Mini 1725 - Game Over

[ChaosOmega]

Playerlist

Slandaar
MarioManiac4

KTthecreeper

supercool898
Nosferatu
Aristophanes

Annadog40

Hinduragi

makara

revalista

Firesong
RadiantCowbells
Glork
Smudger
Maxous

Shadoxx8

Soapbar
Rory

Spoiler: The Living

MarioManiac4,

mafia goon

, survived
supercool898,

mafia encryptor

, survived

Spoiler: The Not Living

Rory,

town odd-night vigilante

, lynched day 1
RadiantCowbells,

townie

, died night 1
Glork,

town weak motion detector

, died night 1
Smudger,

townie

, lynched day 2
Slandaar,

town encryptor enabler

, died night 2
Aristophanes,

mafia 1-shot roleblocker

, lynched day 4
Hinduragi,

1-shot bulletproof town bodyguard

, died night 4
Firesong,

townie

, lynched day 5
Nosferatu,

townie

, endgamed
Maxous,

townie

, endgamed
Soapbar,

townie

, endgamed

Game Status

Game Over

Rules

1. No outside communication about this game unless your role permits it.
2. Don't quote your Role PM or any out-of-thread communications. Don't fake-quote it, either. Paraphrasing is fine.
3. Do not edit/delete your posts.
4. To vote somebody, either bold your vote, such as

vote: ChaosOmega

, or use vote tags, such as VOTE: ChaosOmega. If your vote isn't bolded or vote tagged, it will not count. Unvotes are not necessary to change your vote.
5. During the day, a player will be lynched when they have more than 50% of the players currently alive voting for them. Once that amount has been reached, they're dead. No unvotes will save them. Players can post in the thread up until I post the lynch scene and the thread is locked.
6. Once it has been posted by me that you are dead, you're dead. Do not post any more,

not even a bah post

.
7. Every day will have a deadline of 2 weeks. Extensions will be given for extreme circumstances.
8. Nights will have a deadline of 2 days. If you have a night action and do not send one, you will do nothing.
9. If you're going to be gone for longer than a 48-hour period, post in-thread letting everyone know for how long. If 48 hours pass without a player posting or saying they will be absent, I will prod them. For the purposes of this rule, the weekend counts as 24 hours.
10. If a player would receive a fourth prod (unless it is their first prod of the day) or they have not responded to a prod within 24 hours, I will search for a replacement for them.
11.

#0040FF is my color. Don't use it.

Also, no small or invisible text or cryptography.
12. Please PM me if you have any questions about the game.
13. Have fun.
14. If anyone breaks any of the aforementioned rules, I have complete control over the actions that will be taken.

Sample Townie Role PM

You are a

Townie

. Your only weapons are your mind and your vote. Use them wisely.

You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and at least one member of the town is still alive.

Please confirm by sending your role to me via PM.

[ChaosOmega]

Role PMs are going out now. When I receive 11/13 confirmations, Day 1 will begin.

[ChaosOmega]

It is now Day 1. With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline is exactly 2 weeks from this post, or in (expired on 2015-10-20 08:54:05).

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Slandaar

Cop head start set up, let's all pile on!

[Annadog40]

VOTE: Nosferatu

I wanna testing something real quick

[Soapbar]

VOTE: Annadog40

"I wanna

testing

something real quick"

IMPROPER GRAMMAR

YOU GET RVS VOTE

[Slandaar]

Let's test a theory and lynch Rory.

VOTE: Rory

[supercool898]

VOTE: revalista

Why do you have an exploding planet as your avatar? That seems very scummy to me...

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Supercool898

non-RVS vote.

[supercool898]

RVS according to Mafiascum Wiki

At the beginning of a game of Mafia, each Townie has precious little information about the setup. As a result, the first set of votes are made with

either no reasoning or humorously flawed reasoning.

VOTE: RadiantCowbells for being wrong about my vote not being RVS.

[RadiantCowbells]

My vote was the one that wasn't RVS.

Also incredibly suspect that you're using a by the book definition for what an RVS vote is.

[supercool898]

Your vote can only be non-RVS if you were also saying mine was.

Otherwise you would have no reason you have given for your vote

PEdit: Oh wait, this is RC I'm playing with... You don't use reasons with your votes...

[RadiantCowbells]

PEdit: Oh wait, this is RC I'm playing with... You don't use reasons with your votes...

[supercool898]

^ My reaction when I first played with you :3

[RadiantCowbells]

I was right tho, so your case is sort of lacking in water holding capabilities.

[supercool898]

Technically

, your vote is still RVS since you didn't add a reason... :P

[RadiantCowbells]

Just because I don't state a reason doesn't mean I don't have one.

Or was my scumread on Accountant 1 day into the game just random as well?

[RadiantCowbells]

I mean you're basically right now saying "HA you don't give reasons" even though you've seen me be right without giving reasons before, which makes me think you're not saying anything here for my benefit.

[Slandaar]

Your vote can only be non-RVS if you were also saying mine was.

Is this true?

Assume everyone makes an RVS vote. If no-one can/should vote someone who made an RVS vote in a serious vain (because nothing can be read into them), then, what is the point of RVS?

[RadiantCowbells]

Assume that no RVS vote can merit a serious vote.

All votes are RVS.

Proof: By Strong Induction.

Let {R0, R1.... RN...} to infinity be the set of all votes made in this game.

1) Base Case: R0 is an RVS vote because there is no prior content.

2) Inductive Step: Let RN be an arbitrary vote made in the mafia game.
Assume R0....RN-1 are arbitrary votes.
Since no prior votes are non-RVS votes, RN is an arbitrary vote.

Therefore, all votes are RVS votes.

QED.

[supercool898]

Just because I don't state a reason doesn't mean I don't have one.

Or was my scumread on Accountant 1 day into the game just random as well?

I'm just giving you a hard time, that is sort of my humor style (it might not be the greatest humor though...).

Your vote can only be non-RVS if you were also saying mine was.

Is this true?

Assume everyone makes an RVS vote. If no-one can/should vote someone who made an RVS vote in a serious vain (because nothing can be read into them), then, what is the point of RVS?

In a normal case, it would be true. The way I looked at it is if he was stating his vote was non-RVS, then in order to make that true, the statement "non-RVS vote" would need to be his reason.

[supercool898]

Oops, almost forgot to respond to Slandaar's second part of his post.

I view RVS as sort of an ice breaker. It allows people to talk and make mistakes. When a person makes a mistake, then that is when RVS starts to end.

[Soapbar]

Your vote can only be non-RVS if you were also saying mine was.

Otherwise you would have no reason you have given for your vote

PEdit: Oh wait, this is RC I'm playing with... You don't use reasons with your votes...

This is hilariously shoddy reasoning combined with (what seems like) an attempt to try and invalidate RC's votes.

Which seems pretty scum yeah

VOTE: Supercool898

[Soapbar]

To be fair, I would like to see RC's reason for thinking his RVS was scummy. I'm positive you were reaction testing but still.

[Soapbar]

Also I missed it but that hilarious OMGUS vote on RC by Supercool is also pretty telling