Scummies 2009 Nominations

[Vi]

I want to nominate Jahudo for

Most Enjoyable Game

(Mini [theme/normal]) for Mini 783 Cowboy Bebop Mafia

Second

[Vi]

I want to nominate Jahudo for

Most Enjoyable Game

(Mini [theme/normal]) for Mini 783 Cowboy Bebop Mafia

Second

Third

that game was fun and well thought out setup wise.

Happy scumday Vi

Fourthed

and such. Not necessarily for the setup, but it was very enjoyable for a number of other factors.

Jahudo recruited eleven of the twelve players, so he deserves credit for that.

@Shanba: Thank you!

[Vi]

One idea that I have as an award is

most unpredictable player

What do u guys think?

This needs to be rewarded?

[Vi]

One idea that I have as an award is

most unpredictable player

What do u guys think?

This needs to be rewarded?

Maybe there should be a

Most Predictable Player

or

Most Consistent

award.

Again, this needs to be rewarded?
Consistent transparency is only a good thing if you're Town, after all.

I'm against meta-based awards in general.

[Vi]

Oh right, before I forget.

Nominate Benmage for Best Performance in a Losing Cause

in Battle Mafia.

Benmage's role: Godfather with a debilitating post restriction
How we viewed Benmage: Vig who nailed scum three times consecutively with the most awesome post restriction ever who only got caught by the game getting locked down by Town

[Vi]

"Smooth Operator" - for the "moderation" part of modding: vote counts, prodding, generally keeping the game running smoothly

?

[Vi]

(See: Suzumiya Haruhi Mafia, TRADTiMM... both were designed as Best New Role bait, among other things.)

Having a bunch of unique roles makes it difficult for any one in particular to stand out.

[Vi]

Nominate Tar for Best Mechanic

for the Ultimate/Remuneration mechanic in Legacy of the Ancients

Fourthe

oh wait.

[Vi]

The Scummies Planning team will be updating the nomination list soon to reflect these changes. We've got a little more time this year, but expect nominations to close sometime in January.

EDIT: Don't forget - nominations that aren't thirded aren't judged!

[Vi]

Don't forget - nominations that aren't thirded aren't judged!

Are you serious? Where is this mentioned?

I'm pretty sure that's the implication of "we don't pay attention to fourthing, fifthing, or Nthing of nominations".

[Vi]

Don't forget - nominations that aren't thirded aren't judged!

Are you serious? Where is this mentioned?

I'm pretty sure that's the implication of "we don't pay attention to fourthing, fifthing, or Nthing of nominations".

Oh, that's not how I read that at all. In previous years there have been fifths, sixths, sevenths, which just spam up the thread. Mith's point is that it doesn't add anything to the nomination to have those vocal supports.

If he's said that thirds are required or the Scummy Planning Team has decided something else, that's cool.

*shrug* When in doubt, assume I don't know what I'm talking about.

[Vi]

mmm... But that means that some players will advertise themselves to get these things? lame.

I didn't know this was a popularity contest after all...

Advertising yourself is in poor taste, but sometimes it's better to do that if you believe you deserve a nomination that nobody has thought of. [size=0]*kisses that one goodbye*[/size]

[Vi]

Thanks, but I was already nominated for Professor Mafia for something else.

Nominate Vi for Professor Mafia

This combination warrants a *hug*

[Vi]

Do you really have to win every single award, Vi?

YES

Just because I'm nominated for an award doesn't mean I'll get it. I usually don't

[Vi]

*pokes Vi*

Hmm...perhaps if i continue doing this I'll obsorb her good townieness...

*continues poking Vi*

I didn't know this was facebook

*pokes back*

So you're essentially the Martin Scorcese of MS.

Well, we don't know if that carries over to MS yet. But we're going to find out...

[Vi]

There's a difference between getting your foot in the door and bandwagoning...