Ok I've tried to address things in a more simplified format because there was a lot for me to go over.
My Voting Record:
How can you say that my near perfect voting record compared to your bad voting record makes me more scummy? In your words AmeliaLi's voting record was scummy. I gave you a valid reason as to why I voted Lateralus and then switched my vote to HH later on, if you choose to disregard it then I fail to see what more I can say in my defense.
Also you say because HH got quick hammered while I was away makes me more scummy? I fail to see your logic. Me being on the HH wagon at all makes no sense if you are looking at me as scum. The town was undecided, and Lateralus was digging himself a deeper hole, when I switched my vote, if I was scum it would make a lot more sense for me to keep pushing Lateralus. AmeliaLi's lurking and semi-defense was a lot more scummy to me.
The bottom line is I had valid reasons, yes you can say this is WIFOM and say that scum would act that way, but my actions at the end of the day were pro-town.
Guardian Lying:
I do not understand why you would come out and say that you thought AmeliaLi was town and then change your mind later to scum other than to leave a point that you could come back to later and say "See I'm not scum" to me it doesn't make sense as a good play for town or scum.
Guardian Claim Order:
You say that everyone should wan't to go last in a claim no matter what. I don't believe this. If you were a vanilla townie it would make more sense for you to want the scum to go first and any actual power-role to go last. Instead the order that you suggested put the two most pro-town players at the start and you at the end. I didn't voice any objection at the time because as I said I was under the impression that you were setting town up for a cop-claim. The fact that you didn't claim cop is really a null-tell now because in the end you didn't claim last.
Guardian Ass-Covering:
There was no reason for you to point out Rishi's hammer on YB, other than to put suspicion on Rishi. We as a town had all agreed, to a time frame for YB to make some sort of defense. Considering the lack of effort YB had put into defending himself up to that point, I had assumed that he was playing scum that had given up, and didn't see any problems with Rishi's hammer. For you to come out and say that you only have one vote and didn't think that YB would be lynched after all the emphasis that you put on the deadline for YB to defend himself is almost beyond belief.
Guardian "I'M TOWN"
I find it ironic for you to defend your constantly repeating "I'M TOWN" by saying I do this when I'm town. You cannot expect anyone to believe that you would play differently as scum. Also as I pointed out referencing completed games as a defense is WIFOM. Of course you know of completed games when you acted this way as town. Of course you are going to act the same way and reference them as a defense.
Pleas to emotion
I made one plea to emotion at the point where I was taking a gamble on either winning or losing the game. I didn't use it as a defense. I didn't use it to push my point of view, I was just honestly on the edge of my seat praying that I had made the right decision. If you feel that my one sentence at a pivotal time is a "is a strong indicator of Crub being scum" then I want to know what your continual use in almost every post today is?
My Vote on Guardian
You say I didn't want to discuss things with you. I had discussed things with you. I made it clear that I couldn't come up with any sort of case against Rishi, when you threaten to vote me unless I can come up with a case what am I supposed to do? From my point of view we had passed the point of trying to make a case against Rishi, I had already tried and failed and you had already tried and failed.
Yes I voted straight after your read through. However this was not the first time you made your views clear that you were going to vote me. You already made it clear that you were going to try and make a case against me, and not Rishi. Then when you actually do you find it strange that I vote you? To me, based on your posts today it was obvious that you were going to concentrate on me. You came out and fos'ed me because I had made a case on you. You made a case on me but pretty much ignored Rishi. It was clear to me that we were already at a point in the game where Rishi was going to have to decide who wins this game.
You say it was the "easy" option I took by voting you. By no way was it an easy option, I
was
worried about Rishi being scum, however I felt the chance that Rishi was scum was minuscule compared to you. At some point someone had to take a chance and vote. I took it and I'm glad that I did because I chose correctly.
My RishiTown Vibe/My Lack of Defense
I cannot believe that you are trying to use that I didn't make a case against Rishi to defend myself as a reason why I am scum. I asked you to do the same thing, and you didn't/couldn't. As I said earlier, both you and me agreed that making a case against Rishi was pretty much impossible compared to the case we made against each other. I never said that I didn't suspect Rishi, I said that compared to you the level of suspicion was minuscule.