Mini 938: Weeds Mafia (GAME OVER)

[McGriddle]

/confirm

[McGriddle]

Hi Grid.

AHHHHH!

Okay, hopefully this game goes better between us Ythan. I am willing to start this fresh haha

[McGriddle]

sweet, the guy I replaced with is now replacing someone else in which we are in a game together. Oh how life is so crazy sometimes lol.

[McGriddle]

welp that's 12/12

[McGriddle]

Vote: Konowa

for putting a second vote on magna

[McGriddle]

@ Leech - What is your ideal role? Would you rather be town or scum? Explain why.

@ horrordude0215 - If you were at L-1 and you were a simple townie, would you claim a PR to try to save your own ass and catch actual scum instead of you? (I can go into much more detail about this but I will leave it at this for now.)

@ Fate - Are you good at playing scum or not? Explain why.

@ The1fifi - Which is a better tell, lurking or over-defensiveness? Explain why.

@ MagnaofIllusion - How would you trap a possible scum target? (meaning you troll them or something of that sort)

@ thatguy00 - If you thought Player X was scum would you just vote them and give reasons from their previous statements, or would you ask a few questions before placing a vote? Explain why.

@ Ythan - Do you believe it is a good idea to policy lynch someone in 1 game because of something that happened in another? (lol) Explain why.

@ BrokenBlueprints - What do you think about policy lynching? Explain why.

@ Sando - What do you think about people who go V/LA a lot during a game? Are they scummy for it or not? Explain why.

@ ooba - What do you think about Lynch All Liars? Explain why.

@ Konowa - Who would you kill right now if you had the chance to kill someone? (ie day killing vigilante) Explain why.

[McGriddle]

@ horrordude0215 - If you were at L-1 and you were a simple townie, would you claim a PR to try to save your own ass and catch actual scum instead of you? (I can go into much more detail about this but I will leave it at this for now.)

Hell no... lynch all liars goes into place there... then the real power role would cc and town would lose it in a NK. It's a dumb situation to be in

This is debatable. I don't think (on day 1) a cc would occur. I don't think a PR would want to give himself up so early in the day. The biggest possibility that could happen is the real PR could push for his lynch still and in return the real PR gets killed, then the fake-claiming townie would get killed the next day. So I couldn't see a counter clam unless the person was either really scummy or the real PR was stupid.

@ Everyone: you may answer any questions out of the list that you would like too. They are general questions, not specific to anyone in particular.

[McGriddle]

My name is McGriddle lol

[McGriddle]

@ thatguy00 - to quote you click the "Post Reply" button, and highlight what you want quoted, then select the "quoute" button.

[McGriddle]

sheesh, I am just trying to get conversation going. There is nothing about that that is distracting. It is all about what kind of players people are so in the future of the game we know their style of play. Also there is nothing going on in the game.

[McGriddle]

Vote: Ythan

for being mean to everyone ever, and accusing my questions of being scummy. They are general questions, not really that special.

[McGriddle]

Whoops meant konowa

Unvote, Vote: Konowa

[McGriddle]

EBWODP: and he also looks like he is jumping at a quick wagon after what f1fi said. BTW f1fi don't hold a grudge on me for that other game I am not allowed to speak about lol.

[McGriddle]

Oh please, like you're perfect T.T You called me thatguy, why don't you keep THAT straight?

[McGriddle]

@ Leech - What is your ideal role? Would you rather be town or scum? Explain why.

@ horrordude0215 - If you were at L-1 and you were a simple townie, would you claim a PR to try to save your own ass and catch actual scum instead of you? (I can go into much more detail about this but I will leave it at this for now.)

@ Fate - Are you good at playing scum or not? Explain why.

@ The1fifi - Which is a better tell, lurking or over-defensiveness? Explain why.

@ MagnaofIllusion - How would you trap a possible scum target? (meaning you troll them or something of that sort)

@ thatguy00 - If you thought Player X was scum would you just vote them and give reasons from their previous statements, or would you ask a few questions before placing a vote? Explain why.

@ Ythan - Do you believe it is a good idea to policy lynch someone in 1 game because of something that happened in another? (lol) Explain why.

@ BrokenBlueprints - What do you think about policy lynching? Explain why.

@ Sando - What do you think about people who go V/LA a lot during a game? Are they scummy for it or not? Explain why.

@ ooba - What do you think about Lynch All Liars? Explain why.

@ Konowa - Who would you kill right now if you had the chance to kill someone? (ie day killing vigilante) Explain why.

1. Scum, because I am alright at being scum.

2. Debateable but I would be honest.

3. Like I said, I am okay at being scum.

4. I like over-defensiveness, from experience, lurkers are 50-50 scum or lazy town. So OD is a good tell when they have 1 or 2 votes on them.

