NY 114: Mafia vs. Werewolves (Game Over)

[Faraday]

unvote vote chronopie

biggest bandwagon and a 31 page day 1 is ridiculous. let's do this I trust the reasons are good.

[Faraday]

Cut by replacement: Faraday manages to stun me like none have in recent memory. In spite of being the one saying it, I'm not sure if that's a compliment.

@Faraday

- How much of the game have you read?

pages 1-4 and this page.

[Faraday]

*I would like for Parama to tone down and/or cease posting. We get the idea.

I CANNOT BE SILENCED

please don't spam the thread it makes it harder for replacements to

pretend they've

read the thread.

(I've been following alongish too, Vi so no need to worry)

The Supersmash guy is town btw. I think nhammen is town too.

[Faraday]

*I would like for Parama to tone down and/or cease posting. We get the idea.

I CANNOT BE SILENCED

please don't spam the thread it makes it harder for replacements to

pretend they've

read the thread.

(I've been following alongish too, Vi, so no need to worry)

The Supersmash guy is town btw. I think nhammen is town too.

[Faraday]

hmm having read over the thread pretty quickly i have to say it's been one giant clusterfuck, a lot of stupidity at times.

i think all the masons and monks are town, btw. that's more-so me trying to outguess the mod than anything else, but i think it'd be a neat thing to do, reminds me of iam's emerald city to some degree.

nhammen and foilist both look pretty town, the latter especially.

serial is probably town too, and smash bro is town for his early game behaviour which looks very n00b town to me. parama's attack was understandable though so I don't find him scummy for it really.

[Faraday]

i've just listed 10 or so town reads, i'm working for there, give me a chance. also disagree as it gives you a load to analyse. but it is a 32 page thread, give me a fucking chance.

not upset with my current vote, don't like his jump on the nhammen wagon overly much.

[Faraday]

*from there

[Faraday]

Don't give town reads because that tells the mafia who to kill.
Stick to giving scum reads and only scum reads (neutral reads MAYBE)

give scum reads and neutral reads and the scum will never ever be able to work out who you think is town? lol.

ANYWAY READING THE THREAD NOW GAIZ AGAIN.

[Faraday]

page ten makes me want to kill myself.

[Faraday]

ebwop: page ten makes me want to kill myself

[Faraday]

i'd not be overly upset at sevis/sgraiize/dry-fit/leafsnail all being shot by a multi day vig so if anyone's holding back, there's no need. timeater too maybe.

pman needs to post a lot more, 6 posts at this stage (and no content in them) is unacceptable. earlier town reads look all the more right. Vi's pretty townie and is scumhunting. even if she's scum it probably won't be a game deciding factor anyway so it's okay. out of the masons/monks I think there's a slim chance of scum, lynchmepls and seraphim are really town looking due to stuff and i'm obv town, so if there is scum ..well yeah it can't be vas either, so yeah there's probably no scum in them i think.

lol that was rambly.

i believe nhammen's claim at this stage too.

lowell's as townie as he can be I think, he's hard to read but at this stage he looks more town than scum.

[Faraday]

Faraday made my day.
I can't wait to talk to him in the mason chat. He says that the masons should be town and he had a bandwagon on him.
@mafia side: Can you Nightkill faraday? He's clearly the werewolf in the mason group.

you're an idiot. stop being an idiot. what does me having a bandwagon on me have to do with ANYTHING at all.



Other stuff: Unsight's been backgroundish. Also she's not a mason, I am, so therefore scum (note this is a joke due to previous games together)

I prefer a Raiize wagon to chronopie but it doesn't look like anyone else thinks the same.

[Faraday]

unvote

for reasons why read the thread and note the large amount of facepalm worthy things already, don't want an 'accidental' hammer.

[Faraday]

nhammen/foilist/chrono scumteam, I already told you guys this

this seems a bad guess.

plus there's 2 scum teams anyway it's pretty much assured.

eh waiting for the flip.

POM might be scum.

i might be v/la the next couple of days, my uncle's in hospital.

[Faraday]

Good question.

In other news

Vote SGRaaize

[Faraday]

^^^Maybe you got roleblocked by nhammen.^^^

The post definitely does read that way, I'll give you that.

[Faraday]

Hey I'll just unvote and vote sgrra...owait I was already voting him ^_^ go me.

[Faraday]

Other stuff: Unsight's been backgroundish. Also she's not a mason, I am, so therefore scum (note this is a joke due to previous games together)

Was too busy being backgroundish on Day 1 to reply but you totally replaced in just to say this didn't you?

Good question.

In other news

Vote SGRaaize

Why is no one else commenting on this?

SGR's sole contributions to Day 1 were trying to lynch the masons and asking if he was himself a dumbass.

@Faraday: What do you think of MS, SSBF, and LMP?

