New York 194: Guns N' Roses Mafia! (Day 8)

[Ilikebugs]

Do we have a role list? anyways (

Vote: Ness

) just because he voted me ;P

[Ilikebugs]

Im a vanilla townie

[Ilikebugs]

Why are people bandwagoning this early?

[Ilikebugs]

hey reubus whats up

[Ilikebugs]

Hey guys sorry that I haven't been talking that much, it's just because when each day I have to look through 3 new pages there is not much I can add to it. In terms of why I claimed d1, it's because I was asked to and if I didn't claim that would either mean I could be seen as mafia or as a power role that mafia would like to take out first.

[Ilikebugs]

Id also like to know why I was asked to claim and why people were on jam before?

[Ilikebugs]

umm jam is too new so I dont know if hes acting scummy or townie for him

[Ilikebugs]

I claimed because pisskop told me to

[Ilikebugs]

Okay so here are my reads so far:
Drixx I wouldn't think make himself such a target d1 if he was scum. It's been a while since I've played mafia so I can see myself as town doing what Drixx is doing in his current position.
Reubus hasn't talked at all so I'm hoping he can add something.
Killthestory started the Drixx vote which seems more scummy than town to me.
Egg I think is using player meta which can easily backfire. Also voted Drixx immediately after killthestory. However still neutral on him due to him actively asking questions.

[Ilikebugs]

Ya I'm new I'm still a townie after all

[Ilikebugs]

Ya I'm new I'm still a townie after all

what does being new have to do with being a townie?

http://prntscr.com/ann5ym Based on the posts you have.

[Ilikebugs]

Drixx, yeah I'd like links to those dirty lies you've told recently. (Also holy shit that game was like 8-10 months ago already?!?!?). Also, why do you think your wagon is "easy"?

Unvote, Vote Creature

^sounds like I was reading that "here wo go" correctly then. His play since that hasn't changed my mind either.

Sircake, did you actually read my reasoning on Drixx critically? It wasn't just because he told a funny joke.

Bugs, why do you think Drixx intentionally made himself a target? And what is wrong with Killthestory's vote on Drixx? Do you think he somehow knew a wagonwould follow?

Kop, thanks I guess? That's the answer I wanted from Bugs but now we'll never get it. I forgot I'd asked though to be fair.

I agree with post 446.

I dont think Drixx wanted to be a target, but what he was doing made himself seem scummier. Killthestory voted Drixx without a reason, and Egg went with the vote. Just an observation for a potential pairing.

[Ilikebugs]

No I'm not an alt

[Ilikebugs]

Wait a sec. Did we ever find out ilikebugs has any FM exp? ilikebugs, tell me about your FM experience.

I've played a bit of mafia on other sites, I'm new to these long games though.

[Ilikebugs]

Unvote: reubus swagrid

Vote: iraonvp

I agree with the assessment given already. I've been watching him post in the previous few pages, and it seems like he isnt giving a town vibe.

[Ilikebugs]

Ok, catching up.

I want to echo the thought that Rubeus' excuse of the number of players making it hard to have opinions worries me. And he replaced Ness so I'd be pretty coolwith lynching that slot. 533 may have had a bit of the ol' Amished tell too. And his "any suggestions?" response to sircakez asking for his scum reads rubs me the wrong way.

DGB, you seem most confident on Drixx being scum, but voted Rubeus. Am I misunderstanding your level of confidence in one or both of those reads or is there something else I'm missing?

Drixx's 602 is a weird reaction to a bussing accusation. I don't like his attempt to discredit DGB's scum read on him in 642 either.

Irao, why did you copy DGB's "this is town" posting style thing? (I have to admit I chuckled at the vote count and your own post being posts you called town)

Kop, you said Irao is giving out town reads too easily. Then you voted him for the "this is town, this is scum" posts saying he isn't engaging people. What is your read on DGB who made a few similar posts?

Slandaar's Frag-Drixx theory interests me. If one of them flips scum, it will interest me a lot more.

Not a fan of Frag dodging Slandaar's question because he feels it's loaded. It feels like he's worried more about the way he's percieved than he is putting legitimate information in the thread. Like he has something to hide. Like a scum PM.

SomethingSmart shares a lot of opinions with me. Not sure what I think about that.

Bugs, are you stil scumreading Rubeus? If so, why switch to Irao?

I am suspicious of Reubus, but he hasn't talked much about the game. Until then I can't be too sure. Irao was acting really scummy by the end of the day so I felt that he would be safer to lynch d1.

[Ilikebugs]

Well if we have to lynch today then...

Unvote: iraonvp

Vote: reubus swagrid

[Ilikebugs]

So my read going into today is still on ira. However I am looking to see at who else is acting scummy. Jam hasn't contributed much, so I'd like to see more reads from him. Other than that I think Egg is strong town for me. Drixx has been acting a bit strangely by the end of yesterday so Ill look more into that

[Ilikebugs]

Frag, can you give specific examples of where Drixx's Day 1 was "solid"? If you feel you've done this already, point me in that direction.

Bugs, what is your read on Firebringer and Frag?

On frag, I think that he's town because he brought up a lot of points that I agreed with, like in post 1009.

Firebringer is still a null read and I'd like some reads from him.

I also right now think that Drixx is a slight town read for me.

[Ilikebugs]

To be honest Im still on scum reading irao and I think that a lynch on him would be safest.

Vote: iraonavp

I'd like to read more on why Drixx is acting scummy to other people.

[Ilikebugs]

Ok I think that I am more comfortable with Drixx as my town read. He's been acting more chill than I would think he would act as scum.

[Ilikebugs]

OK I dont think GuyFawkes is scum. Other are saying that he is scum because of his lurkiness, but I don't believe that is indicative of alignment.

Unvote: Iraonavp

people arent voting him so I guess Ill jump off for now.

[Ilikebugs]

Ok, time to catch up.

I don't like Drixx's "idiot ball" stuff or Frag's one line response to Ozgin's case. If the Firebringer lynch for some reason can't happen, I'm going to have one hell of a time deciding between these two.

Bugs, I get that you are scumreading Ira, but why did you describe his lynch as "safe"? The power role claim makes his lynch risky if anything. I also see that you unvoted. Who would you like to lynch if not Ira?

Kickass, you called Drixx the scummiest you've ever seen and a page later said you were torn on him. If he's that scummy, shouldn't you want him turbolynched? In your past game with him, was he ever under heavy pressure? That simple fact can drastically alter someone's play. Also, based on your reasoning for voting Guy, I have to ask: what is your read on Snark?

Jam's Guy vote sucks.

If I would have to choose someone right now, drippinggoofball hasn't been contributing too much and is just fillering for the most part.

[Ilikebugs]

Vote: Aristo

He hasn't said his reads, and he isn't defending himself. I see him more as scum than town rn.

[Ilikebugs]

Can I hear some more opinions on why Drixx is being voted on?

[Ilikebugs]

Why are people on Snarky?

[Ilikebugs]

So I've been wondering, in this game there is no rolelist, so there could be some role which benefits from being targeted by town roles, or being lynched right?

[Ilikebugs]

Can we get vote counts on the first page? I'd like to know current vote standings. I still think Aristophanes is the most scummy on the board right now.

[Ilikebugs]

So how is SnarkySnowman more scummy that Aristo?