Marked for Death!! (day two)

[Ircher]

/in

[Ircher]

VOTE: Chamber
Luckily, I don't have to sue the worst!

[Ircher]

Hi, this is my first marathon game VOTE: Tim Goodman

Nice to meet you tris! I hope you enjoy it.

[Ircher]

VOTE: OkaPoka for posting an incomprehensible message.

[Ircher]

Can people stop claiming to not have gotten/not read their role pms? If I'm being honest, that ought to be against site rules. (I know at least one user has actually gotten banned in the past for doing that consistently.)

[Ircher]

I'm not scum

Convince us.

[Ircher]

Can people stop claiming to not have gotten/not read their role pms? If I'm being honest, that ought to be against site rules. (I know at least one user has actually gotten banned in the past for doing that consistently.)

well it's not against site rules in a MARATHON

but you definitely shouldn't post until you know 100% what your role is

I'm pretty sure at least 95% of typical mafia site rules also apply to marathons. Or are you suggesting we can discuss ongoing marathons?

[Ircher]

actually didn't get a role pm this time

okay, good to go now

Even if that is true, you shouldn't be stating that in-thread imo.

Sorry, I should get back focused to the game. I got distracted by this tangent.

[Ircher]

VOTE: Tris
Claim

[Ircher]

VOTE: Tris
Claim

Scum

Are you claiming scum, or are you stating my post is a scum post?

[Ircher]

Lets talk about how bad this post is.

well, of course it's bad. I wrote it, after all

do you think it's indicative of anything other than me trolling for shits and giggles?

The answer is actually possibly.

But unlike last game, you aren't pinging me that much rn, so that's a good sign.

[Ircher]

VOTE: Tris
Claim

Scum

Are you claiming scum, or are you stating my post is a scum post?

VOTE: ircher

i cringed irl

Why is this worthy of a vote? It is a legitimate question; some people (myself included) claim scum to troll. And obviously, their message is ambiguous.

[Ircher]

VOTE: Tris
Claim

Scum

Are you claiming scum, or are you stating my post is a scum post?

I am claiming scum.

Ah the good old WIFOM argument.

Also, I'm fine with a Tom lynch.
VOTE: Tom

[Ircher]

VOTE: Tris
Claim

Scum

Are you claiming scum, or are you stating my post is a scum post?

I am claiming scum.

Ah the good old WIFOM argument.

Also, I'm fine with a Tim lynch.
VOTE: Tom

VOTE: Tim
(Partial EBWOP)

[Ircher]

Hi, this is my first marathon game VOTE: Tim Goodman

this is my first marathon game too

in fact this is my first mafia game ever

how do i play mafia

Your post qouted here (tris) is pretty bad, and Something attacks it in a really over the top way, then completely drops it and gets on someone else's case for a similar tell. Feels all wrong.

Where is Something attacking tris for this? And the post that is quoted isn't really that bad. It could be a legit troll post.

[Ircher]

I'll vote Rainn or Ircher. I think both of them are scum. I don't know why Oka is still voting me.

Sell your case on me.

[Ircher]

Your post qouted here (tris) is pretty bad, and Something attacks it in a really over the top way, then completely drops it and gets on someone else's case for a similar tell. Feels all wrong.

I wasn't attacking it, I was just memeing on it lul

and I never got on anyone's case, actually, though I can see how the newbscum greeting post might have been misinterpreted. I was asking if people were applying that tell.

Oh, here is this tell that someone did, are we going to attack them for it? Is absolutely an attack, just a really non committal one. One you might have not wanted to be tied to.

Meh, I think you are overthinking it/overexaggerating your point here, chamber.

[Ircher]

Tim is still a good lynch. Someone convince me for Rainn; I haven't really seen anything alignment-indicative from them.

[Ircher]

It's pretty obvious to me that they saw me as LHF, set me as the marked, and then went all in after me as an easy target.

Everytime you repeat that line, I scumread you more.

[Ircher]

I'll abstain from that wagon, even if it is a no lynch.

[Ircher]

Was gonna post this before lock:

I'll abstain from that wagon, even if it is a no lynch.

when rainn flips red, this gets lynched immediately

Why must you do this to me? No one has even posted a decent case that does not 100% rely on a single past game. Why should I join that wagon?

[Ircher]

So chamber is town, urap is probably town, smart is probably town, I'm town.

[Ircher]

That leaves Tim, Tris, and Oka, but I don't really think it's Oka either.

[Ircher]

That was an obvious scum push on me by the way.

Eh, I can buy this, but at the same time, this is "Look At Me, I'm So Town" WIFOM argument.

[Ircher]

Smart townread is pretty awful as is declaring yourself town, Ircher.

I'm confirmed town from my point-of-view.

I just played a game with scum!Smart and Smart's play here doesn't really resemble his play there.

[Ircher]

From what I know of Ircher it's likely.

I'm not scum.

Just who are you?

[Ircher]

(You don't have to answer, but I totally don't know you unless you are an alt.)

[Ircher]

VOTE: Tris

[Ircher]

maybe this time i caught two scum d1

VOTE: oka

Remind me why?

[Ircher]

I don't know you particularly well. I've read at least one game you were in.

Yeah, that doesn't suffice at all for getting an accurate guage on my playstyle.

[Ircher]

I think that lynching Ircher before endgame is important and he's a good right now lynch.

Why do you keep insisting on this?

[Ircher]

Gg town!! Woot!

[Ircher]

Oh damn tw beat me to the edit

Don't worry, I saw it too!

[Ircher]

it's best to just not talk about whether you did/did not receive your pm itt, just discreetly pm the mod and pretend to be normal [tm]
not against rules as ircher implied but it leads to angleshooting which is ick

in a game this short, not saying anything for minutes is also going to lead to angleshooting

damned if i do, damned if i dont

it's best to just not talk about whether you did/did not receive your pm itt, just discreetly pm the mod and pretend to be normal [tm]
not against rules as ircher implied but it leads to angleshooting which is ick

and pretending to be normal is actually against site rules

I guess this is a good point that I did not necessarily consider. But again, (not trying to start debate here), I just consider it bad form to make those kinds of statements. And you weren't really gone **that** long imo. Anyway, just something I feel you should keep in mind in future games. (Also, I brought it up because that was not the first time today someone did that.)

[Ircher]

I agree that confirms are a good idea.