5. I would continuously pressure them, and if they are scum, hopefully crack.

6. I would ask questions.

7. It's not a good idea to use meta to policy lynch someone else.

8. Policy lynching is okay sometimes. If someone is liability to the town and 1 scum is already killed, then it's a pretty good bet that it is useful.

9. V/LA is null to me. Possibly a scum tell if they use it enough.

10. LAL is not really a good tell. could be bad town, could be bad scum. Either way its bad but it depends on the situation.

11. I wouldn't kill anyone. Maybe, if I were forced, Ythan.

[McGriddle]

For that post? Reads as newbie to me.

I have been playing this game too long to let this slip go untouched.

Unvote, Vote: Ythan

You rarely ever use the reads newbie excuse, you are usually the one arguing against that tell.

[McGriddle]

What Ythan? I'm an idiot? Is that not mod killable? personal attacks?

[McGriddle]

Hey, McGriddle!
I seeeee you.
Come post with us.

That's creepy lol.

nothing is really sticking out to me. I am watching this topic very closely right now. Any questions you have directed for me?

[McGriddle]

Regarding Ythan, I do believe he is scum-hunting. His posting at the speed of light, sometimes, bothers me, but I agree with some of the observations he has made.

I'll be able to post in more detail in the next 24 hours but respond quickly to this point.

What observations do you agree with?

Ythan's posts are specifically crafted in a way to most shield himself from scrutiny. They are brief. He has usually dismissed criticism as scummy, newbish or simply stated it was wrong without providing support.

Is this scummy? Perhaps. But also it may simply be a carefully honed tactic to try to irritate players into overzealous responses, looking for the Over-defensiveness he indicated was a scum-tell.

Unvote: Ythan

@ McGriddle - Other than taking pot-shots at Ythan for what appears to be a long standing grudge between the two do you have any other suspicious suspects?

No I do not. Ythan is scum. And you are right. Long standing grudge, but that's not affecting my vote.

[McGriddle]

stupidity just keeps pushing my buttons

Then get smart?

Ythan, why can't you just be a respectable player like everyone else? Why must you ALWAYS personally attack people. It gets old REAL effing old.

[McGriddle]

Point one, Sando plays like a human and I have seen the extent of his response to my attack.

Point two, Grid is astronomically, incomprehensibly, cosmically anti-town in any role and needs to be either lynched or NKed as soon as is convenient.

Therefore

unvote vote McGriddle

You have never in the handful of games I've played with you been anything but a pox on town and I don't expect that it will be any different here.

Am I the only one who finds this absolutely nuts?

Although there is a point in there. I haven't been lurking there are just a few reasons why I haven't posted in this games. I am busy with college, the arguments neither contain anything I can pull out as a scum tell, and no posts are requiring my attention. Basically not much is going on. No reads, and nothing directed at me.

[McGriddle]

Thank you

[McGriddle]

Hello. Starting my read but if you would all tell me who is scum it would help immensely.

Ythan

[McGriddle]

look at 236 fitz.

[McGriddle]

My my my. I think I hit a nerve with 329.
@horror: Try not to ask questions that I have already answered. In my last post, I specifically stated that I would gladly lynch either Sando or Leech. In fact, you even state that my iso 16 (post 329) is full of "nothing but questions", meaning that you read it and promptly ignored in a bad attempt to misrep me. Definitely something to remember.
In fact, you saying that I have done "nothing else" in those posts is a misrep.

Tell me, why do you ask me for my top suspects when I just listed them?
Do you have that short of a memory, or you just do not like me listing Leech and Sando as who I would lynch? Right now, I am leaning more towards the latter, especially given your commentary on Leech earlier in the day.

Hit nerve or not he is right.

[McGriddle]

Fate, how many times have you switched your vote between the 2 now? lol

[McGriddle]

Sure,

Scum:
Ythan
Thatguy
Sando
Ooba

[McGriddle]

Oh I meant to take Ythan off an

Unvote

[McGriddle]

Meh the reason I am not voting Ythan is I have learned to be accepting of his ways. I just let it go now.

[McGriddle]

Meh the reason I am not voting Ythan is I have learned to be accepting of his ways. I just let it go now.

That doesn't address the second part of my post... please give reasoning for your supects

no

[McGriddle]

Sorry guys forgot to say I was V/LA but it doesn't matter. Ooba you can disagree with me all you want, but the fact that you think everyone is scummy makes me

Unvote, Vote: Ooba

[McGriddle]

And that was as OMGUS as it gets.

I have more of a case on you, but as it is easter I have RL obligations that require more attention and I will post my case either tonight or tomorrow.

[McGriddle]

This is stupid -.-*

[McGriddle]

Oh because you always contribute so much

[McGriddle]

I am town.

[McGriddle]

Okay,

I am town.