Open 612 - Bad Poets Society - Game Over - Town Win

[Ranger]

vote: GM
free town points to anyone who can guess why i made this vote.

I

might

see what you're seeing, so I could probably follow you, but I happen to hold stronger suspicion on Errant.

[makara]

OK real talk - my vote on ranger was a reaction test. I don't like the way that Errant responded to it - it felt like it was going after a scummy-looking player without looking deeper. He could have asked why it was a serious vote, but he mostly seemed interested in going after an easy target.

VOTE: Errant

@ranger pls get an avi - it makes your posts easily recognizable on a quick glance

[goodmorning]

@GM - 37 - Lets talk more on this. When on earth do people get credit for ending RVS?

They don't, but they might think they do which is more relevant to the situation.

[Quaroath]

Vote Count 1.0*

They start out all random
aghast at their fandom
Who is it that shall recite?
With their pants pulled up tight?

Who could it be... maybe ika masume?
or maybe Errantparabola is full of hyberbola?

Errantparabola - (3) goodmorning, Ranger, Makara

Goodmorning – (1) Ika Musume
GrayFoxxxx - (1) Brunneis
Ika Musume – (1) Varsoon,
Makara –(1) Errantparabola
MaxwellPuckett - (1) Vedith
Vedith - (1) GrayFoxxxx

Not Voting – (4) duppin, MaxwellPuckett , The Fire Hermit. Trivium

*Votecount corrected

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-25 23:59:59)
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

[GrayFoxxxx]

Well not your entrance but your whole "I am relooking at his iso" like, what iso? Theres 44 posts in the game and nobody has more than like 5.

I checked his ISO after GM voted him. I don't know what else to call it but ISO...

[Errantparabola]

Mod- im not on ikas wagon

Fixed, investigating what happened

[GrayFoxxxx]

Looks like an attempt to grab credit for ending RVS etc

I would say props for taking us out of rvs

Here is a post of me doing the exact opposite

How was Mak over-responding? All he did was inquire about how your vote was better placed on him

When I mean overresponding, I'm talking about makara's omgus serious vote

If anything it looks more towny to me.

How was it an over reaction as opposed to a normal reaction?

You could say I'm asking how would you have reacted in his spot.

[GrayFoxxxx]

I do disagree with gm.

I don't think he was trying to take credit.

[Varsoon]

@Mod: Could you edit the first post so that it is clear which accounts are publicly playing in hydras?

Doing that now.

And done

[Ranger]

@ranger pls get an avi - it makes your posts easily recognizable on a quick glance

Can't. I tried, but I got an error. Sorry. It shouldn't be a problem, though, so long as I'm the only avatarless player in the game.

[MaxwellPuckett]

vote: GM
free town points to anyone who can guess why i made this vote.

I

might

see what you're seeing, so I could probably follow you, but I happen to hold stronger suspicion on Errant.

I'm interested to know what you

might

be seeing regarding GM.

PEdit: Your mafia career will be filled with pain if you don't have an avi, bub.
VOTE: Ranger

Mostly cause they're fun! c: The error should tell you what was wrong.. try a smaller image?

[Ranger]

It says the file cannot be displayed because the extension is not allowed, but I've tried png, jpeg, and gif, all for an image that's 52x90 pixels large, and only 7.47 kb. I really don't know why it's not working. :/

[MaxwellPuckett]

Huh, okay, that's weird. I'm sure there's a reason for it, but I can't think of one with the info here. For ref, mine's a 100 x 100 .png image so I don't know why yours isn't working. Contact site help?

[Ranger]

Ah, there we go.
IT WORKS!

[MaxwellPuckett]

UNVOTE: Ranger

Goodnight everybody!

[MaxwellPuckett]

Wait, you're the same person who I asked about goodmorning. While not as pressing as you getting an avatar, I'd still like to know. In the morning. I won't read it now.

[Ranger]

I'm interested to know what you might be seeing regarding GM.

Realized I skipped over answer this, sorry. Didn't mean to ignore it. Generally, I've been raised to not immediately reveal these things until more time has passed, allowing more players to chime in. Particularly, the player being pressured. (In this case, GM.) So I can answer, but I generally like to wait until time has passed.

I assumed Ika was doing the same thing, actually.

[Brunneis]

How was Mak over-responding? All he did was inquire about how your vote was better placed on him

When I mean overresponding, I'm talking about makara's omgus serious vote

I'm having a hard time taking Mak seriously in 11.... Especially that early.

Plus, you didn't state why you voted for Mak in 12 until after you were questioned about it. But before then, you say that your vote was "semi-serious" but credited to Mak in 15 that he put us out of RVS (But your vote remained).... Before half of us even posted in the thread...

I'm suspicious of the ambiguity generated from your posts.

42

@GrayFoxxxx

Why not you? My vote was RVS. It's just that you didn't seem to have any reaction to my initial post, so I pried.

I just find that your posts so far have just vaguely stated whether you agreed or disagreed with someone, and I find that odd, especially since you've done nothing over your original vote that concerned Vedith - whether it was meant to be RVS or not.

Yeah I'm going on a limb with FB being town... (I know he's IC btw :roll)

@Brunneis - 41 - Why did you originally ask Ranger and Errant and then mention the Gray hasn't responded?

@GM - 37 - Lets talk more on this. When on earth do people get credit for ending RVS?

Because Ranger/Errant haven't stated their votes, and I inquired to understand why they were serious.

Also, between my first post, and the second - 20 41 - Errant actually replied to my question, whereas Gray had posted several times between then and there without any sign of acknowledgement from my post.

