Mini 665: Day 1 - Abandoned

[Jenethron]

Hi.

Vote: Verbal

, because that's one heck of a creepy avatar.

[Jenethron]

Don't know what fisherofman was thinking, obviously I am curious as to why he would think a mass claim at this stage would be a good idea.

I reiterate the points made by afatchic and others on thegreckoj. I too dislike when questions are posed yet the answers are given. Easily could be a way to bail fisherofmen out of his situation.

Similarly, I dislike georgi's post, where he doesn't really add anything new, just pushes his vote in. I understand that it is early in the game, but it still makes me a bit nervous.

hardly a bandwagon with just two votes for a decidedly suspicious suggestion (fisherofmen calling for a mass role reveal)...

what is equally suspicious though is the way you, afatchic, seem to be cuddling-up to Y.C

FOS afatchick

I find this interesting. So, according to you, afatchic is "equallt suspicious" as fisherofmen, even though afatchic was only agreeing with YC and fisherofmen was proposing a

massclaim

? Sounds like mere retaliation to me.

What is scummy about this? It is just stupid, but townies are as prone as scum to have stupid ideas.

Interesting theory. Why do you think that fisherofmen's action isn't indicative of his alignment? Wouldn't you argue that it has to point one way or another that he is either scum or town, even slightly?

Waiting (as is everyone) for fisherofmen.

[Jenethron]

My scumhunting looks like newbie/scum moves when really they are pure genus as I just got a page of good reading out of one sentence.

...

Um if I missed anything let me know.

Okay, sure. The thing is, if you got a page of "good reading" from it, why aren't you

using

this good reading to make judgements and suspicions? Are you honestly saying that with that "good reading" you got

nothing

about the other players? I don't buy it.

[Jenethron]

no it doesn't, but it is a very curious (ie suspicious) state-of-affairs, isn't it?

Is it? I don't understand that vote at all. Why is afatchic's posting an "anomaly"?

Further, why are you using a "quasi-random" vote when there were actions that otherwise justified a vote, essentially meaning that, IMO, we were at that point out of the random voting stage.

vote: georgi

. Until there is an explanation, it just doesn't make any sense.

I got confused about what the vote count was, so I've provided it:

afatchic (3) -- georgi, Snufkin, Y.C.
fisherofmen (3) -- afatchic, Sineish, thegrekoj
Georgi (2) -- Kuribo, Jenethron
Rage (1) -- chazworthington
Not Voting (3) -- Verbal, Rage, fisherofmen

[Jenethron]

thegrekoj -- why do you think that afatchic is the most pro-town player?

[Jenethron]

Sorry for not posting for a while.

thegrekoj -- why do you think that afatchic is the most pro-town player?

i was just saying information is to the towns benefit. posting usually brings about information. since afatchic is posting the most he is contributing the most information at this point.

I think this is too theoretical. You mention originally that afatchic is the most helpful player because he posts the most - as rage says, quality is better than quantity. It sounds like a way of incriminating georgi, by accusing him (incorrectly IMO) of targetting the most helpful player.

That said, I think this is a fairly minor point, however, since as you did note, georgi's way of targetting afatchic was scummy.

chazworthington, why are you still voting for rage?

I'm keeping my vote on georgi. His self-vote and other behaviour still bugs me.

Need to re-read the posts by kuribo and afatchic.