So let's look at the quick rise and quicker fall of the IS wagon.
First vote on the IS wagon, and his first vote of the game. Essentially a random vote for reading purposes.
In post 31, Klick wrote: In post 18, Firebringer wrote:How about my awesome train, guys?
Random weird question, who you guys think would be most dangerous scum team here?
Did you read some of the earlier Jungle Republic games before asking this?
DV's probably town, I'm leaning scum on Mario and IS.
VOTE: IS
My vote. I explained it later.
Agreeing with my reasoning.
In post 53, DeasVail wrote: In post 41, Klick wrote:DV gave an answer only specifying me as a dangerous member of any scum alignment, implying he wasn't thinking in a team mindset.
I'm still not sure about this. My post implied that my lack of saying any other names was due to my lack of experience with anyone else, and you're the only person who I have played a significant amount with (albeit a long time ago). My guess is that I probably would have said the same thing or something similar as scum, though this could be my own ignorance speaking I suppose. What do you think of my argument for it perhaps not being a towntell though? And was this something you considered?
What do you think of Klick's theory?
I'm not as sold on the tell of threes as Klick seems to be, but nonetheless
VOTE: Idiot Savant
Hesitant vote on IS for my reasoning.
In post 56, Wanderer-nl wrote:@Hayato: What kind of insightful questions do you expect on page 2? My question was a first attempt to get things moving. I happened to already be voting for you, but it's not something I would have voted you over if I wasn't. Like Savant just described having issues with sarcasm/jokes, I have that too. So yeah, when I see something I'm not sure about, I ask. That helps me prevent silly thougtprocesses and eventually tunnelling on a false assumption. I hope you're being aggressive town and not dodgy scum.
I don't know how I feel about how Savant liked my question. I was hoping it would get a little more attention so I could get reads from the reactions, but the reactions to Firebringer's random question attracted more responses so now it's become useless.
I don't know how Klick plays as town, but I read up on this set-up before the game started so I knew where his reads came from and to me they're nothing to worry about. I also felt
20 felt pretty town so I agree with his early townread on DV.
@Savant: It's not a silly reason if it works.
VOTE: Savant
Again, based on my reasoning. Side-note, this post is a town post.
In post 59, gameplay506 wrote:I actually read it
Ok stop it wanderer :/
So lets try this shall we?
VOTE: IS
L-1
He's not totally convinced by my reasoning, but is voting for the sake of putting IS at L-1. Leaning town on this.
After this, myko says he'd be fine with Mario hammering IS (if I'm reading Post #67 correctly).
This is presumably in response to gameplay's L-1 and Mario's intent to hammer.
In post 81, mykonian wrote: In post 75, MarioManiac4 wrote:
GG catching me, but please actually consider who i am before trying to read me, or you will regret it.
And the ONLY reason I wanted to hammer with a 6/5 ratio was because it was ika!hydra, and that's literally it. It would have felt so fucking good to do that hammer vote if they weren't the seer.
yes, considering who you are and this and post 66, you are probably scum.
GODDAMNIT FIREBRINGER
vote firebringer
and I trusted you
HOW COULD YOU.
I don't like this hop off of IS, especially since he was cool with a hammer before this.
This vote makes sense, considering gameplay didn't really seem to have a scumread on IS in the first place, the wagon was dying, and his real scumread was Firebringer.
DV also changes votes, but the wagon is essentially dead by this point.
In conclusion, IS is still scum, I could see myko being scum too, and DV/Wanderer/gameplay are town.
myko, I'm not a fan of your reasoning for suspecting Fire of being scum. If anything, I see him blatantly targeting one scumteam over another as a towntell, because scum would also have to pretend to be finding their own team.
I'd also be willing to wagon mykonian if that ever happened, as I have a gut feeling there too.