![Cheerful Smile :]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png)
VOTE: quagsire
i was feeling enthusiastic about playing with you againIn post 28, nomnomnom wrote:you said hi to me twice, suspicious....
also I think it was in venrob PYP
In post 31, Captain the Furret wrote:also excited to play with the amazing skitter, its been awhile since I actually played in a mafia game with skitter and actually cared about it even remotely seriously.
hi!In post 32, Menalque wrote:hi skitt
do you think there's scum in the players not voting?
* this was meant to ask if they thought there's scum in the players who hadn't posted yetIn post 40, skitter30 wrote:do you think there's scum in the players not voting?
also i'm going to repeat that the giant gifs are really really really annoying
i don't see itIn post 46, nomnomnom wrote:I let my heart guide me
my heart was like "this post stinki"
so I voted the stinki post
In post 56, Heaven wrote:Nice to see skitter again after she gave me a heart attack last time I played scum and nom3, who inherited that heart attack.
Luckily, my scum abilities have doubled since last we met. Not that it's relevant, or anything.
he doesn't sound like a robot who is forcing himself to write each post so that he doesn't get replacedIn post 72, nomnomnom wrote:what's different from that one micro you played with him where I replaced him
you caught him fairly quickly there so I'm curious
ok so why'd you list those players in that post then?
sorry, why is the heaven wagon a thing exactly?In post 93, Menalque wrote:why are people always so afraid of L-1s
the whole l-1 lolhammer thing was not great
it's a tone thing, he feels kinda not awkward
where do you think he's being awkward @menaIn post 109, skitter30 wrote:he doesn't sound like a robot who is forcing himself to write each post so that he doesn't get replaced
uh no i kinda agree with him? the first page was weird afIn post 136, Menalque wrote:this was really out of nowhere emotional escalation
there's a certain level of forthrightness / 'not caring about how i'm perceived' in that post that was entirely lacking in that microIn post 136, Menalque wrote:this feels like it's leaning a little too hard into the "fake claiming scum as scum" joke
also it's not an emotional escalation?In post 136, Menalque wrote:this was really out of nowhere emotional escalation
y thoIn post 138, nomnomnom wrote:this is just a personal note but this kind of rvs post/vote is scummy as fuck
probably scumIn post 139, Menalque wrote:okay but like in general, what which alignment do you think cares more about perceptions
lol noIn post 142, nomnomnom wrote:the whole point of rvs is that for scums the first vote is never random
so voting someone's that's not in the game and saying "haha it's just a joke guys" is kind of a red flag and just sounds like scum avoiding any kind of association
wait i just realized he voted ico who's not actually in the game but who i thought was for some reasonIn post 142, nomnomnom wrote:the whole point of rvs is that for scums the first vote is never random
so voting someone's that's not in the game and saying "haha it's just a joke guys" is kind of a red flag and just sounds like scum avoiding any kind of association
i dont' think it felt charged reallyIn post 151, Menalque wrote:it's like ~charged~ but it's coming from nowhere and that just feels offIn post 148, skitter30 wrote:also it's not an emotional escalation?In post 136, Menalque wrote:this was really out of nowhere emotional escalation
i dont' get what your problem is here really
idk if I can explain it more than that
wherein i caught both scum upon catching up upon repping inskitter30 wrote:ok holden is a decent townread
getting gut-town pings on blatant scum
if volxen never posts wobat is probably scum
heaven is pinging me the wrong way
really good scumgame, good at ate, i'm not super great at catching herIn post 160, Menalque wrote:@skitt @furret what are your opinions on nomx3's scumgame?
i mean agree with you that mena's heaven l-1 thing was weird but your take on his rvs post was badIn post 162, nomnomnom wrote:idk man people seem to think I'm stupid as fuck when it comes to scumhunting but what I say makes sense for me god damn it :/
hard to make people follow wagons with me when they hardly understand my reasonings and it's irritating
ummmmmIn post 212, nomnomnom wrote:it especially hurts from skit considering I like playing with her and I hate to think that she maybe thinks I'm bad as town
urgh
he wasn't giving townreads left and right, he gave like 2.5In post 230, nomnomnom wrote:it's not weak
you just seem to give townreads left and right without any explanation, spend your time specifically make a case on me and you don't even vote me
that gives me a lot of pings
ok but this didn't like happen; he gave like 2.5 townreadsIn post 233, nomnomnom wrote:I'm suspicious of people who give townreads left and right because that's generally ultra scummy especially without much rationale behind it, especially in the context of micros where there is a lot more emphasis of finding other townies rather than minis and larges
although i'm not actually sure town!nom wouldn'tIn post 238, Luca Blight wrote:You’re openwolfing. Town!Nom would not want to 1v1 someone over this lol
he didn't espouse a townread on me, he said he thinks my posts make sense, which is not at all the same thing.In post 248, nomnomnom wrote:I don't care if they're light townreads I refuse to believe anyone from this table has a 100% good way to discern skitter's alignment early on d1 and I say this as someone who's been studying how she plays for a while
what kind of read is "she makes sense" anyway, that's not even a read
wait where did the quag scumread come from?In post 252, Looker wrote:S{Quag | Heaven/Nom | Aldus/Skitter/Menal | Captain/Luca}T
why are you townreading quagsire?
