Death Note Mafia (Game Over!)

[KuroiXHF]

We understood and accepted the very slim likelihood of everyone dying.

[JasonWazza]

Well, i killed Mew, and i die afterwards, so everyone dies

[malpascp]

So all threats to town were eliminated.
And we win!
All acording to the plan

[KuroiXHF]

No. Jason still had one more day.

[KuroiXHF]

I thought I screwed up and town actually won lol. That would have been impressive.

But yeah. If there were three people on day eight and there was a no lynch, even if Jason killed someone, they would both die and one townie would remain

[Gamma Emerald]

So some background and thoughts.
I saw this game and thought "I like the anime, let's do this". I was worried I'd get a flavor I didn't remember, but I got Rem, the Shinigami who watched over Misa. I figured my role would be set on town, and a decent role at that. So I almost slipped out of rage when I saw people suggesting Misa as scum, and seeing Rem there wasn't any help. When Narna got on my case for defending Hark, I ended up deciding to soft my role by saying I like to defend. He then got cheeky and asked me to defend her, and I said we'll see. The next important point I'd like to address were the wagons on Creature, JW, and Nero. The Creature wagon pissed me off because some people were being a bit too pushy, especially Nero. This is what caused me to scumread Nero. BTW Nero turned into a bab in the Dead PT and said he was the towniest player, which is a damn lie: I feel Basic did a better job being towny. The next big wagon was JW, and he claimed Vig, but everyone assumed SK. I don't get how he wasn't lynched D7, especially with that bullshit idea of two Secondary mafia he was selling. The final big wagon was Nero. Kraska made herself a scumread to me by being reallt pushy about lynching not-Nero, and then she claimed masons with him. AC also posted the stupid theory about a bunch of people who were pushing Nero being likely buddies, which was really scummy. Then Nero claimed cop, which I felt was a form of scumclaim. By having two roles assiciated with him he pretty much became confscum. I also really suspected kraska at this point due to the mason fakeclaim. If scum hadn't killed her she would have been an easy ML.
I think this about covers Day 1. Day 2 thoughts sometime.

[Wisdom]

especially with that bullshit idea of two Secondary mafia he was selling.

I feel like you're just saying that because you got spoiled. If you were still in the game in, say, Basic's place, you would still be hunting for Nero's buddies. I know I was hunting for them until I saw IaI flip town and figured out what was happening.

[Gamma Emerald]

No it's still dumb
IF THERE WERE 2 SECONDARY MAFIA LEFT THE GAME WOULD HAVE BEEN OVER!

[Wisdom]

I also really suspected kraska at this point due to the mason fakeclaim. If scum hadn't killed her she would have been an easy ML.

No, kraska was pretty obvious town. I understand how fakeclaim makes you think scum, but you have to be less shallow; there are certain types of town players who do such things.

[Gamma Emerald]

I also really suspected kraska at this point due to the mason fakeclaim. If scum hadn't killed her she would have been an easy ML.

No, kraska was pretty obvious town. I understand how fakeclaim makes you think scum, but you have to be less shallow; there are certain types of town players who do such things.

Yeah
That's why I'm going to be skeptical of any mason claims by kraska from now on.

[Wisdom]

No it's still dumb
IF THERE WERE 2 SECONDARY MAFIA LEFT THE GAME WOULD HAVE BEEN OVER!

No, because there was still an SK/vig alive. Say for example, that Mew and Ank were team2, and town lynched Mew; then Jason shoots Ank. Scumteam 2 doesn't win, despite being 2:2.

[Gamma Emerald]

No: the rules generally state that ONCE A SCUMTEAM ACHIEVES A SIMPLE MAJORITY they win.

[Wisdom]

Yeah
That's why I'm going to be skeptical of any mason claims by kraska from now on.

no, what you should do is understand people's character and try to figure out their motivations for doing things.
For example, it was easy to figure out that kraska was overconfident town who had a huge townread on Nero and wanted to save him.
Don't associate scummy actions with scum; associate scum motivation with scum.

[Wisdom]

No: the rules generally state that ONCE A SCUMTEAM ACHIEVES A SIMPLE MAJORITY they win.

That's generally the case because once scum have the same number alive as non-scum they control the lynch and they can force a no-lynch and win. In this case that wasn't the case like I demonstrated.

[Nero Cain]

Gamma, anyone with two brain cells knew the mason claim was fake and I even said so. Creature was still scum. Credit where credit is due but it was SirCakez and someone else that meta scum read him and after reading his ISO I was more than understanding of why he could be scum so you and Basic scum reading me for scumreading scum is a fail on your part.

[JasonWazza]

No: the rules generally state that ONCE A SCUMTEAM ACHIEVES A SIMPLE MAJORITY they win.

This is not a standard game, i even linked to why that doesn't work.

Basic read this and then vote Mew.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Win_Condition

[JasonWazza]

Like there is no reason while the game was running to assume that a simple majority won the game.

[Untrod Tripod]

To nominate this game and any players or mods in it, please see the Scummies nomination thread.

[Gamma Emerald]

Been rewatching the series and noted that the victory of Mello is rather fitting, seeing as he beat Near in the end

[Gamma Emerald]

Also prob going to do a more flavorful rendition of the game's events sometime

[KuroiXHF]

Also prob going to do a more flavorful rendition of the game's events sometime

Snarky Snowman is doing a spin-off of sorts in the mini queue. You might want to also check that out.

[Gamma Emerald]

saw that
It's more of a retelling of this game with influence by the show's events

[Vince McMahon]

saw that
It's more of a retelling of this game with influence by the show's events

Yeah, agreed. I know it's not the same; I just wanted to make sure you were aware, since I like this fan-fic kind of stuff.

[Wisdom]

Been rewatching the series and noted that the victory of Mello is rather fitting, seeing as he beat Near in the end

eh, it would be more fitting if the SK's actions resulted in a town win

[Frozen Angel]

Been rewatching the series and noted that the victory of Mello is rather fitting, seeing as he beat Near in the end

eh, it would be more fitting if the SK's actions resulted in a town win

Nice one