Micro 1068 | Normal Designer Mafia | Postgame

[Not Known 15]

So anyway, should we share PR picks? I think it helps town more than mafia.

Does it, really?
Well, yes, but not fully.
We should share ambiguous and Mafia-only picks, I think, EXCEPT ambiguous investigation roles.
But should we really share town-only roles? What's the benefit of that that outweighs the info we give to scum?
And identifying the invest roles is of course a big no because it could give extremely useful info to scum.

I submitted three roles.

Mafia Goon and two others.

[Not Known 15]

VT is a not Role, VT is "Vanilla Town Alignment". For example, Serial Killer and Mafia Goon are ALSO not Roles.

I'm pretty sure they are, though it can't hurt to get confirmation I suppose.

@mod, would "Vanilla Townie" or "Goon" have been valid picks during signup?

In any case, I also do believe that you don't believe they are, so you did satisfy the doubt I had.

Oh jeez, MAYBE they are valid. I don't know. I didn't bother to apply fucking vanilla on designer mafia and i doubt anyone else did so.

At this point I should probably reveal that 2 of my picks were Vanilla Townie and Mafia Goon...

[Not Known 15]

Yes there's a rule saying you have to call someone Mafia before voting them? OK, I await mod intervention on that. Not holding my breath though.

You disagreed with my stance it's fine.

Voting me implues you think i am mafia. But there's nothing you said about this. So you just vote me because you disagree with my stance, without regard if i am mafia or town.

So my question is valid.

This is just a pile of nonsense. And Enchant is often making very strange posts not really within solving effort, but it's more like a mode... and this post is an attempt at serious mode but... it's just an argument for the sake of an argument, instead a town thinking on how this could be town(by simply saying that Enchant's stance is also sus; or simply by falling into the "X says wrong things so X is scum" fallacy). It's extremely early so peoples votes can naturally be very weak, but that's also something Enchant knows... so I think this is even falling the test for weak reads.

VOTE: Enchant

[Not Known 15]

NK15

I order you to comment on Drew's progression and vote on me

The arguments I see between you two would make sense as coming either from town or Mafia, but they are actually pretty weak.

[Not Known 15]

NK15

I order you to comment on Drew's progression and vote on me

The arguments I see between you two would make sense as coming either from town or Mafia, but they are actually pretty weak.

What

Only Drew has been making arguments

I have been calling them dumb

And your arguments for that are actually not that convincing... which is why I called them weak.

[Not Known 15]

Why is Enchant E-2 already

Lycanfire scum for that

(with NK15)

Game done

Why?

[Not Known 15]

nah

Why not?

[Not Known 15]

I dislike this gamestate

Probably having 3 votes helps

VOTE: Hellhound1

And where is this now coming from?

Explain yourself.

[Not Known 15]

Hmmm.... interesting. So Furtive is town. And Drew was the scumkill. I will look at this in detail tomorrow.

[Not Known 15]

VOTE: Not Known 15

[Not Known 15]

Hope you weren't town

Thanks for playing

no, sadly not.