The Resistance - Game 1 (GAME OVER)

[shos]

Ok Im here!! Woot!

Lolz
Illbe home in less than 30 minutes

[shos]

Gotta read rules super carefully to undeestand whats going on lol
If theres anyone who has played this before, giving us newbies tips would help!

[shos]

Caucasian yoi should use the countdown tags

I think rejecting would give us more information but webhave a total of 15 options to do that so maybe accepting randomly is ok?

I think accepting for a start is good
If there is a failure then next round we will need to find who the spy is out of the three

[shos]

tbh we now have the high chance on possibly clearing 3 people. I'd rather not do this randomly.

This sounds like scum prep

Spies can also vote success, remember?


Pedit: more info because we can analyze which "random" trio eachonw chose

[shos]

Im oit of the train.
Gonna have to drive soon so no phone 10 mins

I want radja to not be in the 3

[shos]

Zoraster leans town
Do spies have daytalk?

[shos]

Pick zOraster iprobablysuck and someone other than radja

[shos]

I trust zoraster

Also dont pick aronis

[shos]

Driving

[shos]

k I'm home.
Coug had WAAAAY ENOUGH information to make a smart choice, and instead he chose "randomly". I'm sure he is scum


reading up

[shos]

Uh-oh... So ani or Ceph is a spy. I'm inclined to send Ceph over Ani at this point for POE reasons, but those two need to be sorted out.

@shos or IPS: Which of those two and/or me did you think is a spy and why? You rejected; this implies you thought this.

you are the scum. You had enough stuff to think with and chose randomly, and "woah, coincidence!" exactly one was scum.

[shos]

who chooses the trio now?

[shos]

That was really a good team
only radja is scum there
and we need 2 "fail" for this to fail, not 1!

[shos]

Since I was being ninja'd to hell when I was trying to respond...

k I'm home.
Coug had WAAAAY ENOUGH information to make a smart choice, and instead he chose "randomly". I'm sure he is scum

Again, there were no strong oppositions to the top three, and I really did not trust Aronis.

you are the scum. You had enough stuff to think with and chose randomly, and "woah, coincidence!" exactly one was scum.

I had every reason as either alignment to include myself. If I'm scum, then whomever I send along with me is largely irrelevant, so this makes logical sense only in that respect. Not a compelling reason out of you.

I think you're scum, possibly with Cephrir if I did the 50:50 wrong.

including yourself is educated, yes. But the other two? did you read the game at all? Do you honestly have no scumreads, no townreads?

I rejected because I wanted to see more teams suggested by more people. I also wanted more time before our second mission.

hmm.
That actually makes sense.
although that really was a good team.

[shos]

Coug, why did YOU reject?

[shos]

Why did YOU reject that, Ceph?

I rejected it because Radja is a spy IMO

in round 2 they need TWO "failure" for the mission to fail

[shos]

ohhhh crap
I suck lol

hmmn.
then yeah I'd have rejected too if I knew that.

[shos]

i am seeing nothing that tells me the scum aren't aronis/ips/(coug/ani)

so i guess i should play to what i do actually know and send everyone but those four?

I'd prefet ani in the team and radja out. Remember we had two "success" in round 1

[shos]

ugh
Why do people think radja is town? am I missing something?

/newb

[shos]

We have no reason to think ani is scum as far as I can see. We do have reason to think coug is.

[shos]

ugh
Why do people think radja is town? am I missing something?

/newb

I'm trying to be very clear on my reads here.
I don't know how else I can convince you.

I have to say I feel wierd about you by now. thinking.

[shos]

Zoraster, I am starting to doubt you

[shos]

on another note, both IPS and StrangerCoug rejected this team twice, along with Zoraster.

could you three explain your choice?

[shos]

Zoraster, I am starting to doubt you

Why? I rejected precisely the same setup last time, just with ani suggesting himself instead of cephrir suggesting himself.

I'm more interested in the people who switched their votes.

yeah but you did that for information. Did you get some? are you expecting more? do you think we should still be 'info gathering' instead of actually trying to get some successful missions?

[shos]

why did you accept shos?

because I ISOed you and the reason I had for you-scum was meh at best.

[shos]

I already explained

I think Radja is scum.

could you explain why?
I thought so too a few minutes ago

but in general he is being competent, participating and he speaks clearly, as in, not hiding and all. I changed my mind about him. Why do you think he is scum?

[shos]

on another note, both IPS and StrangerCoug rejected this team twice, along with Zoraster.

could you three explain your choice?

Why are you so eager for the team? Is there anything to say that you can't form exactly the same team this round? Except now I get to see which of the two you pick and I don't have to deal with someone from the failed team making the decision to put himself on the team.

