Open 570: Making Friends and Enemies (Mafia Wins!)

[Shinobi]

I know, I called you out so early and everybody went "nah she's town."

And I was sitting here the whole time, like, "wat."

[goodmorning]

I felt really bad for Toffee, but not so bad that I didn't start completely trolling.

[Metal Sonic]

Yeah beast was ok. Long deadlines got too boring though


Ha gm gotcha

[Shinobi]

I felt really bad for Toffee, but not so bad that I didn't start completely trolling.

Yeah, I definitely felt his frustration. I got really lethargic during day 1 and day 2 and I think it showed, and I was still one of the more active players in the game.

That was bad.

[goodmorning]

Ha gm gotcha

tbqh the only thing that I wouldn't also have done as town was get as frustrated as I got, but good on you. Actually that's pretty much the whole reason I got as frustrated as I got.

I felt really bad for Toffee, but not so bad that I didn't start completely trolling.

Yeah, I definitely felt his frustration. I got really lethargic during day 1 and day 2 and I think it showed, and I was still one of the more active players in the game.

That was bad.

Just goes to show what an apathetic Town will let happen. If you're Town you have a duty to be active so the Scum can't hide amongst lurkers.
Toffee not claiming when he was run up was a little surprising to us. We assumed if he was a Mason that he would have, so more fool us because when I put it that way it looks super obvious.

From our discussion last night:
Huntress: Who do you think is most likely [to be a Mason]?
goodmorning: Shinobi maybe? I have no idea. I just feel like Toffee, with a large wagon and a nearness to deadline, might have yelled about being a mason, insulted everyone, and peaced out. He was not calm.
But if the two of you think it's so then I will concede that I haven't been so much reading Toffee's posts as calculating my own to enrage him.

[Shinobi]

Hahaha. I don't think lylo would have gone differently if I was alive; I don't think I ever would have voted with Josh on anything considering he was making up scumreads on me from start to finish.

[davesaz]

Well, at least the last reads I posted were partially right.

The modding was OK, I might suggest vote counts a little more frequently.

[Wisdom]

So I was right in stopping my tunneling on pea and Josh.. Only to go and scumread the masons next. Yay fail

[Josh_B]

I don't feel bad for tunneling on the masons, they were pretty scummy.

I need to learn how to get scum lynched. nyaayyayya and huntress were obvscum by the time I joined. hepheastus's vote on NPAU was the worst

[Scripten]

This was a pretty fun game. I wish I'd been able to be active in it a little longer. My reads were kind of crap, though.

Any advice from others, though my contributions were admittedly minor?

[Shinobi]

So I was right in stopping my tunneling on pea and Josh.. Only to go and scumread the masons next. Yay fail

So how's that outside game knowledge working out for you?

[Wisdom]

Can't talk about that, game still ongoing

[Shinobi]

I can see humor isn't exactly your strong point.

[Wisdom]

Prolly because you didn't make any sense. I replaced out the moment I got the suspicion of outside info so my reads were never affected by that

[Shinobi]

Woosh.

[Nero Cain]

I don't remember being majorly suspected so ya for me. Thanks to my team for helping me win. I think you did fine Beast.

[Peabody]

Good games, guys.

I thought GM and Wisdom were masons together which is why my town reads were not waivering on them.

Nice job, mafia team!

[Aegor]

Sorry for being useless. I did pretty much read the whole game though, but I did think that JoshB was pretty scummy, so I probably would not have been an asset there anyway.


Scumteam, were there any slips or scummy things that we should have picked up on? I did not strongly suspect any of you.

[Nero Cain]

I don't think so I also did not read the full game when I replaced in. lol

[goodmorning]

Scumteam, were there any slips or scummy things that we should have picked up on? I did not strongly suspect any of you.

nya was pretty blatantly scum and heph wasn't great but Nero managed to get that slot respected enough. Huntress flew INCREDIBLY under the radar without anyone noticing. I was trolling Toffee pretty hard.
So any of those things should probably have been noticed but weren't.

[Huntress]

Thanks for modding, Beast!

I'm ok with our PT being opened if it hasn't been yet.

That is why we do not vote in lylo without consensus about whom to vote.

Not sure why you quoted my post before this? And we did have consensus before voting. I waited because I was paranoid that BBT was trying to trap me somehow.

I would like people to rate me as a mod and tell me what I can do to improve in the future please. If it isn't too much trouble at least.

I think the game went smoothly and I liked the pace. Only thing that needed changing I think was the deadline which was a bit too long. Just try to keep to daily vote counts and prod checks and you should be fine.

This was a pretty fun game. I wish I'd been able to be active in it a little longer. My reads were kind of crap, though.

Any advice from others, though my contributions were admittedly minor?

I think you were doing ok. You were asking good questions and were being townread by most people.

[Metal Sonic]

i am VERY SAD you did not follow up with this :'(

Up to page 27.

Liking Huntress more after reading more of her.

Liked Shinobi's attempt to act as a peacemaker between BBT and Mala in 583. This sort of thing shows town most of the time.

Changed my mind about the Zebulin slot. Liking davesaz a lot.

Not quite sure about uctriton, but he slighly leans towards town.

hephaestus is most likely scum.

My other reads remain the same.

goodmorning/Peabody/hephaestus is my first guess at a scumteam.

--

Pausing for a while as I have to go, will continue reading soon.

[Metal Sonic]

toffee obv mason lololol

i was very frustrated

[Metal Sonic]

How are you town-reading Shinobi?

PEdit - what has she done that is scummy?

I don't have any good answers besides "He looks town". He did mention that he "burned" me in another game, that was half-true. I was townreading him for quite awhile until the later part of the game where he became obvscum. It might be happening now, and I have no way to find out.



Look at how defensive she is. And I wrote a pretty big case against her for a game with less than ten pages. You read that, didn't you?


PS: I just realised that goodmorning is female. Then I tried to go to her GTKAS to attempt to find out her age (out of curiosity). It wasn't put there so I had to guess.

Josh's play is way more impressive than what happened in Marvel Avengers.


Bluebloodedtoffee, come to your senses please. Uncle Sonic is being very patient with you!

You're good though. Super town. Screw Toffee and let's hunt scum together.

BlueBloodedToffee,

Who do you think is the towniest at the moment? Help me fix my read list. ^

Maybe there is a townread that needs to sit up there, but is in my No Read or Maybe Town section.

[beastcharizard]

Mafia QT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 9#p6207509

Mason QT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 8#p6207518