***Mini Normal 1744 - Country Music Mafia - Game Over***

[RolePlay25]

Hey FA, do you notice how you keep contributing to the game under pressure? That's because you're town. Mala kittens has under no pressure decided to not contribute a damn thing, after a week of not contributing a damn thing. Do you see the difference? I do.

[RolePlay25]

Oh she's not lying about what she's doing in real life. She's exaggerating its impact on her time. She replaced in thinking "I'll have time to handle that, just barely, only one game and it will be fun." Then she drew scum. I doubt she likes playing scum. So it became a convenient excuse. Same with her town read on FA. She knows FA is town, she likes FA but she doesn't want her neck out to save a townie, so we get this vague stuff. The vote on Cow was literally pitiful.


Town mala wouldn't let "outrage" get in the way of playing the game and would offer actual interesting posts, infrequently. What's in her posts, Acryon? Wastelands of nothing. And she uses the posts she admits she barely gets a chance to make to what? Complain people are making jokes and vote for "being a jerk"?

[RolePlay25]

Yeah okay. I'm being the bigger man and not namecalling you back. Now if you want to avoid the game-relevant title "liar" care to point to those oodles of content?

[RolePlay25]

And literally the previous game I was in ActionDan replaced in, claimed to be busy, and posted very little. Scum.

[RolePlay25]

Yeah that's convenient. Scumbag.

See how it's an excuse Acryon? She could post nothing because she's too busy. She could post useful stuff because she's town. Instead she posts fluff to try and elicit sympathy. It's cheap playing on the heartstrings, like a politician. Logically she's scum, so appeal to emotion repeatedly and attack me personally to avoid game-relevant posting.

[RolePlay25]

I don’t think “I was drunk” is a legit defense in mafia.

I recall once I was so plastered that I randomly came onto a game and voted someone with an illegible wall.

They were town :\

Man I don't mean to be needlessly snarky, because I think you're extremely likely to be town, but how did anyone tell that from any other vote?

FA, if you're not going to play ball, then stop back talking to them. It's a waste of space and effort. Go actually pick something useful to do. What do you think of mala kittens?

[RolePlay25]

Either stop responding to them and start scumhunting or claim. You're literally just feeding the frenzy, and it's completely useless.

Pedit: I got bored and decided I wanted to win. Roleplaying is more fun when someone will actually step up and be the town leader and you can have actual conversations with them. But you're scum, so why do you care?

[RolePlay25]

Keyser refused the mantle of leadership, he preferred long analysis to action.

But thanks for telling us why you killed him.

[RolePlay25]

I think I've been fairly clear on that. Mario Maker. Cow. FA. RC. Titus.

But tell me golden, what do you think of Mala kittens?

[RolePlay25]

Actually scratch that.

Let me glance through your posts.

Do tell, who do you think is town and scum, Golden? You haven't lobbed accusations at very many people, because you haven't done much of anything.

[RolePlay25]

If you don't trust yourself enough to make reliable town/scum reads and don't like accusing people, why do you play mafia? It's a bit like me saying "well, I'm playing scrabble, but I hate trying to spell words and really dislike trying to fit them on a grid"

[RolePlay25]

No, I don't follow clowns who fakeclaim. That's amateur hour shit. If you can't get the town to listen to you without lying and theatrics you're not a leader, you're an attention seeker.

[RolePlay25]

No one respects you after the fakeclaim, RC. None. Not a single person. I'll let town do their own thing, especially day 1, but you ain't on the reservation, you ain't near the reservation, you ain't in the same county as the reservation.

[RolePlay25]

"It's a reaction test!" Cool, okay. What do you think of Golden's reaction?

"I'm voting FA because she's anti-town!" When your fakeclaim was what, the epitome of good mafia play?

I'd prefer not to follow the lead lemming, thanks.

[RolePlay25]

Like there comes a point where you should realize "oh, I'm the guy they leave alive in 3 man lylo because even in the strange event my reads are correct they can probably convince the other guy to vote for me".

[RolePlay25]

Golden's reaction was pure scum, RC. Who knows that your cop claim is fake besides Titus?

[RolePlay25]

Yeah okay, I'm not going to bruise that ego I see. You're lucky I'm not a vig.

Now who knows you're town, but also knows you're not a cop?

[RolePlay25]

Yay! You are thinking.

Now who would benefit if we lynch you and Titus, assuming she's town? And who would think they just hit the jackpot but be nervous about trying to cash in too hard?

[RolePlay25]

Is there anyone in the town that you see who desperately wanted to act as if your cop claim was true, but just couldn't bring themselves to 100% commit to something they knew for a fact was false?