Because it has my townreads. You, me, radja as well now (earlier I thought it was 2 needed etc)... This helps me narrow it down 100% imo if it fails, which I think it doesn't.

on another note, both IPS and StrangerCoug rejected this team twice, along with Zoraster.

could you three explain your choice?

I don't like the weakness of your case on me. You said I chose randomly without any regard to reads. The "random" choice you claim I made was made at the very beginning of the round, so in effect, I needed a reason not to include animorpherv1 or Cephrir. Only Aronis suggested anything remotely of the sort, and even then, it was a WIFOM case. I don't understand what you get about this.

you had reasons to include others. and you knowingly chose to go for the random choice from the round start instead.

[shos]

{shos, radja, zoraster} are 100% in my pool. I need to decide the last one

[shos]

1. StrangerCoug - scum
2. animorpherv1
3. Cephrir (in the place of N)
4. shos - town
5. Radja - town
6. Iprobablysuck
7. Aronis - scum? dunno, wierd as hell
8. zoraster - town

ceph and ani are both leaning town on my end. Both can be in, I think. Ani's ISO is okish. I'll ISO ceph

[shos]

you had reasons to include others.

And what, exactly, should have compelled me to accept those reasons?

stop arguing for shits. This is a marathon game and you are currently arguing against my case on you, which makes it legitimate disagreement, and either way that makes no reason to scumread me. your reason is basically omgus.

you are scum.

I'd rather have you take me tbh. I want to win.

First off, there was this ^

Second he keeps saying i'm scum and hasn't exactly said WHY. People who do that are 100% scum in my experience

(explanation for shos who asked me why I thought radja was scum)

I don't see how this is scummy at all.

[shos]

{shos, radja, zoraster} are 100% in my pool. I need to decide the last one

I've read Ceph's ISO. I like that. he has many posts which feel genuine. prefer this to ani, although I think both are town.

send in:
shos, radja, zoraster, cephrir.

[shos]

trust me, DL won't beat me

[shos]

Spoiler: all info so far

Send: StrangerCoug, animorpherv1, Cephrir

Everyone now has (expired on 2016-08-09 12:22:43) to accept or reject this team.

Stranger:

ACCEPT

ani:

ACCEPT

Cephrir:

ACCEPT

shos:

REJECT

Radja:

ACCEPT

IPS:

REJECT

Aronis:

REJECT

zoraster:

ACCEPT

The team has been accepted. SC, ani, and Ceph have (expired on 2016-08-09 12:27:35) to pass or fail the mission.

The success/failure submissions are shown below, randomized.

SUCCESS

FAILURE

SUCCESS

The spies have claimed the first base, putting them in the lead 1-0. Animorpherv1 is the next team leader, and has (expired on 2016-08-09 12:42:17) to propose a team.

SEND: ME/ZOR/SHOS/RADIA

Everyone has (expired on 2016-08-09 12:41:50) to accept or reject this team.

Stranger:

REJECT

ani:

ACCEPT

Cephrir:

REJECT

shos:

ACCEPT

Radja:

ACCEPT

IPS:

REJECT

Aronis:

ACCEPT

zoraster:

REJECT

The proposed team is rejected. Cephrir now has (expired on 2016-08-09 12:56:43) to propose a team.

nah, i'm not doing that, vote as you will but i want a damn win

Send: me, shos, zor, radja

(expired on 2016-08-09 12:57:04)

Stranger:

REJECT

ani:

ACCEPT

Cephrir:

ACCEPT

shos:

ACCEPT

Radja:

ACCEPT

IPS:

REJECT

Aronis:

REJECT

zoraster:

REJECT

The proposed team is rejected. shos now has (expired on 2016-08-09 13:10:20) to propose a team.

{shos, radja, zoraster} are 100% in my pool. I need to decide the last one

I've read Ceph's ISO. I like that. he has many posts which feel genuine. prefer this to ani, although I think both are town.

send in:
shos, radja, zoraster, cephrir.

(expired on 2016-08-09 13:14:00)

Stranger:

REJECT

ani:

ACCEPT

Cephrir:

ACCEPT

shos:

ACCEPT

Radja:

ACCEPT

IPS:

REJECT

Aronis:

REJECT

zoraster:

ACCEPT

Everyone on the team has (expired on 2016-08-09 13:16:38) to accept or reject.

The success/failure submissions are shown below, randomized.

FAILURE

SUCCESS

SUCCESS

SUCCESS

The spies have claimed the second base, meaning the resistance now needs to win all remaining missions. Radja is the next team leader, and has (expired on 2016-08-09 13:30:17) to propose a team. Choose wisely.

[shos]

Can scum talk to each other?

if not, we can assume that all scum send "fail" if they are in the team?

which means at least one of {aronis, iprobablysuck} is scum, since they weren't on both teams.
if ceph is scum, that means both of them are scum.

if ceph is town, we have a big problem

[shos]

Zoraster voted against in the first time this team was offered. if it had scum, and he had been scum, he would have known that and just supported it then.

