feel like changing my vote

[Raskolnikov]

An interesting story.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

do you think it's significant?

[Raskolnikov]

GBT is like 85% scum.

And what is the remaining 15% ?

[RadiantCowbells]

What if scum didn't shoot Raskol but instead shot their PR read and they were 1-Shot BP?
Then GBT would be free to bus without worrying about a confirmed clear, and I'm pretty sure she would expect to be able to win the 1v1 citing my bussing meta and probably not get lynched after me.

My issue rn is that I don't see why scum Gigabyte busses in this situation rather than search out the PR if they targeted Raskol like they should have.

[RadiantCowbells]

GBT is like 85% scum.

And what is the remaining 15% ?

Creature > Grey > MattBlack.

[Raskolnikov]

What if scum didn't shoot Raskol but instead shot their PR read and they were 1-Shot BP?
Then GBT would be free to bus without worrying about a confirmed clear, and I'm pretty sure she would expect to be able to win the 1v1 citing my bussing meta and probably not get lynched after me.

My issue rn is that I don't see why scum Gigabyte busses in this situation rather than search out the PR if they targeted Raskol like they should have.

No one respond to this theory.

[Raskolnikov]

You feel awfully rolefishy today.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

My issue rn is that I don't see why scum Gigabyte busses in this situation rather than search out the PR if they targeted Raskol like they should have.

OK, so if you agree the optimal play is to shoot raskol is, then what the fuck is 921?

there was no shot of you getting nk'd, i don't think anyone on the TB wagon would have hammered schadd_, so???

it was a really fucking pointless hammer and when i saw it i assumed your next step would be to hardbus cassie, chain an easy ml on me, and then get a pretty easy 3-way

GBT is like 85% scum.

And what is the remaining 15% ?

Creature > Grey > MattBlack.

creature is obvious fucking town fuck off with that shit

[RadiantCowbells]

OK, so if you agree the optimal play is to shoot raskol is, then what the fuck is 921?

there was no shot of you getting nk'd, i don't think anyone on the TB wagon would have hammered schadd_, so???

it was a really fucking pointless hammer and when i saw it i assumed your next step would be to hardbus cassie, chain an easy ml on me, and then get a pretty easy 3-way

I thought ThinkBig was reasonably likely to be scum and I didn't want to risk you switching over.
I wouldn't have been surprised if I had been shot but I am pretty fucking sure that no doc would have saved me over Raskol.

You feel awfully rolefishy today.

I am trying to solve the game and solving the game means figuring out what scum and PRs did last night.
If GBT is PR they should claim because otherwise I'm lynching them today. Everyone else can stay quiet.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

Get me to L-1 and we'll talk.

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: GBT

That's one.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

I thought ThinkBig was reasonably likely to be scum and I didn't want to risk you switching over.

i townread schadd_ but ok

VOTE: GBT

That's one.

[RadiantCowbells]

i townread schadd_ but ok

After the bullshit I've seen I wouldn't be surprised if you got away with it anyway. Especially in a town where people managed to get 4 votes onto Schad ????

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Cassielle

Ehh I think that GBT is still more likely to be town than Cass. If Raskol dies tonight I'll reevaluate but I don't think that Cass/GBT are scumbuddies atm.

[Raskolnikov]

I don't think that Cass/GBT are scumbuddies atm.

Really?

[cassielle]

wow interesting to come back to. twice. first: wake up in the morning, someone hammered a lynch without intent or anything and ended the day before i could even get to meet them. and then today, im the fashionable scumread.

i find it weird absolutely no one has questioned gbT or Radiant's scumread of me? but ok

ill claim now because if its sheeptime again then i doubt anyone will give me the chance to do it at the usual point in time, not that it matters because im a safe lynch if yall really want to mylo or something

Vanilla Townie

regarding this gamestate at this point in time:

i still stand by short days being worse for town, even though apparently thats not a widely held view. you can put that on my grave if i get MLed for this mess. radiant's talk about everyone getting 24 hrs then hammering 20 minutes later is anti-town all by itself imo tho, so i think my point will get across. really weird swing from shade's slot though, must be how people felt about me replacing rakkar

i still think schadd_ did not address anyones concerns and that i really, really want to hear more from him soon on them. regardless of radiant's read of him.

i stand by my rask read (i.e., superscum). the others im mostly tossing out because of tb flipping town (weakened schadd_ read somewhat) and the lack of nk, something is weird and idk what it is precisely. my reads were crap (though tb looked p undeniably like scum) from start to finish and i need to review the topic.

right now i have two reads. creature (town) and rask (scum). its gonna take awhile for me to get a reasonable readslist together. this game is bizarre.

p-edit: radiant is reading stronger and stronger scum before i even review the topic, just from 957 onward. not so much 957 itself (i dont scumread people for scumreading me, its poor play imo) but in conjunction with what happens after it and the completely incomprehensible creature scumread.