Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic Mafia (Game Over)

[MonkeyMan576]

I will be posting content later tonight. As I said, I am busy at the moment.

[Antihero]

Then maybe you should eliminate the soundness of the premise by posting content.


VOTE: ABR

oh yeah? why?

that's not really talking about Neil parroting Mhork. I take it you still think he's scum?

Still ok with killing Monkey,

i'm a big picture guy, nero. in large games, there's usually about 3-4 conversations going on a time so ignoring something isn't necessarily bad by itself

FYI: the case on monkey has nothing to do with lack of "content"

[TiphaineDeath]

Where did that abr vote come from?

[Albert B. Rampage]

You saw that too, didn't you?

[Lord Mhork]

Can you explain the inconsistency for me here, monkey?

I will be reading through later tonight, but ArcAngel's PL crap is very annoying. No one has ever accused her of being the greatest player in mafia history.

I'm not going to get drawn into your ate game, AA9.

I said policy lynches are anti-town, and your comments suggested a pro-policy lynch stance.

And I said policy lynching is annoying, not you specifically. So no, I didn't call anyone any names.

[MonkeyMan576]

First round of reads, may not be able to finish everyone tonight.

Action Dan:
Voted ArcAngel and td with little explanation. Very light content.
Read: Slight Scum



Aegor:
Fairly active, but comes of as somewhat defensive. Says that Neil doesn't deserve a vote then votes him 7 posts later.
Read: Slight scum


Albert B Rampage:
Very soft spoken, seems to be avoiding content/confrontation. Could be scum or a town power role.
Read: Neutral

Antihero:
Very active/agressive. Like his scumhunting.
Read: Town

ArcAngel9:
Tries to provoke people to get reads, which is annoying, but admittingly effective. Doesn't know her own biases though.
Read: Slight town

Aronis:
Active, yet logical. A good combination for scumhunting if he is town. Hasn't posted a lot recently though.
Read: Neutral

[MonkeyMan576]

Can you explain the inconsistency for me here, monkey?

I will be reading through later tonight, but ArcAngel's PL crap is very annoying. No one has ever accused her of being the greatest player in mafia history.

I'm not going to get drawn into your ate game, AA9.

I said policy lynches are anti-town, and your comments suggested a pro-policy lynch stance.

And I said policy lynching is annoying, not you specifically. So no, I didn't call anyone any names.

Yeah, when I posted the PL statement, I was over-concentrating on AA9 rather than looking at the bigger picture. Hey, even I make mistakes.

[MonkeyMan576]

Cephrir:
Interacting with a lot of different people, probably trying to get reads.
Read: Town

Farside:
Active and logical, as usual. Haven't played with her as scum though.
Read: Town

Kdub:
Mod.

Lord God:
Only one post, but at least he's not afraid to confront AA9.
Read: Neutral

Lord Mhork:
Not terribly active, but his posts have good content. Willing to look at meta.
Read: Leaning town.

Mastin:
Only one post. Could be lurking or might just be busy.
Read: Leaning scum.

Monkeyman:
Easy to pick on but is town. I saw it in my role pm!

Neil:
Very agressive but seems to backtrack a lot. Might be overactive.
Read: Neutral

[MonkeyMan576]

PeregrineV:
Very active and confrontational. I like it.
Read: Town

PhDScar:
Haven't played with him I think so not really sure of his tendancies. But he looks ok so far.
Read: Slight town

TheFuzzyLogic99:
Either badscum or badtown.
Read: Scum

TheUnderachivers/NeroCain:
Actively scumhunting.
Read: Town

TiphaneDeath:
Very thoughtful and willing to put himself on the line for an unpopular opinion.
Read: Town

Vezo:
Not much content, but likes to ask questions.
Read: Neutral

[Antihero]

obvious situation awareness issues aside...

that's pretty bad

[Aegor]

Then maybe you should eliminate the soundness of the premise by posting content.


VOTE: ABR

oh yeah? why?

that's not really talking about Neil parroting Mhork. I take it you still think he's scum?

Still ok with killing Monkey,

i'm a big picture guy, nero. in large games, there's usually about 3-4 conversations going on a time so ignoring something isn't necessarily bad by itself

FYI: the case on monkey has nothing to do with lack of "content"

You saw that too, didn't you?

@Anti: what is bad?


So, ABR is following this thread.

I like my vote.

[Antihero]

analysis on key slots that i'm interested in:

Action Dan:
Voted ArcAngel and td with little explanation. Very light content.
Read: Slight Scum

Albert B Rampage:
Very soft spoken, seems to be avoiding content/confrontation. Could be scum or a town power role.
Read: Neutral

Aronis:
Active, yet logical. A good combination for scumhunting if he is town. Hasn't posted a lot recently though.
Read: Neutral

Neil:
Very agressive but seems to backtrack a lot. Might be overactive.
Read: Neutral

PhDScar:
Haven't played with him I think so not really sure of his tendancies. But he looks ok so far.
Read: Slight town

Vezo:
Not much content, but likes to ask questions.
Read: Neutral

a very clear pattern emerges. "neutral" reads and summaries of player's ISO's (as opposed to analysis)

[Albert B. Rampage]

Unvote, vote Monkey

[Lord Mhork]

ABR why are you not throwing a hissy fit?

[TheUnderachivers]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

Is this the same ABR?

[TheUnderachivers]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

Is this the same ABR?

[TheUnderachivers]

Kdub:
Mod.

Lord God:
Only one post, but at least he's not afraid to confront AA9.
Read: Neutral

Mastin:
Only one post. Could be lurking or might just be busy.
Read: Leaning scum.

Lord God is a PV alt, me thinks

[Kdub]

Day 1 - Vote Count #8

Aegor (2)

- TiphaineDeath, neil1113

vezokpiraka (0)

-

Aronis (1)

- vezokpiraka

Albert B. Rampage (1)

- Aegor

TheUnderachivers (0)

-

farside22 (0)

-

PhDScar (0)

-

PeregrineV (0)

-

Lord Mhork (0)

-

neil1113 (0)

-

Cephrir (0)

-

Antihero (0)

-

TheFuzzylogic99 (3)

- MonkeyMan576, PeregrineV, Aronis

ArcAngel9 (0)

-

TiphaineDeath (2)

- Lord Mhork, ActionDan

ActionDan (0)

-

MonkeyMan576 (7)

- PhDScar, ArcAngel9, Cephrir, TheUnderachivers, Antihero, farside22, Albert B. Rampage

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (1)

- TheFuzzylogic99

17 votes available
9 votes needed to lynch

V/LA: farside22 (4/21), ActionDan (4/21), PhDScar (4/21)

Deadline: (expired on 2014-05-05 17:47:00)

[MonkeyMan576]

So me not posting a 100 page read makes me scummy?

[Aegor]

You not actually making an effort makes you scummy. You posted nothing but factual information.

[MonkeyMan576]

I'm making more of an effort than a good third of other players. Again, it's only day 1. You'll have a much better chance of lynching actual scum elsewhere, my wagon is not at all logical.

If you want to go after a lurker you should go after ActionDan or LordGod.

[vezokpiraka]

vote monkey

Good lord. Those reads are abysmall.

[MonkeyMan576]

Albert and Vezo are clearly voting me because I didn't have a town read on them, not because I am scummy.

When I flip town, take a close look at my wagon.

[MonkeyMan576]

I'm going to claim before I go to work. I will be gone for the next 8-9 hours. My role is Hanhaar, Vanilla Townie.

[vezokpiraka]

Wow. That defense.
Ofc I'm voting you because you have a neutral read on me. How did you figure that out? /Sarcasm