Quick, bus someone!
![Razz :P](./images/smilies/icon_razz.gif)
Might you possibly elaborate on that? Whose is the most interesting?MacavityLock wrote:I also think we're seeing some rather interesting reactions.
KingEnigma wrote:I want to vote for Elmo, but thats mostly because Elmo hurt my feelings....but I may get over it, but it'll take time.
Really? Which, and why would he do that?MacavityLock wrote:I'm still on the Enigma wagon. I don't see how he's being helpful andI think he specifically posts things in a confusing manner.
His last post is Oct 5th; he was prodded Oct 9th. Given he hasn't responded to it, I would surmise he's being replaced.destructor wrote:18. Prods must be responded toin thread.
19. If you don't reply to your prod within 48 hours you will be replaced.
Thanks, I try to be concise.MacavityLock wrote:Because the way I read it, you're saying two contradictory things in just 4 words. Which is impressive.
Yes.Tarhalindur wrote:Is there a reason for that FoS?
An astute observation.forbiddanlight wrote:You know, people generally have REASONS for saying things.
Your reasoning is backwards. I don't believe he's dropped any scumtells, which is a pre-requisite for believing he's town. I'm not giving your observations as much credit as you do because I disagree with you. Sidenote, I'm fairly sure you have no business calling my attack on you OMGUS, given I killplz'd you before you attacked me.forbiddanlight wrote:But my observations are more sound than you seem to be giving them credit for. As far as I can tell, you are just dismissing every scumtell in the book because you think Tim is town and want to OMGUS me.
Intentional or not, this is a strawman; my point was the disparity between the strength of what I did and you/Tar's stated bloodlust. I think anyone pushing something relatively minor that hard is more likely to be scum looking for an easy lynch than town genuinely trying to find scum. Or would you say what I did was an extremely strong tell?forbiddanlight wrote:Lol wut? So we shouldn't lynch anti town people?
That was addressed to Tar. This doesn't work: If I say that I think making posts like 200 is a scumtell, and the burden of proof's on you to show you'd do that as town - well, if you're town, you would do that, because... you would. You cannot say "a priori X is scummy, Elmo is doing X, therefore Elmo is scum", you need to show both that X is scummy generally and that me doing X here is scummy in this specific situation.forbiddanlight wrote:I personally think the burden of proof is on you. I've never played with you, so I have to use baseline scumtells. Guess what, you are filling them.
I KNOW, RIGHT? I'm thinking surely anyone past a raw newbie can come up with those two.Flask of Pestilence wrote:He says he can't imagine why Elmo-town might act like this; I can think of one protown explanation for Elmo's actions and one neutral one, and the suggestion of policy lynching nearly always pings my scumdar.
Elmo wrote:I am going to deeply enjoy watching TarScum fail at justifying a Flask lynch.
Farkshinsoup wrote:I may have been wrong about Tim/Flask.
Rishi wrote:FoP is looking bettter than Timeater.
iamausername wrote:In other news, Flask of Pestilence has compensated enough for Timeater to make me want to Unvote.
destructor wrote:.::] Vote Count [::.
Flask of Pestilence (1)- Tarhalindur
No, my point was the opposite. It wasn't scummy, but he jumped on it anyway, and someone genuine wouldn't have. I believe only you and Tar know me; the fact that TarRishi wrote:Then, when Tar jumped on the case, Elmo was all like, "Ha! I was being scummy on purpose and you fell for it! I caught you, scum."
Um. Tar and FL were going to be lynched, which is why they full-claimed. No-one apart from them has claimed. We haven't massclaimed. No-one wants to massclaim right now. All we have done is claimcamn wrote:FOS: ELMOfor engineering this massclaim thing so early. I think it tells us much less than we think. . . and gives the scum a lot of targets.
Hopefully it will work out.
Please elaborate on both points. I don't like this post.MacavityLock wrote:camn's refusal to claim whether or not she's a cylon leads me to believe something's up. That plus KE's general scumminess before dropping out
This is why the cylons need to know. Certainly at least one cylon appears to have believed they were nominally scum, which would obviously hurt our scumhunting. The humans need to know because it's natural to assume cylons = scum. Specifically, if I had seen "FL was lynched, she was a cylon", I would have thought she was definitely scum. It should be evident why I need to know that is not necessarily the case.forbiddanlight wrote:K, I'm a cylon affiliated with the cylons. Do you want a name?I have no idea if I'm town, scum, or what, just that I don't know anyone elses alignment
Tarhalindur's Standard Rule Set wrote:<1a> Attempting to use loopholes in the rules to gain an advantage in the game is considered jackassery, and will be treated as such. This applies to things like encrypted codes, invisible text, editing and deleting posts,trying to use the structure of the role PM to gain an advantage, etc. Please, use your common sense!
Pretty sure I didn't ask you anything about the structure of your role PM. Also pretty sure that specifically telling you to be careful about modkills and to paraphrase stuff as needed directly contradicts what you just posted.Elmo wrote:Tarhalindur and forbiddanlight: Please state or paraphraseeverypiece of information in your role PM. Don't get modkilled.
Yo, forbiddanlight. To the extent you can, comment on this? It didn't sound like you *had* a faction. You just claimed you were affiliated with "the cylons", right? I don't understand how KoC can genuinely have this information if you don't have something comparable.iamausername wrote:Was anyone else given this much information about their alignment?Knight of Cydonia wrote:I'm a Centurion allied to Natalies/D'Anna (forbiddan)'s faction.
I don't understand KoC's distinction between "make" and "model". But I am wondering precisely how a centurion would be able to gain information about a humanoid cylon.battlestarwiki wrote:Furthermore, the Centurions are unable to distinguish one copy of humanoid Cylon from another.
I don't understand why you'd breadcrumb something and complain about people not immediately picking up on it. That seems to defeat the point of a breadcrumb. If you want to announce something.. just say it?Knight of Cydonia wrote:Jeez, how loudly do I have to breadcrumb things? Surprised no-one picked up more on the fact that I said there were definitely two Cylon groups. I'll put it out there for the idiots.