Title Fairy: Abuse of Mooglepower!

[TheButtonmen]

[Party Pooper] Theses titles all suck, Vi's was the best of the lot but now you guys are just running it into the ground. [/Party Pooper]

@RC:

How many games have they been N1 killed in? I like the look of it but I'm not getting the reference.

[TheButtonmen]

I don't really play mafia, but the two things that really stick out about Dram are 7.5 inches and stalking his boyfriend into turning gay
Don't see that relating to hornithologist

Maybe a play on cult recruiting could work?

Something about the Homosexual Agenda?

[TheButtonmen]

Hey guys remember the whole stop suggesting shit titles conversation?

Are we going for a record number of title fairy thread shutdowns, 'cause I'm down for that and will gladly pitch in if that's the goal.

[TheButtonmen]

Nominate chesskid3

for

Princeton

Because I have no idea if it's true or not. But I find it absolutely hilarious and I want it to be true. I want him to have the title to remind everyone that a Princeton student wrote whatever dumb/stupid/trollish post was just made.

Although making fun of Princeton in this manner is funny I don't approve of rewarding Chesskid's bad play.

Titles were given for "bad" play all the time.

[TheButtonmen]

Or to be Title Fairy.

[TheButtonmen]

if chesskid gets a title I might as well leave this site forever because THAT'S PATHETIC.

WE DON'T GIVE NOTORIOUS VIs TITLES THAT REWARD BAD PLAY. THAT JUST MAKES THEM EVEN WORSE.

We don't?

When did this change?

[TheButtonmen]

He's a troll though.

He wishs.

[TheButtonmen]

Ah look how cute that Izzy brought in her friends from scum-chat to support that title

Oh Christ! The people who were involved in the events leading up to the title are here discussing it.

Oh ta noes.

If UT can't get this title as it was given for reasons that occurred mainly in scumchat, Scumchat LoLapoloza and Scumradio then we need to strip a bunch of previously given titles.

[TheButtonmen]

actually, please let me know about all these titles floating around, because that's bullshit too

Did you notice the post two ahead of yours where ReaperCharlie points out 4 such titles?

Again - you personal feelings on this matter aren't really relevant. Sorry that you disagree with Oman and (insofar as I can tell) the administrations stance on the Title Fairy process.

So either take it up with Mith or stop whining.

Dear lord how dare he have the audacity to publicly state his dislike about how this thread has been going and the change over the years in what exactly the driving idea behind the title fairy was.

You're just as annoying as him but he at least is bitching about topical stuff where as you're just just bitching.

@Oman:

I think you need to do a public / loud refresher course on what exactly you think this thread is and how it should work, the endless bitching about what is a good title / venting of every slight has surpassed people spitballin' about titles and has now (imo) pretty much just de-railed any good that could come out of this thread. What was a fun diversion and community building thread is now srs business (and that just sucks).

[TheButtonmen]

Oh, and for the record, if ReaperCharlie gets a title, especially one that has to do with

fucking unicorns

, I'm going to change my account password and forget it.

Well I have a new mission.

[TheButtonmen]

He just doesn't want to pass out non-mafia titles, because when you give UT Fat and Sassy, soon enough you'll be giving someone like ReaperCharlie a unicorn-themed title.

Did you miss the part where we talked about other non-mafia titles, or are you just choosing to ignore it?

He ignores everything that doesn't support what he wants and just gets more and more indigent as time goes on.

[TheButtonmen]

He just doesn't want to pass out non-mafia titles, because when you give UT Fat and Sassy, soon enough you'll be giving someone like ReaperCharlie a unicorn-themed title.

Did you miss the part where we talked about other non-mafia titles, or are you just choosing to ignore it?

He ignores everything that doesn't support what he wants and just gets more and more indigent as time goes on.

Well, now you're just showing that you know absolutely fuck-all about me.

No, UT, I haven't ignored it, but I'm clearly showing support for the fact that mafia titles on a mafia site makes sense. People in the past have gotten titles for non-mafia related features, but that is such a low minority that it's not even worth bringing that up as a type of argument because such a low number of people have gotten titles for those kinds of features. It's not a good sample size and it's not worth talking about. Oman talked with mith and clearly agreed with the set of rules that he abides by now and it's not anal or nazi-like in the least; it's worked for a long time. 99.9% of titles on MS are about mafia games. It's just not worth arguing that we should expand that .1% just because of an off-site joke. This wasn't a problem before, so why is it a problem now?

