I'm 50% in agreement with Bro. Good link there, since I don't see scum intent. He is wrong about me, but whatever.
I see Bro, Mala, and Grandeur as Town. I'm not wrong on those. Probable Comando is town and UTC is ... not lynch material.
That leaves Cheery, MVM, and Jily So, two of those are town. 2 of those are scum. No association. There is nothing on Jily except for scarce Mort post.
Cheery is Ice and MvM is Fire. Likely.
Case on cheery: I'm going to extend on what Bro said.
In post 66, Cheery Dog wrote: In post 62, BROseidon wrote:What do you guys think of hawk? Do his concerns look more or less forced than commando's?
About the same, but then I'm not actually serious with my commando vote
Your commando vote was good. I find it that new players playing scum tend to be careful with their votes and are cautious with getting seen as scummy. Your original vote adds sufficient pressure to get commando speaking and slipping if really scum. Why back down like this?
Post
70 says that Dry is Prob town, but doesn't elaborate as to why he thinks that. Going against the common grain and taking a stance far from their buddy if Ice.
posts
106 ,
112 ,
135, and
162 and every question he directs at Boro have no followup.
Post
127: So it's not a definite one is town then, I'll be watching that you're not just hunting one team though. This is actually a good strategy to find scum. Pro points for this, but this can easily come from Scum mentality. Scum would want to distinguish town from scum as quickly as possible and plan accordingly.
Post 221: "Now I'm had a weird thought that guille and dryfit are buddies doing weird distancing, but I think that's overlooking other crap, and just there to confuse myself." Covering his bases after he said dry is town.
Overall, if you read his day 1 posts he only seriously votes for MVM. But considering the 4 post with no followup and his concern for Boro. His discussions with boro just like the 4 posts I mentioned as not having followup, have no followup. They all have reasons for Cheery to vote for any of Boro, Mort, and MVM. Although, he does eventually vote for MVM but not for reasons that can be obtained from his unresolved questions to these players.
In post 303, Cheery Dog wrote:I'm quoting the part I don't understand, well I guess I'm also slightly confused by what you're considering about guille after being convincing, but what I quoted is the important part to me.
Anyway I can't see guille being the remaining ice goon due to starting interactions with boro being too in yourface buddying - or him wanting to actually kill Dry-fit.
(though it was probably borophil choosing that kill)
I would be convinced with only day 1 play that Cheery is scum. This post tell me he is Ice. As Ice he knows I will flip either Town or Fire. So he needs to do two things. Voice his opinion against me being Ice but leave it open so that I could get lynch, in the event of me being Fire. And also discredit the argument proposed by Bro, so that he won't get lynched after I am lynched.
Vote Cheery