Open 570: Making Friends and Enemies (Mafia Wins!)

[Josh_B]

Subject: Open 570 Mason QT

Wow.

What the fuck just happened.

I thought one of Huntress/Uct was scum. VCA is starting to point to Huntress being scum.

GM is probably scum as well. I think the last one is Nero. Dave is town due to Zeb posting his reads when he replaced out. Only a townie would do that I feel.

Good posting.

[uctriton00]

Well, I was wrong on most of my reads, in fact the only "good" read I had came at the very end of the game where I said to look at people who didn't replace. Huntress and gm had been in the entire game, and there's no reason for them to replace, they were winning by a landslide.

hephaestus, if he had stayed in, would have gotten himself killed too, so Nero did a good job.

I still think I did the right thing by killing myself because I would have taken out BBT or Shinobi before hephaestus, so I would have lost us the game anyway.

[uctriton00]

@Mod, you did a fine job, but I agree 3 week timelines are way too long; the days become gluttonous pages (like 20-25+ pages each?) and catching up becomes a chore and apathy sets in. Other than that, no complaints, congrats on your first completed game!

What happened with the Wisdom force replace?

[uctriton00]

This game was extremely hard to gauge, I would have driven us off a cliff

So my guts are huntress and GM, then idk for 3rd

I still think aegor is town because I don't see a scenario where a scum is force replaced

Yeah, I was gonna say that I didn't find any of those reads to be particularly useful.

No offense.

heh

Yeah Shinobi my frustration with you that day was completely sincere, I thought you were making a case just for making a case. What seriously went through your head when you said "I found the bullshit, I am attacking it?". Like seriously, what was that?

[uctriton00]

Wisdom was replaced for fear of having outside knowledge of the game given to them by another player.

Didn't see this mod.

I'll PM you; in my second moderated game I had a mistake where I had to force replace someone, so if we share experiences maybe we can learn from them?

[goodmorning]

On deadlines: Have you considered a conditional deadline? I tend to do (#players + 1) days, with a minimum deadline of a week.

[Shinobi]

This game was extremely hard to gauge, I would have driven us off a cliff

So my guts are huntress and GM, then idk for 3rd

I still think aegor is town because I don't see a scenario where a scum is force replaced

Yeah, I was gonna say that I didn't find any of those reads to be particularly useful.

No offense.

heh

Yeah Shinobi my frustration with you that day was completely sincere, I thought you were making a case just for making a case. What seriously went through your head when you said "I found the bullshit, I am attacking it?". Like seriously, what was that?

Nothing, really. I'm a big fan of pointless rhetoric.

I probably wouldn't have voted you at all if I was actually paying attention the whole time. I just kind of hopped on and saw a thing I didn't like, so I went "let's see where this goes."

Was it a really big deal?

[uctriton00]

No, it was all I could really use to try to scum hunt, I wasn't getting much one on one from others at all this game, I felt ignored

I was heavy info lynching this game, otherwise I couldn't form any reads otherwise

[Shinobi]

Huh.

I've never been a fan of information lynches. I always feel like they're useless.

Then again, I hate associative reads but this place is huge on them.

[Josh_B]

There were a lot of jokes this game. My favorite was when BBT said I'll sheep Josh or GM. Then GM voted BBT.

[Malakittens]

I'm sorry

[LlamaFluff]

done