Zoraster is now officially conftown, I think.

[shos]

if ceph is scum, then we assume {aronis. ceph iprobablysuck} is the team.

I kinda thinks that is unlikely. Entropy-wise, lol

we have so many other options in all of which ceph is town. I can mark him as town.


any team should from now on include ceph and Zoraster, in my opinion

[shos]

on D1 there was only one FAIL. scumcoug would want ONLY 1 scum in the team, because he can't know if BOTH go fail and then it is much info for town.

Therefore I think the scum in the first round is coug (together with his basless omgus on me the entire game).

which makes ceph and ani town, which agrees with my previous analysis of ceph.


{ani, ceph, zor} town on my end

[shos]

shos outed himself as Resistance

??????????

yeah I have no idea what he's talking about lol
a moment ago he was 150% against me

[shos]

who chooses this time?

please make sure {ani, ceph, zor} is in your team.


Aronis has done nothing the entire game. I'm reaaaaally happy marking him as scum/not on the "team"

[shos]

phew
that was stressing

radja, you rejected yourself?

on my logic, if zor is town and ani is town, that makes radja scum
but I'm not sure as HELL. zor, help me

[shos]

probably cold feet
but that would suggest him being town

then who the fuck is scum on the round where I chose the team?

[shos]

so radja is if nothing else playing anti town here, I guess

lol this guy is so scum

[shos]

Aronis, IPS and someone who has just been nominated is scum.

who the fuck is that.



I am officially deleting all my reads and putting radja as town.

if both IPS and aronis are scum
it suggests ceph is too

but then why would they all support??

[shos]

shos, radja, zoraster, cephrir.
have 1 scum
StrangerCoug, animorpherv1, Cephrir

same

Aronis is probscum too

Aronis/ani/???


could it be zor? he has experience in this game, his reject/reject/support may have been planned

[shos]

yeah I think this has to be it

Zor is a scummy mcscum of experienceland
and his partners are anim and Aronis

[shos]

I know I'm going against the flow
but it is the only thing that makes fucking sense

Cephscum along with aronis and IPS is another option though...but then why did round 1 both rejected despite ceph being there?

[shos]

Zoraster who do you think the scum are?
I think you are.

[shos]

HURT: Zoraster
lol

Zor is scum with Ani and aronis.
that is my decision

[shos]

radja is just about as town as can be.

he would NEVER get ANY flak from accepting his own submission. and he still rejected. that means he submitted, then thought about it more and decided he was wrong. radja is town.

[shos]

rejecting this one too

[shos]

SC isn't scum

[shos]

well im on board with coug scum so i guess i'[m probably going to accept anything zor proposes

what
no

[shos]

well im on board with coug scum so i guess i'[m probably going to accept anything zor proposes

what
no

[shos]

okay.

SC-shos-Radja-Ceph?

Would you go for that Coug?

this is all town, yes.

[shos]

ANI and ZOR and ARONIS

are scum

[shos]

we can't have FIVE in a row
we can have two.

still this is best:

SC-shos-Radja-Ceph?



note that zor stopped reacting to me and radja? that's cuz he's caught

[shos]

OK. good.

Townies are:

1. StrangerCoug
3. Cephrir
4. shos
5. Radja
6. Iprobablysuck

let's get this done.

[shos]

note that ALL townies have to vote accept this time, because if we reject the offer game is over.

[shos]

Well, if SC is scum the game is over.

is true
but he's town.

i like zor's team best but i'm not 100% on it

Ceph, if you are town you have to accept today no matter what. so game is pretty much solved anyway. zor is scum, you'll see

[shos]

So my name is clear or the game would have automatically been called.

I'm thinking of doing it Radja's way right now.

voting no to your proposal?????

why would scum do that?

they would get 0 flak for supporting their own.
and they'd get another base.

[shos]

lol aronis
you have to put more effort to games in the future

[shos]

WP ceph, damn it!

[shos]

Aronis, you don't deserve this

[shos]

the funny thing is that if both had failed it, the game would have been pretty easy. but since only one did...

who was the person who voted succeed in Day 1?

definitely.

this game was brilliant, I loved it! will play again!

[shos]

thanks everyone, for a fun first resistance game
I am surprised I managed to even actually get in time to play lol

[shos]

I like the marathon version of this more than standard, honestly.

I'd give more than 15 minutes though. maybe 30 would be perfect.

[shos]

They definitely outplayed us. I kinda played on statistics when I called ceph town of the options at the time and all. Aronis, I didn't mean to make you feel bad, it was more of a whine about LOL BUT I TRIEDDDD. My first game, I have <NO> idea what I'd have done as scum. I enjoyed playing, very much!