[RolePlay25]

Okay, so in closing, I'm just going to say I have about 14 pages of notes from most of the posters in the game that say "RC is acting anti-town/playing bad/whatever". FallenAngel is acting anti-town and run up the "fuck you, I'm gonna do my own thing" flag. The entire thing is anti-town.

Is your vote on the player you believe is most likely to flip scum if they died this second? Mine is.

[RolePlay25]

Are you prepared to throw away today lynching her if she doesn't care?

[RolePlay25]

Okay then. At least you have conviction, even if your course is the edge of a cliff.

But Mala kittens shall die.

[RolePlay25]

I think this one is more like Garfield.

[RolePlay25]

As a social experiment then, have you ever seen survivor, like with that one useless tribe member who never takes part in any challenges, never does anything for the group, and just kvetches when they're called out on it?

[RolePlay25]

Acryon, your vote has no power. No one fears it. It sits on fallen angel, yet she does not fear lynch, for she knows it is nothing but hot air.

You, lead the town? Pah. You fool, you lead nothing. Even scum wouldn't follow something that hollow.

[RolePlay25]

Vote: FA

Yeah, that explains the bullshit from earlier.

If this is another gambit, I'm ripping your lungs out and shoving them down your throat.

[RolePlay25]

This is exactly fucking

can't say word self-censorship

to be true.

[RolePlay25]

So um

If you are town

I want to know why anyone was complaining my play was anti-town on day 1.

Like apparently the level of town play around here involves setting yourself on fire and running in a giant circle

[RolePlay25]

oh fuck it.

Call me scum if you want. You can have a nice lollypop.

Unvote

This is policy, I don't do policy. Unless it's very good policy, and lynch all liars is out the window, and she didn't call her previous incarnation scummy.

[RolePlay25]

Bulletproof

Miller

univestigatable is scum claim. Honestly.

Need to think about this, that's a fucking stupid role to have. Don't think it's town tbh.

[RolePlay25]

It would explain some of RC's play, maybe. But why not play super town man day 1 if you're trying to draw a night kill? The way RC played was custom designed to draw investigative roles and deflect night kills.

[RolePlay25]

People tend to claim something close to their roles. And Aescetic counters town roleblocker quite nicely.

Is this a genuine scum slip in the wild?

[RolePlay25]

@MarioManic: Can I get a FA vote?

@RP: Ascetic doesn't block NK's.

See this is the other reason you're not town leader. You don't read. RC claimed bulletproof.

[RolePlay25]

@MarioManic: Can I get a FA vote?

@RP: Ascetic doesn't block NK's.

See this is the other reason you're not town leader. You don't read. RC claimed bulletproof.

TBH I did miss the 1-shot BP part. What did you think of RC with all of her D1 "claims" to pull a NK?

We interpreted it as noise. Scum clearly interpreted it as noise, if he's town. He contributed nothing of value. What I can't decide is if that's bad play or scum play.

But man letting a bulletproof Miller claim live sticks in my craw.

Pedit: I don't think FA is scum. RC... Man, I hate to play mod meta, but that claim is UGLY

[RolePlay25]

It's honestly one step above NK-immune Miller vig. Fine, said enough until I think but UGH

[RolePlay25]

I am confused as to why Acryon is fine with RC's fake claim, but FA must die and he has no responsibility for her death (as he clearly tells us). That's not inconsistent, that's bipolar.

[RolePlay25]

For the record, lynch all liars is brilliant, and any townie who lies should be aware they're courting death. It just shouldn't be mindlessly applied.

Seeing it applied to FA and not RC is making me super titchy. Although if I had a vig shot, I'd shoot both of them (oh but it wouldn't work on one! The joys of bulletproof millers, can't investigate them, won't ever be night killed)

[RolePlay25]

Like the more I look at it, the more I think RadiantCowbells just claimed scum.

Literally claimed scum.

The fact you people are okay with this frightens me. What the hell has happened here?

[RolePlay25]

Okay, lets walk through. Aesthetic means you can't be targeted by the town doctor or the town roleblocker. Correct? The roleblocker is meaningless for a town ascetic. The doctor is very meaningful - except that RC is bulletproof. So he doesn't need a doctor. Would you ever put an ascetic bulletproof in a game with a town doctor? I mean, ascetic bulletproof is bad enough, but with a town doctor and roleblocker? It literally doesn't make any sense. Nor can we claim mod WIFOM, this isn't some theme bullshit or mini queue experimental, at least four people have to have looked at "town doctor + bulletproof town ascetic" and said "yep, that seems great".

On the other hand, ascetic scum to counter town roleblocker? Oh, that makes so very much sense. So very, very, very much sense.