Latter 2 are very likely town. MS = Midnight Sorrow I assume. Haven't paid much attention, lots of fluff posts but I get a sort of newb town vibe off of him instead of newb scum unlike say the person I'm currently voting. Will probably re-evalutate tomorrow, and read some people in iso.

[Faraday]

oh look, a wagon.

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow

doopdedoopdedoo

herp derp i'm gonna play kwl and vote for kwl reasons u gaiz ^_^

[Faraday]

hmm about half the game are looking pretty town to me, i'd put a bullet in the other half in pretty much any order if I could though.

need to re-read too as there;s people not even registering on my radar either way, e.g. askbob and dr robotnik.

[Faraday]

the midnight sorrow bandwagon is interesting btw. the intiial reasons were b/c he didn't do fuck all? same could be applied to the guy people are currently switching too. so yeah.

[Faraday]

I roleblocked SGR.

I don't think there is any chance of NK WIFOM, but there is something else I am worried about.

More comments after I catch up on ... 3 pages in the past 12 hours? Which will happen after the movie I'm watching ends...

In the meantime:

vote SGR

Something else? You mean the fact that all our masons and monks are still alive while a non-mason, non-monk is dead?

vote: SGR

Why does this worry you. Unless you think we're all scum

[Faraday]

GOD DAMN IT WHY IS THE SITE BEING SO FUCKING SLOW JESUS.


I don't understand why people think the roleblock means nothing, he's very likely scum WITHOUT the block and this makes it more likely.

[Faraday]

i'll be back properly soon and stuff but just checking in.


Uh, I really still want Socrates dead. Raaize was scummy as fuck without the block and I think the block makes him MORE likely to be scum.

Nhammen is still town. Gut is screaming town from his play.

lemme see can I read up properly.

[Faraday]

Town:
foilist13
Faraday
Lowell
LynchMePls
nhammen
Parama
SpyreX
SerialClergyman
Unsight
vezopiraka
Super Smash Bros. Fan

I think they're all self explanatory^ some are stronger than others but w/e


Dr. Robotnik
Dry-fit
askbob
Leafsnail
Midnight's Sorrow
Nachomamma8
Pomegranate
Shrinehme
Socrates
Nikanor
Timeater

The people on the not town have varying degrees of scumminess. I'd not mind all of them dying at once though, in fact I think that it'd contain pretty much all the scum.

Socrates/Shrin/Dry-fit as my top 3 I think.

Unsure on the MS wagon, I'm not actively against it but I think there are better options.

[Faraday]

11 on each LIST. Need more townies itt.

[Faraday]

read nacho in iso, pman's lurking was annoying and scummy as he's usually like a rabbit on crack in terms of posting but maybe it was site wide (note: go check).

dr robotnik's a better wagon too, I like the case put forward by nacho

[Faraday]

WE SHOULD LYNCH SOCRATES GUYS. WHY WON'T ANYONE LYNCH SOCRATES.

I think Robotnik's slightly better than SHRIN having read back but I'm good with either so let's get this done so I can go to my masonry and LOL DISCUSS stuff.

If we have a vig they best be fucking shootan tonight. There's enough targets ofr 6 vigs so ship up and shoot

[Faraday]

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH


@ Nacho IDK my vote is on who I think is most likely to be scum, I've no idea why the soc wagon fell apart. RAIIZE was horribly scummy.

unvote vote ROBOTNIK

looks scummier than MS who has a slightly better chance of being town.

[Faraday]

Depends how long it takes you

ETA on a catch up would be helpful, but I don't suppose it matters as this day has been looooong.

Happy with the shrin lynch. I suppose we should get a claim before he goes but whatever.

[Faraday]

Oh apparently the MS wagon disappeared. Never mind that then.

I still think socrates should be dead but whatever.

[Faraday]

idr what's happening here from the downtime lemme read up...

oh wait yeah we're lynching scum >_> never mind.

[Faraday]

Depends how long it takes you

ETA on a catch up would be helpful, but I don't suppose it matters as this day has been looooong.

Happy with the shrin lynch. I suppose we should get a claim before he goes but whatever.

haha cheeky git!

I'll start now shall i boss?

BM

Nah, it's just this day's been long already. Just do what I did and skim the middle pages at first, they're choc full of stupidity.

[Faraday]

who'd BM replace?

[Faraday]

OOH AHH JUST A LITTLE BIT OOH AHH A LITTLE BIT MORE

[Faraday]

haha top of the page.

we could always change the wagon to socrates scum. where's SHRINE anyway? he should claim or something.

the whole put your life on them being scum thing is of course stupid, as you can't be 100% sure unless you're scum with them but it's not scummy.

UH ANYTHING ELSE? NO, let's go.

[Faraday]

@ our moronic vig/prospective sk. Do us a favour and shoot yourself next time instead of shooting a town power role. LOTS OF FUCKING LOVE.


Hold the fucking phone.

Why are people so much more interested in lynching socrates today than yesterday. I mean the nhammen kill seems like a bad vig to me.

