Open 594: Stack the Deck (Game Over)

[Aneninen]

davesaz (3) Aneninen, texcat, Inquisitor
Inquisitor (1) davesaz
(

Not voting

) numberQ, randomidget, Reubus Swagrid, House
8 alive; 5 votes lynch.

Ja Inkvisiteur du hast Recht. Aber ich denke daß ich jemand von Davesazes Idee töten soll wenn er Stadtwohner flippen würde. Okay?

[davesaz]

Maybe we lynch someone from my list instead?

[Inquisitor]

Maybe we lynch someone from my list instead?

No.

Ja Inkvisiteur du hast Recht. Aber ich denke daß ich jemand von Davesazes Idee töten soll wenn er Stadtwohner flippen würde. Okay?

wat

[numberQ]

You posted that you'd ISOed me, therefore, you must have found my case against Davesaz.
You took much effort on speculating Random's claim then you said that you're bad at Setup logic.
Your observations about Swagrid are valid, but could be faked easily.
Also, don't you have any reads on House, Inquisitor and Texcat?

I used ISO as shorthand for a few of your posts, I didn't actually read your entire ISO and probably should have clarified. That said, I just found your case on dave (post 617 it looks like), and I can see where the votes are coming from. Some of your points seem a bit nitpicky (how was his post 402 "testing the waters" in any way whatsoever?), but he is definitely prompting for discussion way more than he's providing it. I can imagine that being scum trying to look town.

Also, I quite clearly said writing up the post helped me organize my thoughts, which is why I put effort into it. Try reading.

Regarding Swagrid, my observations are "faked easily"? That's a shitty, nonsensical thing to say. Anything said in Mafia could be "faked easily".

Reads: House is too unguarded for me to think he's scum. All his posts have this "I don't care" attitude about them, and it doesn't feel faked. Inquisitor was never really on my radar, but looking back that's because he didn't really do anything. He has low, scummy amounts of content in his posts, but his vote sticking to Ane for most of days 1 and 2 strikes me as town more than scum, if only because I think scum votes would have been swept up in the turbulence of day 1. Overall, not a scum read. Texcat hasn't done anything overtly scummy, but nothing overtly townie either that I can see. I see her as more town than scum if only because there are others that are scummier.

Right now I'd feel comfortable with a dave or Swagrid lynch. Personally, I think Swagrid is more scummy, but I can agree with the dave voters enough to put him at L-1.

VOTE: davesaz

[Inquisitor]

I totes did stuff.

D:

[Aneninen]

Ja Inkvisiteur du hast Recht. Aber ich denke daß ich jemand von Davesazes Idee töten soll wenn er Stadtwohner flippen würde. Okay?

wat

A drunkpost which can land on your ignore list.

Actually I tried to say that if Davesaz happens to flip town, I can still Nightkill someone from his list.
As for this, Davesaz, what's your recent read on NumberQ? The more I read his posts the less I like them.

[Inquisitor]

Haha, okay.

I'm relatively confident that NQ is town just based off of the sheer amount of activity and the transparency with which he presents himself. I don't really get the vibe that he's hiding anything in his posts and I have a clear image of what he's trying to accomplish and the direction that he's moving in.
So that shot would preferably be off-limits.

[numberQ]

I totes did stuff.

D:

Maybe you did. I mostly posted that based on memory and a quick skim of your ISO. You aren't posting fluff the way some people in this game have been (Swagrid), but for some reason I had a sense that you were just posting without contributing. Looking back over it now, I actually think you had some townie content, like your interactions with BBT.

As for this, Davesaz, what's your recent read on NumberQ? The more I read his posts the less I like them.

But Ane, I simply can't be scum. If I keep saying that over and over, maybe someone will believe me. I mean it worked for you.

[davesaz]

As for this, Davesaz, what's your recent read on NumberQ? The more I read his posts the less I like them.

660 could be scum using knowledge of how many roles exist to look town. His reason for voting me looks to be mostly sheeping you, which could be buddying you as a known PR.

[numberQ]

As for this, Davesaz, what's your recent read on NumberQ? The more I read his posts the less I like them.

660 could be scum using knowledge of how many roles exist to look town. His reason for voting me looks to be mostly sheeping you, which could be buddying you as a known PR.

The only mention in that post of how many roles exist was the minimum amount required for my "this person is scum" hypothetical situations to work. Nothing I said was knowledge town didn't have. Way to reach. And yes my vote on you is sheeping. As I've said multiple times, I'd prefer a Swagrid lynch but I'll go with the majority on this one because I can see you as scum too. It's also not like we're in danger of instantly losing. If you flip town, I'd be perfectly happy with your sacrifice because it gives us some concrete information, and then I'll probably gun for Swagrid's lynch day 4.