Vote: RC

Try not claiming scum next scum game.

[RolePlay25]

Like if I'm going to pin my game on anything, it's going to be "no normal queue in the history of the 1744 mini normal played on mafia scum has included a town doctor and a town bulletproof ascetic, because it doesn't make any sense". And I'd be damn willing to bet that's correct.

[RolePlay25]

Mmmm, it's permissible to discuss activity levels - "X is claiming to be out of time and busy in one game, but is posting a storm or moderating a micro game (HI MALA) elsewhere" is fine. I agree you're on an ugly line though.

[RolePlay25]

Cow, as much as I like the hammer, the content of your ISO is somewhere between dismal and appalling.

Although this is a beautiful birthday present for RC~

[RolePlay25]

Merry Christmas! Get lynched!

[RolePlay25]

Is saying Merry Christmas offensive?

[RolePlay25]

Gonna prodge and post another analysis post tomorrow.

There're a lot of new pages and I'm pretty tired from waking up early. I'll not post until the evening when I'll have a clearer head and be able to reread the thread properly.

I'm in the middle of a reread of the day and would like to finish it before I draw any conclusions.

As much as I enjoy our witty banter, the ratio of promises made to promises kept on your analysis is really terrible.

I think there's a 0.00000% chance you die tonight, so you better have something nice to say tomorrow.

[RolePlay25]

Like, there's enough skating for you to be Nancy Kerrigan.

[RolePlay25]

And FYI, for the rest of y'all, I still think Cow is town, but this stuff is helping literally no one. It's not helping people read cow, it's not helping cow read the game, it's just a gigantic black hole. Given we already have Mala kittens promising zero content for the rest of time and space, DWLee delivering similar, and guest starring MarioMaker, we really can't have too many more lurkers before this game stagnates to a town loss.

If I'm dead fyi, kill a kitten for me.

[RolePlay25]

Oh and Titus now has zero excuse to whine about being demotivated. So she better pick up.

[RolePlay25]

Although honestly I don't see scum titus and scum RC doing that dance... eh, pick up anyway Titus.

[RolePlay25]

Oh right. And murder Golden. However did I forget that?

Good god he has less posts than Supercool.

[RolePlay25]

The time is most certainly day 3. As I said, you ain't dyin tonight, so use the time to reread.

[RolePlay25]

Oh and Titus now has zero excuse to whine about being demotivated. So she better pick up.

Been picking up yo.

Good! I like you picked up! It's nice

[RolePlay25]

...

If you were actually an investigative role

And fakeclaimed fucking bulletproof miller

I will fucking cut you

If that is honestly the case and we're not being trolled like fuck, look in the fucking mirror when you want to find who tanked things

[RolePlay25]

I don't actually give a fuck.

Stop lying as town you piece of shit.

[RolePlay25]

Bulletproof miller! That fucking makes sense! I'll just claim that!

Die in a fire.

[RolePlay25]

Are you seriously blaming me for determining that your fake claim was a fake claim?

ARE YOU SERIOUSLY DOING THAT

OH SORRY.

[RolePlay25]

ASCETIC IS MILLER

IT'S THE SAME THING

CAN'T BE INVESTIGATED. CLAIM IN POST 1 OR DON'T CLAIM

JESUS FUCKING CHRIST

[RolePlay25]

The only difference between Godfather/Miller and Ascetic is that one doesn't involve lying on investigations. Which is why ascetic is being favored over either of the other two. WHICH IS WHY WHEN YOU CLAIM BULLETPROOF ASCETIC YOU'RE CLAIMING SCUM GODFATHER


ASFOIEW)RTH(#Q)RTUQRTUQ_@RT#QT(_UI#QT(JU#QWT()JU()AESTGDESGT

[RolePlay25]

I guess I'm a bad player for determining that you were FAKE CLAIMING

Or maybe I'm bad because I thought FAKE CLAIM EQUALS SCUM

Good god. BJI wasn't getting lynched today. You could have played today absolutely normally, but you had to make sure everyone was looking at you. "I'm so clever, no one will see through my brilliant ruse!"

WELL IT WASN'T THAT HARD TO SEE THROUGH

THIS IS WHY LYING IS ANTI-TOWN

[RolePlay25]

FAKE CLAIM

IS SCUM

IT'S A STRAIGHT ONE TO ONE RELATIONSHIP

I MEAN I SUPPOSE WE COULD HAVE A CLOWN FIESTA INSTEAD

[RolePlay25]

Goodbye. Fuck you. Die in a fire.

[RolePlay25]

Lynch MM.

Lynch Cow.

Lynch Titus.

Please shoot me tonight scum