NY129-Mafia on Werewolf Island! (Game Over)

[Charlie]

Hi guys. I'll start reading the thread from the beginning, but I won't be going through each an every post in detail.
I guarantee a neat summary when I'm done.

[Charlie]

Guys, I like the Snake-wagon, but I prefer lynching confirmed scum over 99% scum, the odds you know. Come to us, I have cookies!

You have my attention here.

[Charlie]

No rope for you, Nacho.
No rope.
No.

[Charlie]

The horror... the horror.

[Charlie]

Read up to page 11.

[Charlie]

Bulletproof SK is more likely.

[Charlie]

Sadly, you're right. Even more sadly for you, you're not going to survive to endgame. How do you feel about getting your kills totally dictated by others?

[Charlie]

Oh dear.

[Charlie]

I say we direct this so-called vig.

[Charlie]

I admit that I'm a lurker, but the fact is I'm lazy in this game. I pro-mice that I'll get some things done Today!

[Charlie]

A moment of silence for the dead...

[Charlie]

Oh yes, I'm sorry.
Look at these votes all over the place, how messy.

[Charlie]

VOTE: mastin2

[Charlie]

Verbrosity is scummy.
Conciceness is pro town.

[Charlie]

Yikes. The more I delay, the more posts piles up and the more reading I'd have to do. Hate to admit it, but I've done little catching up on this game. It certainly is neglected by be. But I firmly believe I can catch up, I just need... more time.

[Charlie]

Have an unvote.
UNVOTE: mastin2

[Charlie]

Summary of players:

2. ConSpiracy - Funny in a good way at page 11.
4. Charlie replacing kr0b
5. Lowell
6. Eldritch replacing Lord MaxKojote
7. Reckamonic replacing RayFrost - Foo. Page 9 says scum.
9. quadz08 replacing Lucresia
10. gorilla
11. T-Bone - Town. Page 11 says Town.
12. Nachomamma8 - Town or Third Party. If I'm wrong I'll eat my hat.
13. Pine - Page 5 says scum. Page 8 says scum.
15. Chronopie - Page 11 says scum.
16. Kise
17. singersigner replacing Shift - Page 9 says Town.
18. implosion - Town at page 11, for the record he's Town when he made a good first impression x2.
19. C-Worl - Page 5 says scum. Page 10 appears really unconvincing; for the record this whole page is full of nonsense.
20. MrZepher
22. RaudhrGarm replacing [Moonstruck]
23. tclawren - Page 9 says Town.
24. Powerrox93 eplacing bristep123

Dead:
8. SnakePlissken,

Vanilla Townie

, Put to Death Day 1!
1. Nero Cain,

Town Seer,

Shot in the Chest Night 1!
14. Nobody Special,

Town Voyeur

, Choked to Death Night 1!
21. Thor665 (who replaced Seraphim),

Town Jailkeeper

, Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 1!

[Charlie]

Allright, here's the truth: I read up my notes, the ones where I caught up to page 11 and then continued at page 12 only to find that I have no idea what I just wrote. I'm not focused enough to actually "fully catch up" in this game.

So in order to make myself more useful I can either:
1) Follow the newer posts
2) Replace out

I'd like to do option 1 if you guys don't mind. Out of courtesy to the mod, this game has had 9 replacements already and I'd rather not be a statistic.
Above are the raw notes I've been keeping, for record's sake.

[Charlie]

Charlie, if you read this (probably not, since you are a lurker). Prove you read this with voting Pine.

I did read this.

@Pine: Please, no self-voting.

[Charlie]

I think the best choice of lynch is Reckamonic the claimed PGO. His posting style... just doesn't feel right. I keep a strangeposting-o-meter, and its not broken.

VOTE: Reckamonic

I un-eagerly anticipate nothing to happen.

[Charlie]

VOTE: Reckamonic

[Charlie]

^Because I can't find myself to believe a PGO claim early game.

[Charlie]

T-Bone, your claim does not make sense.

[Charlie]

OK. A sentence by sentence analysis.

He said he think PGO isn't Normal, as in fitted into Normal games. I think that's wrong, because PGO is perfectly Normal to me. Unfortunately, after looking up on the wiki, there are no references. Hey, let's try asking the

Mod: Is Paranoid Gun Owner (PGO) a Normal role?

No harm in asking that, right?

He said no one is calling them instant scum. Well, I've been ignored then.

He said when he read Nacho's ISO, he thought Reckamonic was scum. To some degree we click here. It's one of those 'aha' moment's I've caught on. See, Nacho as Mafia does stuff like good-posting initially then there is a pause, then not so good-posting later. I know this because of a certain Large Theme game a long time ago where Reck was one of the mods. This sort of behaviour I've detectable through actively reading the thread and scanning of levels of activity, not so much through ISO. Now, I would say based on this behaviour alone, Reck and Nacho are behaving similarly and thus there is a good chance they're in league with each other i.e. Reck is Mafia.

Mentioning the past events in the game, which I sadly don't really get, makes me unqualified to leave a comment on this sentence. Based on the flips, we have 3 other Town PRs, a Mafia Goon & a Bulletproof SK. There is a likelihood that the other Neighbour is anti-Town; I'll have to look up on the claim later.

I dunno about that neighbour comment, I'm willing to assume that both are Town for now.

Overall, implosion's #2038 is enlightening; I can see this post either way.

[Charlie]

So much violence.
VOTE: Reckamonic

[Charlie]

Actually amuse me Charlie
Why are you voting me. I mean, beside the fact that regardless of faction those are the most idiotic kills I could've ever considered pushing.

I'm actually tempted to say because you're Werewolf. But, I think a better answer would be because you claimed PGO early on, and IIRC somewhere or another this increases the likelihood of the claim being false.

[Charlie]

What's a Vig Pool?

[Charlie]

Ooh, classy. Vig the claimed PGO. He'll flip something else.

[Charlie]

Ooh. Cop claim. Seer flip. Symmetry. Balance. Harmony. Zen.
*sparkly*
Hang on while I do some analysis.

[Charlie]

mastin2, would you like to CC gorilla?

[Charlie]

@ConSpiracy: I can't speak from my modding experience. I've only done Minis. This is a Large. Reckamonic the non-PGO should be your guy to ask. But based on what I've read, Large Games with not equal number of Mafia A and mafia B can be done balanced.

[Charlie]

Would you kindly answer my question?

[Charlie]

That wasn't so hard now, was it?
The lynch pool today is one of these 2 jokers.

[Charlie]

Reckamonic, you're not Today's lynch.
UNVOTE: Reckamonic

[Charlie]

I think I need to lie down.

[Charlie]

Major props to DemonHybrid for writing the flavour, I was thoroughly entertained! It made the game a much more fun experience.
Also, I believe he did his best as a mod with all those funky speedbumps this game had (modkill, replacements, minor errors)

Congrats to the werewolves for pulling a victory even with a team member modkilled.

Boo to mastin for killing a guy sitting quietly in the corner, minding his own business (Jk, he was a major talk-o-logist who at times seem like he has lost his mind. So much lulz were had upon reading his posts, moar so when DemonHybrid intergrated his personality into his death flavour).

Good game all.