I am sure one of either the monk or the masons are mafia seeing how the kill goes.

No explain. The two most obv town players in the game being killed isn't a surprise in all honesty.

Need to read up.

[Faraday]

it's interesting to note if socrates isn't scum at least one of the mafia factions would have a good idea he's a mislynch - or at the very least not part of the scumgroup with the wrong kill. going to try and re-read the thread with this in mind.

[Faraday]

Vote: Socrates

I used my one-shot vig to kill nhammen last night. My existance makes me think that there isn't another vigilante loose (and probably not an SK because 4 kills a night is freaking ridiculous), so I think it's extremely likely that Socrates is scum at this juncture. You guys can argue your bullshit mislynch theory tomorrow, but I honestly believe we've hit scum today.

OH GOD WHY DID YOU DO THAT I DON'T EVEN.

[Faraday]

WHY NOT HIT ONE OF OUR SCUMMYVI'S?

I believe the claim though I guess.

[Faraday]

nacho's vigging looks even poorer in the light of some recent posting.

eh unsight's seemed mildly townish up to now. I'll read IT later and see what the story is I guess.

[Faraday]

@Faraday: I recall (not 100% sure on this one, I may be thinking of someone else) you pointing out Socrates as scum several times. Why are you not voting him now?


still thinking mostly. I don't like the people who've had some sort of fucking epiphany overnight due to nhammen's flip. he obviously wasn't going to be lying about his role (i.e. ) scum blocker so I want to re-read the people who were 'it's not conclusive yesterday' and are voting him today.

other than that he's still pretty high up on my suspect list but there doesn't seem to be any rush.

[Faraday]

Sorry been like forgetting about this game and stuff.

I don't object to the Socrates wagon, but my gut is tingling now despite my head saying lynch lynch lynch. It feels like it's going to be a mislynch.

[Faraday]

Parama or Faraday are scum with Lowell, but not both.

Unvote

Let's say Socrates is town.

Vote: Parama

BM

all 3 of these people are prob town.

[Faraday]

Hey BM do you think Lowell's a werewolf or in the mafia?

[Faraday]

Am I crazy to think Pom is scum?

I don't know if BM is trying to confuse the town with that post or what.

No. I think she's scum too.

BM should run a second doctor who mafia on an unrelated note.

[Faraday]

the unsight case is on wherein some people think Unsight know's too much (i.e. seems to be sure soc will flip town) thus she'd be from the scumgroup with the missing kill? is that right or am I missing something (like is that a fair part of the case?)

[Faraday]

But how could ANYONE know someone is gonna flip town? Again, this only works if someone somehow knows who's in the mafia team AND who's in the werewolf team. Personally, I think Midnight's Sorrow genuinely thought Shrinehme was a member of the enemy scumteam, which is why he agreed to die if he flipped town (a promise which, by the way, he's now broken. I can't see any reason why he's still alive). Foilist too... he's even started deflecting to The Guy Who He Thinks Is Scum But Who He Doesn't Want To Vote For Some Reason. There is still NO explanation for why Foilist refused to vote Midnight's Sorrow (who was on his scumlist) due to "lack of reasons" and then votes Shrinehme with literally no new points.

well OK, not know they'll flip town but think about it.

you know your teams kill didn't go through and the socrates is being pushed because of the roleblock. you obviously know he's not scum because of that so there's a fair chance he's gonna be town.

[Faraday]

Sorry been like forgetting about this game and stuff.

I don't object to the Socrates wagon, but my gut is tingling now despite my head saying lynch lynch lynch. It feels like it's going to be a mislynch.

You were more active in both Mafia 110 and Mini 939. What's going on?

Who are your top 3 suspects and why?

it's summer time.


HMM top 3?

Socrates
BM
Pom


Actually Pom's flying under the radar massively, I don't really remember anything from her in regard to who she suspects or who she thinks is town or anything. Maybe that's my fault.

[Faraday]

I'll give this game a read through later and catch some scum. Off shopping now.

[Faraday]

vote battle mage.


called me scum. let's fucking lynch him.

[Faraday]

lol oops too much drink.

vote bm

[Faraday]

i'm v/al for like idk 2 days max. will post after i sleep which will hopefully be soon.

[Faraday]

i was just glad to be killed. outting the masons and monks early was really really fucking stupid though. they were the strongest town weapon here and welp.

[Faraday]

also way too many replacements hurt the town badly. althogh fair play on getting them.

[Faraday]

ssbf your play wasn't too bad, you were really obv town which is probably one of the things that's underrated on this site by some. looking town as town isn't something you should ignore, yeah finding scum is great but if you're scummy as fuck you're going to be lynched (more than likely). thought lowell was really obv town too.

sorry to socrates. idk I didn't really give you much of a chance due to being pretty sold on raiize scum. Oh well, good playerlist, enjoyed it. gg scums.

[Faraday]

Lowell was pretty obv town though. Him being lynched would have been ridiculous.