Predict the kill (7/7)

[singletonking]

2 Mafia
5 Townies

Compulsive lynch, compulsive kill.

Every Night, each townie can guess who is being killed, but cannot guess themselves. Everyone who guesses the kill right earns town 1 point. Scum can also give town 1 point every Night.

After every Night, the number of points Town earned is announced.

Town wins when both Mafia are dead, or Town earns 3 points in total. Mafia win when all Townies are dead. Parity is NOT an instant win for scum, they need to kill all townies and Town will be given the opportunity to earn points to win.

Players:
Ircher
Alchemist21
Rainn
MaryJoLisa
chamber
OkaPoka
pytdarque

[singletonking]

If I cannot get 9 players I will play a reduced version with 7.

[singletonking]

Is this not fun?

Was really hoping to test this out, but I'm willing to mod a different setup if this isn't fun.

[singletonking]

For the 7 player variant Town only needs 3 points

[singletonking]

Cool

For the 7 player variant, the number of points Town needs to get is reduced to 3

[singletonking]

Do you guys prefer site chat or PM

[singletonking]

Sending role PMs now

[singletonking]

Also note that lynching is compulsive

[singletonking]

If anyone wants to join, I have 2 more slots open so PM me if interested

[singletonking]

All role PMs are out, please confirm by replying with your alignment

PM, Site chat, discord, whatever, any channel is fine.

Game starts with all confirms

[singletonking]

Everyone has confirmed, Day 1 begins!

Deadline :25

[singletonking]

Rainn (2): Ircher, MaryJoLisa,
MaryJoLisa (2): chamber, Alchemist21,
Ircher (1): OkaPoka,

Not Voting (2):
Rainn, pytdarque,

:25

[singletonking]

Lynching is compulsive so we're using plurality

[singletonking]

MaryJoLisa (2): chamber, Alchemist21,
Ircher (2): OkaPoka, MaryJoLisa,

Not Voting (3):
Rainn, pytdarque, Ircher,

:25

[singletonking]

MaryJoLisa (3): chamber, Alchemist21, OkaPoka,
Ircher (1): MaryJoLisa,

Not Voting (3):
Rainn, pytdarque, Ircher,

:25

[singletonking]

MaryJoLisa (4): chamber, Alchemist21, OkaPoka, Rainn,
Ircher (1): MaryJoLisa,

Not Voting (2):
pytdarque, Ircher,

[singletonking]

MaryJoLisa was lynched, she was Mafia

Send Night actions by :22

[singletonking]

You can send by PM, site chat, or even Discord, basically anything I can reach

[singletonking]

Ircher died, he was Town

Town earns 0 points

Deadline :43

[singletonking]

pytdarque (2): OkaPoka, Alchemist21,
chamber (1): Rainn,

Not Voting (2):
chamber, pytdarque,

:43

[singletonking]

pytdarque (2): OkaPoka, Alchemist21,
chamber (1): Rainn,

Not Voting (2):
chamber, pytdarque,

:43

[singletonking]

pytdarque (2): OkaPoka, Alchemist21,
chamber (1): Rainn,

Not Voting (2):
chamber, pytdarque,

:43

[singletonking]

pytdarque (1): OkaPoka,
chamber (1): Rainn,
OkaPoka (1): Alchemist21,

Not Voting (2):
chamber, pytdarque,

:43

[singletonking]

pytdarque (1): OkaPoka,
chamber (1): Rainn,
OkaPoka (1): Alchemist21,
Rainn (1): chamber,

Not Voting (1):
pytdarque,

:43

[singletonking]

OkaPoka (3): Alchemist21, pytdarque, Rainn,
pytdarque (1): OkaPoka,
Rainn (1): chamber,

Not Voting (0):

[singletonking]

OkaPoka was lynched, he was Town

Send actions by :47

[singletonking]

chamber died, he was Town

Town earns 1 point

Deadline :08

[singletonking]

Alchemist21 (1): Rainn,

Not Voting (2):
Alchemist21, pytdarque,

:08

[singletonking]

Alchemist21 (2): Rainn, pytdarque,
Rainn (1): Alchemist21,

Not Voting (0):

[singletonking]

Alchemist21 died, he was Town

Rainn, Town, lost

The Mafia of pytdarque and MaryJoLisa win!

[singletonking]

Well that was a game

[singletonking]

How fun was the game?

[singletonking]

Or really the mechanic

[singletonking]

I feel like this point mechanic in its current version isn't enough to balanced 2:5.

Probably, but I cannot make it 2 points because it allows for breaking strategies

Maybe the correct thing to do would be to remove scum giving points

[singletonking]

Or really the mechanic

The game was fun. The mechanic is good in concept but I think it would work better in bigger setups. Early reads are probably always going to be too split for it to be a viable way for Town to win in a 7-p.

Hmm

How exactly would I work this mechanic into a bigger game?

[singletonking]

Eh I did think about balancing mechanics

I feel like town gets an average of 1 point every Night, but I wonder if later Nights should be worth more.

There's also a huge swing factor.