Micro 353: Greatest Idea Mafia! (Game Over!)

[1baldeagle1]

Hello.

[1baldeagle1]

Ok, after reading through the thread, I think Maestro, Aronis and maybe Maruchan are scum.

I'm getting some tells early in the game that Maruchan and Maestro are indirectly communicating with one another. This string of posts strike me odd.

TBH, after reading snscompt1's ninja of my post, I want to remove my RVS vote on my favorite role of all time, and place a serious vote on VOTE: snscompt1


Quickest game out of RVS ever?

I'll bite. Wagon ho!

VOTE: sns

I claim Town 1-shot day-vig

Kill: snscompt1

inb4 you all vote me, go meta me. Particularly in PYP 5: Democracy Ho!


Going to go with my gut instinct on him being scum here, and kill him before he can change my mind.

He seems like he is communicating with his partner whether not he should dayvig sns, and Maestro approves of it by voting and one minute later, Maru kills and it happens to hit a different type of scum, which gains him some towncred.

And for Aronis,

VOTE: Aronis

Discards do mean something. I think this is where we should go today.

Why are you going after me for being one of the few people to throw away an anti town role?

This made me lol. Using discards to prove you are town? Nope.


Gonna vote for Aronis, since I'm more confident in him being scum, then Maestro and Maru. If I had to guess, Maru and Maestro are the mafia and Aronis is werewolf/alien/3rd party.
VOTE: Aronis

P-Edit:

Hello.

Heyyy. You're late. Some1 already got shot and I may be getting shot, idk.

Sorry, lol. For some reason, emails aren't being sent whenever I get a PM, so I have to check manually.

[1baldeagle1]

BC and Not Mafia seems town to me so far.

[1baldeagle1]

Yep. I'm cool with this lynch.

Maru, I thought about that and that's why I was more confident in Aronis being scum than you two. The surprise thing may have been fake to try to cover up the secret interaction in the thread.

P-Edit:

[1baldeagle1]

Ok, we are most likely in LYLO/MYLO situation right now, because we have not seen a mafia/werewolf/alien flip.

Right now, Maestro is at the top of my suspicion list.

P-Edit: This reminds me, should we massclaim?

[1baldeagle1]

Right now, Maestro is at the top of my suspicion list.

Why?

Because of the reasons I stated earlier.

I think Maru scum is still possible, but I'm more suspicious of Maestro because he ignored my case and kept pushing with a lynch to end the day.

P-Edit: I'm okay with that claim order. However, I think Rob should full-claim once everyone else claims.

[1baldeagle1]

VOTE: sns Why the joke vote instead of a real comment on the discards?

Don't see scum rejecting dayvig or gladiator as an ability

@mod Is Marquis or Maestro playing?

Good question in the first post in the game.

Rofl

dayvig:aronis

Good reaction testing to see if Aronis was scum (and Aronis did react in a very scummy manner) to see if we can peg another scum and increase our chances of winning.

So far, Not_mafia has been helpful and I'm getting town vibes from his posts.

I'd also like everyone to claim which they prefer best for alignment - Town, Scum, or Third-Party.

I admittedly like scum best, which is why the reroll sucked.

I play town best, so I prefer to play as town, but every once in awhile I like to roll scum.

[1baldeagle1]

Anyone else wanna do a claim of our original roll roles?

I was a town reflexive-doctor. I doctor'd any role who visited me.

Town Bloodsucker.

[1baldeagle1]

I play town best, so I prefer to play as town, but every once in awhile I like to roll scum.

Oh my god, I want to vote this guy just for his answer here! "I prefer town because I'm good at town, but I also like scum sometimes" I mean come on. So generalized doesn't really say anything but implies that you'd pick town when given the choice bullshit


ugh.


I suck at town but I still prefer to play town. so your reasoning is invalid.

Well, I did intentionally play as scum in my last greatest idea mafia game because I played like so many games as town I wanted to play scum for once.

[1baldeagle1]

Ok, claiming.

Maestro, I'm going to need to know why I have you as visiting the deceased right about immediately.

This can probably be assumed to be LyLo, so no quick voting please.

looks at Maru

How is this possible, I'm the Town Jailkeeper and I targeted Maestro.

[1baldeagle1]

Ok, claiming.

Maestro, I'm going to need to know why I have you as visiting the deceased right about immediately.

This can probably be assumed to be LyLo, so no quick voting please.

looks at Maru

How is this possible, I'm the Town Jailkeeper and I targeted Maestro.

[1baldeagle1]

Maestro, are we going to do the number thing or what?

Also, I kinda understand Maru's logic behind lynching beast, but Aronis was a better lynch at the time, even though he flipped town.

[1baldeagle1]

I'm not doing the "number thing" until you all contribute more to the claim conversation / finish the claim chain we already had in place
Maru's logic is completely invalid - it's not like they were Lovers or a Scumteam, there's no reason AT ALL that " Mason1 = notTown ∴ Mason2 = notTown "

( yes, the odds that they both get Lyncher AND Mason in some form are pretty low, but it obviously happened and it would be completely inappropriate for the Mod to intervene in the way he described )

I believe everyone has claimed already and what is there to talk about? I think Maru is a scum dayvig because he recklessly used his shot, I believe Rob, Maestro and NM's claims since NM's result matches up with Maestro's claim and I liked Rob's gambit, so I'm pretty sure it's Maru.

[1baldeagle1]

I'd like to note that NM's result matching Maestro's claim after Maestro's claim is public knowledge means absolutely nothing whatsoever.

Wouldn't a scum dayvig use their shot then attempt to WIFOM their way out of any sticky situations that result? Wouldn't a specifically Maru scum dayvig definitely do that?

Hint for those who may not be acclimated with Maru: The answer is yes.

The kill is more of a reason for me to want to lynch you than the shot, to be honest.

Oh shit, yeah you're right. Never mind.

I'm not doing the "number thing" until you all contribute more to the claim conversation / finish the claim chain we already had in place
Maru's logic is completely invalid - it's not like they were Lovers or a Scumteam, there's no reason AT ALL that " Mason1 = notTown ∴ Mason2 = notTown "

( yes, the odds that they both get Lyncher AND Mason in some form are pretty low, but it obviously happened and it would be completely inappropriate for the Mod to intervene in the way he described )

I believe everyone has claimed already and what is there to talk about? I think Maru is a scum dayvig because he recklessly used his shot, I believe Rob, Maestro and NM's claims since NM's result matches up with Maestro's claim and I liked Rob's gambit, so I'm pretty sure it's Maru.

Wouldn't scum dayvig have saved their shot for a lylo situation, and used it to win without having to lynch?

Besides, my recklessly using my shot is not alignment indicative. go read PYP5 democracy ho on my wiki. I like to recklessly shoot. Day Vig is my all time favorite role, irregardless of alignment cuz I love shooting crazy on day 1

Ok, fine. I still think you are scum though.

[1baldeagle1]

Dang, gg scum.