TBM, this means that I agree with the tradition. I don't care about what I want, it's about what suites the site better and I'm only showing support for the person who was appointed the person as a title distributor by the people who, you know, run the site.

EDIT: My point is that just because that the VERY occasional person in the past has gotten a non-mafia related title doesn't make Oman obligated to give them out like hot cakes, or at all, for that matter.

....99.9%?

Have you ever looked at the list of titles in the wiki; Here is the break down for users with names starting with A to J (I got bored and already made my point by then)

A: 12

7/12 Not Mafia

B: 10

6/10 Not Mafia

C: 20

14 / 20 Not Mafia

D: 13

9 / 13 Not Mafia

E: 6

4 / 6 Not Mafia

F: 9

4/ 9 Not Mafia

G: 4

2/4

H: 5

3/5 Not Mafia

I: 6

2/6 Not Mafia

J: 7

4/7 Not Mafia


So A) It's not 99.9% about mafia, B) It's not even 50% about mafia.

[TheButtonmen]

i have an idea

lets lock this thread

It's fine as is. I'm not really going to say anymore because there isn't anymore to be said, really.

Nominate DH for And Another Thing

...Yes.

If he will accept it I will

2nd

and repeatedly bug Oman on aim about it, this title is perfect.

[TheButtonmen]

My point is that you shouldn't be getting a title for being a "good" mod. I'm fine with that nominated title, because it describes the complete opposite.

How many bloody times have you said you were going to ignore him?

But every time he posts somewhere there you are following him, we get it you're not a fan now please stop or take it to PMs.

[TheButtonmen]

Only a, b, and d are all negative behaviors that shouldn't be rewarded with a title.

Why?

[TheButtonmen]

RC: Why are you so proud of being so...yeah? I mean, lets look at it this way: This is actually a title about how much you ruin everything good. About how we can't have nice things because you shit all over it.

It's really not though, this would be

This. I think just

Bastard.

works fine.

And I would argue against it but

Ah yes, "Bastard"

was the suggested title and it perfectly showcases his disagreement about what constitutes a bastard game.

It's funny, it's mafia related, it's not a pun and it's based off a well known series of events (just look at this thread).

This is pretty much as good a titles as has ever been suggested during your reign as TF imo.

[TheButtonmen]

It helps to make finger quotes when reading "Bastard".

[TheButtonmen]

b) my propensity to not warn people that said games have bastardly elements

d) the way in which I respond to criticism of bastardliness, i.e. denying it exists


you don't see these as douchebaggery at its finest?

What does this have to do with the title thread and why aren't you just taking it up with RC via PM?

[TheButtonmen]

Because. When people were suggesting titles for shotty's horrible playstyle, it was agreed that people shouldn't be rewarded for playing badly. So why should RC be rewarded for modding badly?

A) Titles aren't rewards and B) That was never agreed.

[TheButtonmen]

Nom Fate for

No Bags

Xth

C

apital Punishment

.

[TheButtonmen]

I'd like to go old school and Nth

Chevre's Title

[TheButtonmen]

I've not read any Zoraster games for a while.
If he doesn't play that erratically, has become more reserved and doesn't feel it reflects how he would play now... I think it's right to be removed.

[/banishment]
I've broken my self-exile from the TF thread to say;

It wasn't a matter of reserved / playstyle.

His didn't understand the setup and thought he was a normal scumteam, it was a misunderstanding, it was funny and it's a fun title.

The spirit of a title, not the letters is what matters.

[banishment]

[TheButtonmen]

For the longest time I thought "riposte" was pronounced "ree-poh-zay" ... come to find out no one pronounces it like that. Literally

no one. ._.

just TBM and I.

FTFY.

Though being stuck in a category with TBM is never a good thing when it comes to pronunciation.

[TheButtonmen]

As an alternative for the Creatively (Un)common nom I'm going to toss in

Nom Chevre for Don Quixote.

The crusading, the need to address the worlds wrongs and the pursuit of perfection and purity rather then acceptance of reality fosted on them by society.

[TheButtonmen]

I feel like you're secretly calling Chevre Deluded here, TBM.

Let's be honest LLD, we both know that if I just wanted to insult someone that I'd do it openly and clearly.

Don Quixote had a lot more do it then just the windmills, it's a serious reference that I think suits him well.