[texcat]

It doesn't look like a Dave lynch is going to happen.
UNVOTE: Dave
VOTE: Reubus

[numberQ]

Why do you say that? If the lynch isn't going to happen it's because you just killed the momentum. I mean I'm all for a Reubus lynch but dave was at L-1. Saying the lynch isn't going to happen seems a little preemptive. I also don't recall you thinking Reubus was scummy outside agreeing with me a few posts ago. Why do you want to lynch him?

[texcat]

Yawn. Momentum?? Really? We only have 5 people voting and one of those is Dave. I'm not sure we'll ever achieve a lynch.

Reubus is my second choice. Maybe with a little pressure, he'll come back and explain why he isn't bothering to vote.

[House]

Yawn. Momentum?? Really? We only have 5 people voting and one of those is Dave. I'm not sure we'll ever achieve a lynch.

Reubus is my second choice. Maybe with a little pressure, he'll come back and explain why he isn't bothering to vote.

Get back on dave or I'm going to tunnel the shit out of you for the rest of the game.

[texcat]

Why don't you get back on Dave?

[House]

VOTE: texcat

He dies or you do.

Right now, you look like you're backing down from a softbus/distancing dance. Replace your vote or die.

[texcat]

Oh good grief. You do realize that there's only one scum left? I can't possibly be bussing Dave.

[House]

Oh good grief. You do realize that there's only one scum left? I can't possibly be bussing Dave.

Then vote him.

[texcat]

I had my vote on him for the past week. I thought it was time to try something else. Will you hammer if I vote?

VOTE: Dave

[House]

VOTE: Dave

[Korejora]

davesaz (5) Aneninen, Inquisitor, numberQ, texcat, House

Inquisitor (1) davesaz
(

Not voting

) randomidget, Reubus Swagrid
8 alive; 5 votes lynch.

davesaz

, a

Mafia

JOAT

, was lynched.

The town wins!

[Korejora]

setup role assignment

numberQ --

Town

Jeanne11 --

Mafia Goon

Creative --

Town

texcat --

Town

BlueBloodedToffee --

Town

randomidget --

Town

davesaz --

Mafia Goon

Reubus Swagrid --

Town

MiteyMouse --

Mafia Traitor

RIP --

Town

Inquisitor --

Town

Aneninen --

Town

new role assignment

numberQ -- Town -- No new role
Aneninen -- Town --

Vigilante

Creative -- Town -- No new role
randomidget -- Town --

Tracker

RIP -- Town --

Goon Cop

BlueBloodedToffee -- Town -- No new role
texcat -- Town --

Roleblocker

Inquisitor -- Town --

Bodyguard

Reubus Swagrid -- Town -- No new role
davesaz -- Mafia Goon --

JOAT

MiteyMouse -- Mafia Traitor ->

Goon

--

Role Cop

Jeanne11 -- Mafia Goon -- No new role

night 1

randomidget -- track

Reubus Swagrid

(no action)

texcat -- roleblock

Dyslexicon

Aneninen -- kill

Dyslexicon

RIP -- investigate

House

(not a goon)

Inquisitor --

(did not receive an action)

davesaz --

kill

Dyslexicon

MiteyMouse -- investigate

numberQ

(vanilla)

night 2

texcat -- roleblock

Aneninen

RIP -- investigate

texcat

(not a goon)

randomidget -- track

Aneninen

(no action)

Aneninen -- kill

Reubus Swagrid

(blocked)

Inquisitor --

(did not receive an action)

davesaz -- ninja kill

RIP

Mafia Thread
Dead Thread

(edit)

now with 27% more unicorn vomit

[davesaz]

GG town. The work issue was indeed real and was the main reason I was passive. I thought the early D1 bus would get me a little cred. Not sure how/why you picked me over the other low postcount folks but it was going to be an uphill battle anyway.

[Inquisitor]

GG town. The work issue was indeed real and was the main reason I was passive. I thought the early D1 bus would get me a little cred. Not sure how/why you picked me over the other low postcount folks but it was going to be an uphill battle anyway.

You were the only person left that we could suspect outside of Reubus. Your team let you down in pretty dramatic fashion.

There were just too many claims and supertowns running around for you to really muck things up this game, especially when your scummates die so quickly.

[Randomnamechange]

Gg, tbh I think tjis setup heavily favours town. Last time I played it we won on day 2.