i dont' understand this vote, i thought luca came off signifccantly better than nom there
i don't really read him as oppurtunistic at all and i also am not sure i agree that he always comes across as obviously town when townIn post 282, Menalque wrote:I agree Luca comes across opportunistic this game but also like, not obviously town? Whereas I think Luca as town normally reads very obviously town
well it wasn't the fact that he wanted l-1's it's more the fact that he was provoking a lolhammer/indicated he was fine with that happeningIn post 334, Alduskkel wrote:also it doesn't even take that much bravado to put someone at L-1 at this stage so there's that too
why are you townreading her?In post 334, Alduskkel wrote:I'm on page 11 and nomnomnom looks like lynchbait
i think she's fully capable of forcing the 1v1 as either alignment and i'm not sure she thinks that luca is liable to win if she's scumIn post 527, Alduskkel wrote:My impression is that nom has been somewhat emotional/confrontational which has attracted votes but I don't think there's scum motive. Why try to provoke Luca into a 1v1 instead of deflecting? In a Luca vs. nom battle I think Luca is more likely to win and I think nom knows that as scum. As town, if she thinks Luca's scum then it might be an uphill battle but at least she's pursuing scum.
yeah i think it's too lolrandom to come from scum there; like lolvoting a pr claim once it's been p accepted for little gain is not really something scum do most of the time; there's no way he thinks it actually gains traction thereIn post 535, Luca Blight wrote:I really don’t understand her vote on me, though
i literally don't remember his early play beyond for the obnoxious gif pokeomon thingsIn post 540, Looker wrote:I felt like people were ignoring him but the wagons he jumped on always made it to L-1/L-2 (Heaven, Luca). I don't remember Heaven; you've been gone for a while. I probably thought he was lurking on purpose.
heyIn post 547, Captain the Furret wrote:hey skitter
wrongIn post 606, GeorgeBailey wrote:As for Chemist and Looker, I think Looker is scummy for reasons stated above, and Chemist for his predecessor, Heaven.
VOTE: Chemist1422
this gives me townpings on george ^In post 604, GeorgeBailey wrote:2. I don't scumread Luca, catching up, one post I really liked was:
i don't see it? why does this make thier reaction to the wagon seem bad to you?In post 616, GeorgeBailey wrote:This particularly was right after he was being brought up to L-2.In post 84, Heaven wrote:Chancellor Alduskkel. Catching scum lords is my speciality.
oh lolIn post 643, Captain the Furret wrote:Ur already voting it I think
@ali yeah i can see thatIn post 583, Chemist1422 wrote:skitter's interaction with Mena on page 6 is pretty towny (for skitter not Mena)
also happy scumday datisi
he was at l-1 , he claimed a town invest, and you just kinda left the wagon hanging and didn't do anything about itIn post 663, Quagsire wrote:i wanted to get reactions, liked the luca wagon at the time. i wasn't actually expecting nor asking him to claim though.In post 626, skitter30 wrote:@quag, why did your unvote of luca come in 491 and not when he first claimed?
uhhh scum weird.In post 669, Quagsire wrote:okay it may be weird but is it scum weird or town weird?
fair enough, i'm probably not out of my scumrange yetIn post 681, Luca Blight wrote:I’ve agreed with nearly everything Skitter has said so far, but that’s happened before when she was scum so I’d wait until later in the game to get a firm read (not that I’ll live that long).
this is scummy ^In post 687, nomnomnom wrote:I'm unsure about Quags, but it sure does look like today's lynch rn
I hate running out of time like this
uhhhhh i mean ok?In post 689, nomnomnom wrote:I'd rather have the wagon on Ald because I feel somewhat more confident there than Quags
I just have mixed feeling on Quags. In an ideal world I'd like to be more convinced to go there because like, argh...
It just doesn't feel good to tell myself to vote there
i think u were using ate to try to get out of ur argument with lucaIn post 708, nomnomnom wrote:What do you really want me to say about them
it's not like I'm on the spotlight and the discussion is pretty much "quag yes or not" for me
i mean is this the only think you like out of his iso? that's p fakeableIn post 696, nomnomnom wrote:this feels very townie to me, more interested in sorting than survivalism is v pro town, even though I recognize that this can be abused and I've abused this as scum in the pastIn post 682, Quagsire wrote:okay so say i flip town then. are you just gonna say "well i was wrong on that time to lynch the next one in my poe" or are you gonna reevaluate some of the people you're townreading?In post 676, Captain the Furret wrote:I haven’t thought about your main once tbh
I kind of just have reasons to townread everyone else
Does Quag look like someone who would pull that sort of string off as scum? Possibly, but I feel unlikely
it looks like he just claimed since he was put at l-1 unexpectedly and was going out and was worried about not being able to claim before getting hammered so just claimed everythingIn post 701, nomnomnom wrote:It seems odd to claim it when you can simply not claim it and let scums go paranoid over a protective
Plus if I need to think in terms of fakeclaim and scum gameplans claiming macho DEFINITELY puts a halt to your wagon except if people really don't trust your claim considering that people will think that you will die the next night if you're town so that at least buys a gamephase for scums which is why I am distrusting of these claims. I'd consider that as scum at least.