Thestatusquo's Mini Normal Review, April 2023 (Released)

[mastina]

Seconding what Datisi said.

[mastina]

You could maybe split the difference and have neighbors with one as a friendly neighbor if you wanna go down that route.

[mastina]

One, but not both, of those probably works, but Datisi is the primary so you'll need Datisi's feedback there.

[mastina]

Indecisive (not same target twice) or if that's still too strong, nonconsecutive are also alignment-neutral options!

[mastina]

Oh, technically, doctors only protect against a single kill in Normals. (It’s a stupid rule imo, they are legitimately the only Normal protective role which doesn’t protect against all kills outside of MAYBE bodyguard, I have always been in opposition to that rule, but it IS the rule right now regardless of how stupid it is imo.)

So, should be changed to specify only protects against one kill per night to meet the Normal standards.

Also, are there result PMs?

[mastina]

i've modded like 10+ normal games and i've had to do it in almost every review, so

It is a requirement, because we've had mods who didn’t show reviewers their intended results PMs who then went on to send results PMs violating Normal Game standards.

[mastina]

the friendly neighbour pm needs to explicitly say that the player is receiving the pm becuase of a friendly neighbour.

the rolecop results are fine, though i think it's generally written as "player is a [role]" rather than "player is [role]" for everything other than vanilla. but if mastina's fine with this, i think it's ok

Yeah I'm not too perturbed by it, it's good enough.