In post 3810, Juls wrote:Bookitty/Seol
Possibly mafia with
: GreenCrayons
Probably not mafia with
: VitaminR (weak), Yosarian
The only notes I had on Seol was the thing I have already mentioned about STD saying there are scum in
{pj, seol, poro, gc}. Also, I took note of the argument that
CES made that Seol replacing out seems more in line with scum as she would have been excited to come back and play as town (would be invested) but as scum not as invested. I don't know Seol's meta but it was a reasonable argument to me.
Bookitty, however, has troubled me. The first thing I noted is that when she came into the game, she said
LML was not scummy but then only a couple of hours later says he is
high on her scumlist (or at least higher than SSK). Then even later that day he is
null leaning scum. OK, I can probably let all that slide. A little inconsistent but it's ok. So then she started saying it's
ok to lynch me. By the end of day one, I wasn't feeling good about the Bookitty slot (I have more notes on day one...will get to that in a second). Flash forward to day two. She says that she thought LML was
crumbing role blocker. From that point I felt better about Bookitty. Things started making sense. Until I realized, that she had noted LML's crumb
before she replaced in. Now I don't understand the chain of events and it feels like she used it as an excuse to not be on the LML wagon. The claim of VT and saying "go ahead and lynch me" bought her a lot of town cred. She may very well be town but I am viewing this with a very skeptical eye.
The few other notes from day one I have on Bookitty are
her self deprecation. I have never played with Bookitty before so I don't know if this is normal for her or not. I also liked what pj noted
here which was that Bookitty had referenced several times that she read pregame, she had read the thread again, reread the thread again but she hadn't posted anything of substance to that point. Then she did what I have called her behind the curtain posts. The
first one I thought was good, it made me feel a little better about her but the
second one just seemed to ramble and confused me. Later while reviewing my notes I realized that it was mostly game recap without any real analysis/conclusions drawn. There were a few but nothing that couldn't be summarized in a line or two.
The reason I have her as not scum with VitR was because
post 499 where VitR asks chamber why he doesn't like Bookitty and basically agrees with everything she has said. It's weak though because it could be faked.
Also, if Bookitty were to flip scum I think
this post will be a good one to revisit. She makes a lot of definitive statements about who is scum and who is town so we should look back here in that event. I look at it right now and it is not inline with some of my reads (such as listing Yosarian and mathcam as town) but to be fair, I have the benefit of 2 scum flips where she has none at this point.
One thing STD said did give me pause (that she might not be scum) though. In the post below, STD tried to stay on the Bookitty wagon instead of going back to LML. So they might not be buddies
In post 673, Save The Dragons wrote:If that were the only thing going for Bookitty, I'd stop voting for her, but again I'm not convinced that this absolves her of guilt and I'm not sure that she wouldn't do this as scum.
All in all, I would say I WANT to read Bookitty as town. She wouldn't be my first lynch choice but she certainly isn't obvtown. Also, I am not sure why I noted her as potential scum with GC but I am sure I will find it and explain when I do.
