Lovers Mafia (game over)

[panthaleon]

/in

[panthaleon]

Confirm

[panthaleon]

Wait is that what watcher means?

[panthaleon]

Yeah we have today and tomorrow to find scum.

[panthaleon]

My hot take is I think Spangled is town. I don't think that sounds like scum pretending to misunderstand the setup.

[panthaleon]

Also my gut says that Josh is lightly sketch for taking the low hanging fruit.

[panthaleon]

I generally suspect scum to pay closer attention to setup than town, especially VTs.

[panthaleon]

Panthaleon what is your mafia experience

I used to play a lot more back in the day. I'm very rusty now though.

Also my gut says that Josh is lightly sketch for taking the low hanging fruit.

I dont actually know what youre referring to

I think someone misunderstanding the setup is a really easy excuse for scum to find an early person to be suspicious of.

[panthaleon]

malkon have u played mafia in person before

I feel like I have that energy

Two things.

1. Lots of times! I was actually the Godfather of a mafia club in college (aka president).

2. I think what pants meant by Josh going for "low hanging fruit" meant that he pointed out spangled was being "sketch" for his post and Josh jumped on it. I get where pants is coming from.

Wow Malkon just claimed Godfather get him

[panthaleon]

I think they're trying to get a read of where you are coming from.

[panthaleon]

question, how do you do the cool vote thingy that josh just did?

Is it like :vote _____: (guess we will find out if that worked rotfl)

You want VOTE: tags Malkon

[panthaleon]

Idk why I don't feel like voting yet

I mean I personally am waiting on Josh to explain the Spangled vote a little more before I commit.

[panthaleon]

His response will make me more or less sure that he is scum.

[panthaleon]

Josh hasn't really explained why setup confusion is alignment indicative. This still looks like he's going for low hanging fruit.

VOTE: Josh Wilkinson

[panthaleon]

Josh "Spangled is scum"

Everyone "Why"

Josh "No one has indicated why he is town"

Everyone "We literally did"

Josh "lmao unvote with room to flip back on later"

[panthaleon]

Ok we have like five minutes until deadline. My fast case on Josh

-Going for low hanging fruit

-Not defending low hanging fruit

-Ignoring vote against him

-Unvoting after pressure without providing reasoning

-Leaving room to jump back on the wagon

[panthaleon]

Ok we have like five minutes until deadline. My fast case on Josh

-Going for low hanging fruit

-Not defending low hanging fruit

-Ignoring vote against him

-Unvoting after pressure without providing reasoning

-Leaving room to jump back on the wagon

my case will not be relegated to the bottom of a page

[panthaleon]

This site really only goes for new players??

It's not really about new players. It's about the case I literally just detailed.

[panthaleon]

We are at LyLo DO NOT vote for anyone or scum can quickhammer and win.

Looking over posts and rethinking reads.

[panthaleon]

Looking at the wagon from yesterday, I feel like with how hard it was to kick things into gear, it was not two scums joining. I feel like that means one or both of Spangled and Malkon05 are basically guaranteed town to me. I could almost buy that it was an entirely town wagon since scum might be afraid to hammer to draw suspicion.

Currently looking into whether KittyMo and S_S are scum.

[panthaleon]

I'm also trying to reconcile a nonsense bus vote if that team is real hm

[panthaleon]

VOTE: SS

gonna feel this out

why is no one voting we have 4 minutes

This doesn't look great since KittyMo wasn't exactly pushing to make a S_S vote while mentioning people should be voting.

[panthaleon]

Looking at the wagon from yesterday, I feel like with how hard it was to kick things into gear, it was not two scums joining. I feel like that means one or both of Spangled and Malkon05 are basically guaranteed town to me. I could almost buy that it was an entirely town wagon since scum might be afraid to hammer to draw suspicion.

Currently looking into whether KittyMo and S_S are scum.

So, my opinion on yesterday, and what i was kind of trying to talk about 10 minutes before the day ended that nobody would really engage me with, is that the very obviously dominant narrative was that everyone was suspecting josh and no one was trying to do anything else

meaning the scenarios were a) scum were afraid to push something else or b) scum were content with this

they probably lose in scenario a so i was more focused on scenario b and trying to push elsewhere

Can you explain what you mean by scum being afraid to push somewhere else?

[panthaleon]

S_S do you think odds are higher that both scum were on the wagon or one was on and one was off?

[panthaleon]

S_S do you think odds are higher that both scum were on the wagon or one was on and one was off?

This is just asking me about KMo's alignment in a different guise. Clearly, I don't know.

I mean we discuss this a layer up to see if that helps tease out whether KittyMo is scum

[panthaleon]

The stilted nature of the vote on Josh leads me to believe it could have been fully town, but I have difficulty reconciling that with the KittyMo vote on you.

[panthaleon]

Ok so I'm starting to feel like S_S's resistance to discuss anything KittyMo is outweighing KittyMo voting him in day one. Them as scum could make a lot of sense.

[panthaleon]

all right, we got 15 minutes.

pants, i want to hear more from you, i'll try to be more specific about what

Have you decided what specifically yet?

[panthaleon]

I mean, what do you want to talk about?

Idk dude talk about what you think of the wagons or what you think of her reads or what you think of her avatar. Like anything would be helpful. I don't like how resistant you are to touching that topic.

[panthaleon]

Malkon I'm starting to think you're right about scum KittyMo

[panthaleon]

Honestly Malkon is rapidly ascending in my town reads because I'm seeing a certain earnestness in his posting. I think it would be easy for scum to play really confused newbie without adding anything of value, and that's not what Malkon is doing.

[panthaleon]

Would you like me to vote KittyMo and put my money where my mouth is then?

How confident do you feel? I just don't want to be wrong have have scum quickhammer us out. I am feeling like scum is prob KittyMo and one of Spangled and S_S

[panthaleon]

I mean we can definitely put them under the interrogation light tomorrow to figure out if I was wrong about Spangled Day 1 or if KittyMo was big-braining us with a bus in a setup it wouldn't make sense in.

[panthaleon]

Would you like me to vote KittyMo and put my money where my mouth is then?

How confident do you feel? I just don't want to be wrong have have scum quickhammer us out. I am feeling like scum is prob KittyMo and one of Spangled and S_S

I can’t quite remember what your reads have been but that feels like a big flip from what you’ve been saying.

Like I said, Malkon ascended as a town read today. This means either you or S_S are scum.

[panthaleon]

VOTE: Malkon

[panthaleon]

<3 u Malkon

Also lol at the town voting faster than scum could

[panthaleon]

Ceph you can always read me. That's not fair

[panthaleon]

Oh shit wait mafia lovers. I forgot if we lynch one, we lynch both