Scummies 2009 Nominations

[VP Baltar]

Nominate SpyreX for Most Improved Player

Seconded

When I first joined the site, I read Mini 672-Tranquility with Spyrex and he seemed very erratic and easily angered. I recently completed Open 122 with him and his play was significantly improved, imo. He replaced in and the town was in shambles. Despite some very scummy looking town players who were antagonistic toward him, he and Camn (who also replaced late) helped turn a sinking ship around and we lynched scum three nights in a row for the win.

Actually, I would also

nominate Camn for best individual performance (Town)

for that game as well. Her boldly claiming JK put the scum in a scramble and was certainly a defining moment in the town victory.

[VP Baltar]

I want to nominate Jahudo for

Most Enjoyable Game

(Mini [theme/normal]) for Mini 783 Cowboy Bebop Mafia

Second

Third

that game was fun and well thought out setup wise.

Happy scumday Vi

Fourthed

and such. Not necessarily for the setup, but it was very enjoyable for a number of other factors.

[VP Baltar]

I'd like to nominate Porkens for Most Enjoyable Game (mini) and Best Flavour Text for Mini 819 - WWF Royal Rumble Mafia. The game was great fun and the classic WWF commentary was hilarious.

Seconded

for Most Enjoyable Game. Even though I was killed on N1, I read the whole game and Porkens definitely deserves praise for his (successful) experiment in restricting post length.

[VP Baltar]

I agree with Empking for once. I view the award as being reserved for someone who is inherently in a bad situation and almost made a comeback, not to someone who started off well and the team still managed to lose.

[VP Baltar]

Or it might encourage mod's to actually start thinking outside of the box and come up with third party roles that are actually balanced a bit. *cough*Vi Pod*cough*

[VP Baltar]

Clearly I am blind.

Second Vi for Best Role

[VP Baltar]

I don't have any awesome corrections for you, but just wanted to say thanks for working so hard Kublai. You da man!

[VP Baltar]

It's also not cool to nominate yourself for a scummy...

^This

[VP Baltar]

Yeah, I was moreso referring to the original nom.

[VP Baltar]

Nominate Quagmire for GD award

Admit it. You enjoy the controversy he so readily provides.

Not really. He posts a lot of drivel that's not interesting or funny in any sort of way. I don't think being jackass should be encouraged.

[VP Baltar]

Nominate Incognito for Bestest IC, for his performance in NG700, NG775 and NG798.

Third Incognito as Best IC

[VP Baltar]

Do you really have to win every single award, Vi? Give folks a chance.

Second Vi for Professor Mafia

[VP Baltar]

Do you really have to win every single award, Vi?

YES

Just because I'm nominated for an award doesn't mean I'll get it. I usually don't

So you're essentially the Martin Scorcese of MS. I told you to stop putting "Gimme Shelter" references in all of your games if you want people to start taking you seriously.

[VP Baltar]

second/third whatever tar is being nommed for

Let's not do things like this. Nomming should be based on legitimate appreciation. I'm not saying whether or not Tar deserves it (and I'm sure he does), but you should have at least familiarized yourself with the material and feel that it actually contributed to the betterment of the site in the appropriate way.