49

@Ranger

Yeah, I'm liking this reasoning a lot better. I'm already detecting inconsistencies with Para

As for my vote, I feel a little weird about Gray, but Para's caught my attention more.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Errantparabola

>>>

Not entirely sure what Ranger and Ika see in GM, I'd like at least 1 of them to post soon regarding this... I've been in a game as town with GM being scum. I don't think I've seen enough to make a clear decision on their alignment. However, I feel a slight town vibe, but I'm not going to go any further than this right now.

[duppin]

OK real talk - my vote on ranger was a reaction test. I don't like the way that Errant responded to it - it felt like it was going after a scummy-looking player without looking deeper. He could have asked why it was a serious vote, but he mostly seemed interested in going after an easy target.

Wait, what? Perhaps I am tired, but are you calling her out for going after a scummy-looking player (in your opinion)?

[goodmorning]

@Mod: I'm totally voting parabola.

He could have asked why it was a serious vote,

p r e c i s e l y

I'm interested to know what you might be seeing regarding GM.

Generally, I've been raised to not immediately reveal these things until more time has passed, allowing more players to chime in. Particularly, the player being pressured. (In this case, GM.)

I'm still not taking it seriously. I thought I'd made that clear already?

[Errantparabola]

In 15 i was crediting ranger for taking us out of rvs
ill respond to the rest when i dont have to phonepost

[Errantparabola]

OK real talk - my vote on ranger was a reaction test. I don't like the way that Errant responded to it - it felt like it was going after a scummy-looking player without looking deeper. He could have asked why it was a serious vote, but he mostly seemed interested in going after an easy target.

VOTE: Errant

@ranger pls get an avi - it makes your posts easily recognizable on a quick glance

Are you kidding?
A "scummy looking player without looking deeper?"
Youre saying this so called "reaction test" is just you acting suspiciously and then calling someone out for saying you were "scummy looking."

[GrayFoxxxx]

How was Mak over-responding? All he did was inquire about how your vote was better placed on him

When I mean overresponding, I'm talking about makara's omgus serious vote

I'm having a hard time taking Mak seriously in 11.... Especially that early.

Plus, you didn't state why you voted for Mak in 12 until after you were questioned about it. But before then, you say that your vote was "semi-serious" but credited to Mak in 15 that he put us out of RVS (But your vote remained).... Before half of us even posted in the thread...

I'm suspicious of the ambiguity generated from your posts.

42

@GrayFoxxxx

Why not you? My vote was RVS. It's just that you didn't seem to have any reaction to my initial post, so I pried.

I just find that your posts so far have just vaguely stated whether you agreed or disagreed with someone, and I find that odd, especially since you've done nothing over your original vote that concerned Vedith - whether it was meant to be RVS or not.

Yeah I'm going on a limb with FB being town... (I know he's IC btw :roll)

@Brunneis - 41 - Why did you originally ask Ranger and Errant and then mention the Gray hasn't responded?

@GM - 37 - Lets talk more on this. When on earth do people get credit for ending RVS?

Because Ranger/Errant haven't stated their votes, and I inquired to understand why they were serious.

Also, between my first post, and the second - 20 41 - Errant actually replied to my question, whereas

Gray had posted several times between then and there without any sign of acknowledgement from my post.

49

@Ranger

Yeah, I'm liking this reasoning a lot better. I'm already detecting inconsistencies with Para

As for my vote, I feel a little weird about Gray, but Para's caught my attention more.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Errantparabola

>>>

Not entirely sure what Ranger and Ika see in GM, I'd like at least 1 of them to post soon regarding this... I've been in a game as town with GM being scum. I don't think I've seen enough to make a clear decision on their alignment. However, I feel a slight town vibe, but I'm not going to go any further than this right now.

To respond to what was directed to me-
I know it was rvs. That's why I didn't have a problem with it. I only acknowledged it because you kinda directly asked me to.

Now to the bolded part. Why are you putting so much weight on your RVS vote? You're framing the situation like it wasn't an RVS, and I should have something major to say about it. When I do ask about it, your response is "it was rvs, why not".

???

I have a small town vibe from you, but I really need to you explain your line of questioning.

[MaxwellPuckett]

I'm interested to know what you might be seeing regarding GM.

Realized I skipped over answer this, sorry. Didn't mean to ignore it. Generally, I've been raised to not immediately reveal these things until more time has passed, allowing more players to chime in. Particularly, the player being pressured. (In this case, GM.) So I can answer, but I generally like to wait until time has passed.

I assumed Ika was doing the same thing, actually.

I don't agree with 'waiting for time to pass' if the player being waited on isn't really being pushed to answer, which appears to be the case. Now that goodmorning has weighed in below, would you feel like sharing your feelings on them? Same question to Ika Musume.

@Mod: I'm totally voting parabola.

He could have asked why it was a serious vote,

p r e c i s e l y

I'm interested to know what you might be seeing regarding GM.

Generally, I've been raised to not immediately reveal these things until more time has passed, allowing more players to chime in. Particularly, the player being pressured. (In this case, GM.)

I'm still not taking it seriously. I thought I'd made that clear already?

As for the other point of discussion, I'm not sure that arguing about RVS pedantics is the best use of our time. I really often see players argue about specific wording and what they expected from each other in the RVS stage, and it all turns up to nothing because the two players have just confused each other, or have different opinions about the significance of RVS, etc. etc.
If you disagree with me on that point, please say so. I'm aware I might be misunderstanding the situation, or over-simplifying.

[goodmorning]

You sound far too reasonable to be Town.