Mini 214- *gasp* important event...it's over!

[ibaesha]

Down with the bullies!

Hmm... this is the first game I've seen started without several random votes. Since I'm not quite sure where else to begin, I'll stick to the norm.

random vote: Nanook

[ibaesha]

I haven't had much to say so far. I thought Nox was a bit over the top being concerned with two votes on a person since that doesn't necessarily constitute a bandwagon, but didn't consider the paranoia scummy per se. Without a few votes and pressure, there won't be anything to say and we'd just stagnate. I'd like to see where the pressure on Nox leads to at this point though.

[ibaesha]

I haven't had much to say so far. I thought Nox was a bit over the top being concerned with two votes on a person since that doesn't necessarily constitute a bandwagon, but didn't consider the paranoia scummy per se. Without a few votes and pressure, there won't be anything to say and we'd just stagnate. I'd like to see where the pressure on Nox leads to at this point though.

[ibaesha]

Argghh I have no idea why it doubleposted. Sorry.

[ibaesha]

Well, Nox hasn't done much to impress me. "That's just how I am." doesn't really cut it, but I'm not prepared to vote for her yet. However, I see no reason to keep my random vote so

unvote: Nanook

and

FOS: Nox

.

[ibaesha]

I read through everything again and I'm a bit lost. I still think Nox is a bit odd since she said she overanalyzes and nit-picks, but had to hypothesize why she did something. As someone who overanalyzes, I'm pretty aware of why I do things and don't need to hypothesize. That said, the claim is believable, so I'll chalk the oddness up to a difference in personality/thinking at this point.

The little squabble between Chaotic and Tony is interesting, however Tony's reaction sticks out more for me than anything else. Seemed like a rather hostile defense there. I suppose it's possible that Tony is town and a little sensitive about lurker accusations and got a little hot-headed about it, but the same could be said if he's scum.

The only other thing I noticed is that Dranko likes to change his vote a lot. Perhaps this is an attempt to see reactions and get people talking (which is good), but jumping around is a hint suspicious to me.

As I said, I do overanalyze, but at this point it's been fingers pointing in all different directions for various reasons, some sound, others I'm not too inclined to agree with, for example, ENYH's vote on chaotic. I wouldn't consider placing a second vote on someone jumping on a lurker bandwagon. While I disagree, I don't necessarily find it suspicious, especially in this game, where there has been disagreements between many people on a variety of issues.

[ibaesha]

I read through everything again and I'm a bit lost. I still think Nox is a bit odd since she said she overanalyzes and nit-picks, but had to hypothesize why she did something. As someone who overanalyzes, I'm pretty aware of why I do things and don't need to hypothesize. That said, the claim is believable, so I'll chalk the oddness up to a difference in personality/thinking at this point.

The little squabble between Chaotic and Tony is interesting, however Tony's reaction sticks out more for me than anything else. Seemed like a rather hostile defense there. I suppose it's possible that Tony is town and a little sensitive about lurker accusations and got a little hot-headed about it, but the same could be said if he's scum.

The only other thing I noticed is that Dranko likes to change his vote a lot. Perhaps this is an attempt to see reactions and get people talking (which is good), but jumping around is a hint suspicious to me.

As I said, I do overanalyze, but at this point it's been fingers pointing in all different directions for various reasons, some sound, others I'm not too inclined to agree with, for example, ENYH's vote on chaotic. I wouldn't consider placing a second vote on someone jumping on a lurker bandwagon. While I disagree, I don't necessarily find it suspicious, especially in this game, where there has been disagreements between many people on a variety of issues.

[ibaesha]

I don't need to be prodded, I'm here. I need to read through Day 1 again though because I'm really at a loss since my last suspicions centered around both people who are now dead. I'll be posting again once I re-read the thread, most likely later today.

[ibaesha]

Meh, after doing a re-read, I don't feel any closer to discovering scum than before. The only thing that caught my attention was Coolbot's behavior, which was addressed by Freezing yesterday, and now by Nanook today. With so little to go on, let's see what

vote: Coolbot

does.

Besides that, there are people either lurking or not contributing, as Nanook pointed out. Let's hear from you!

[ibaesha]

Coolbot, Chaotic admitted to killing Fuldu night 1. This means he didn't recruit so Dranko couldn't be in his cult.

Dranko, why the comment about cops claiming?

[ibaesha]

Dranko: I expected some sort of response like this. I actually didn't think much about your comment about cops coming out, but since it was brought up, I was curious.

At any rate, it appears to me like Coolbot is digging in an illogical place. I'm liking my vote right now.

[ibaesha]

Dranko hasn't given me any reason to believe he's innocent, so my vote stays until he does or I decide someone else deserves my vote more.

Ditto. Except change Dranko to Coolbot.

[ibaesha]

Freezing, ENYH, and Kerplunk haven't said a word today.

unvote vote: EYNH

. I'm not sure about Coolbot's claim or not, but I'd like to hear from the people who haven't contributed anything before we lynch anyone.

[ibaesha]

Nox, you have four out of six votes against you. Stop buying time and claim. [/quote

Alright.

I'm a science geek, or more generically, a townie.

No special abilities for Noxie

Nanook, Nox's claim didn't come out of nowhere. She claimed when pushed to one yesterday, and her claim was believed then. There's no reason at all she wouldn't talk about this. Now it's you who looks suspicious. You come up with "I too am a shy kid" Right after Coolbot's claim, which is MORE out of no where than Nox reiterating her Day 1 claim. There was no reason for you to claim and I thought it was odd then, but after your last post, I think it was just plain scummy

FOS: Nanook

[ibaesha]

I too would like to wait until we have replacements before moving onward. I find Nanook the scummiest of all still, but we lack the input of three people in this game. It's no surprise that the only people talking would be pointing fingers at each other since there's little else to go on.

[ibaesha]

Welcome Thok and Blackberry

o.O Blackberry. Hmm!

[ibaesha]

unvote

I'm confused about why Nox is suddenly scum. Can someone clarify?

[ibaesha]

It seems this goes back to my original suspicions of Nox on day 1 then. Stuff didn't add up but the claim was believed so I layed off. This game has a lot of claims already.

We've got:
3 person mason: Astronaut, Thok, Blackberry (nerds)
2 Shy kids that aren't masons: Nanook and Coolbot
A dead cop- Teacher's pet
a dead cult leader - Cool kid
Dranko said he believed Nox because his role was similar

I'll go with this and

vote: Nox

I still think that Nanook is somewhat scummy, though.

[ibaesha]

Wow. Glad I figured out that I was insane/paranoid. Thanks to those who replaced and helped us get the last bully!

[ibaesha]

hahaha! That's hilarious. Your 'accurate' investigation had me positive I was paranoid/insane when I had 2 guilty results in a row and you were lying! Glad it all worked out.