Your Idea Mafia 2! Day 1 9/9

[All is Who]

Hello everyone. I am Who. All is Who. Who is all. You are all just Who-alts. Everyone's a Who-alt. For some reason I'm the kind of person who likes to make alts and then pretend to play mafia among them.

Anyway, the claiming submitted scumroles strategy from last game seemed to work rather well, shall we do it again?

[All is Who]

I am also Who. I agree with Who that claiming scum submissions is positive utility to town. I would like to add that if anyone submitted something that was negative town utility, that should probably get claimed after we claim all of the scum submissions. If no one objects to this plan before tomorrow night, I will claim our scum submission. If someone objects to this plan before tomorrow night, I will probably claim my scum submission anyway.

-Guyett

[All is Who]

Hello, Who. Who also submitted psychotrooper. I don't think psychomagnet is a role, so that means you also probably submitted psychotrooper (Sorry Guyett). The good news is that Vanilla Alien is hilariously underpowered. The bad news is that psychotroopers fuck with all of our investigations, and we don't know for sure whether it exists.

Also, thank you for the concern, but Who already has a signature.

-Siveure DtTrikyp

[All is Who]

I wonder if anyone caught that judas is a town role and put it in anyway

~All

Hopefully not, that was enough of a nightmare last game. If anybody did submit Judas, Saulus, Unlynchable Alien, or Unlynchable Townie they should say so.

~Bins

[All is Who]

Scum roles claimed so far:
Alien Psychotrooper
Alien Mass Redirector
Vanilla Alien
One-shot Goomaker
Lyncher
Mafia Lover
Mafia One-shot Dayvig (Shinobi said he submitted 3 dayvigs, and it's the only scum dayvig)
Werewolf

People who have yet to claim their submission: Guyett

And now time to claim our town submissions: Childkiller and Black Goo

[All is Who]

and why are many players saying their send town roles?!

It limits the scum's options when fakeclaiming. Also, the negative utility submissions (For example, Childkiller) should definitely be claimed for obvious reasons.

~Armageddon

[All is Who]

Black goo is also a role that should probably be claimed immediately.

Phone post

-shinobi

[All is Who]

This is Jingle. Who is also in All is Who.

Both of us have signed as other players, but I started it .

Obviously negative utility roles can't hurt to claim, but Scum can fakeclaim other roles anyways anyways because presumably there are multiple scum who each sent 2 town roles. Also take into account that scum could go on the internet and lie about the roles they sent, which compromises the whole idea.

Untrue. Given the public information on the number of vanilla roles, we can be relatively certain of how close to accurate the list of roles is. Scum probably won't lie here because that only gives them more options for getting caught. But we should save that discussion until all submissions are in. Your paranoia is probably town though.

List of claimed submissions incoming shortly.

[All is Who]

^
~Who

[All is Who]

All is Who
Scum- Alien Psychotrooper
Town- Compulsive Childkiller, Black Goo

Kabooooom
Scum- Alien Mass Redirector
Town- Tracker, Conspiracy Theorist

Jackel98
Scum- Goomaker
Town- Kingmaker, Compulsive Childkiller

OkaPoka
Scum- Mafia Lover
Town- PGO, Vengeful


Shinobi-
Scum- Mafia Dayvig
Town- Dayvig x2?


Guyett-
Scum- Mafia Dayvig
Town- Dayvig, Bloodhound

Siveure DtTrikyp
Scum- Alien Psychomagnet? (Mass Redirector?)
Town- Childkiller?, Kingmaker?

Bert
Scum- Whywolf
Town- VT, Doc

Anatole Kuragin
Scum- Lyncher
Town-PGO, Governor

[All is Who]

@mod- can you delete post 88? I was promised townpoints.

[All is Who]

Childkiller is town. Also, there might be two town dayvigs, considering there are two on the greater idea list. That is still one over though.

[All is Who]

Who here, I haven't posted in a while due to changing computers and moving in to my dorm. Jingle and I are both signing other player's names, but there is a pattern to who's Who and who's Jingle.

About VTs, Bert's submission doesn't count, so only one discrepancy.

[All is Who]

Well, I'd like to claim my role now, because it'd only end up hurting town in the end. I'm a black goo. Don't hide behind me, protect me, inspect me, or vig me. I also asked the mod, and NKing counts as an action against me, meaning if I'm NK'd, whoever NKs me becomes a cultist.

Town, but we might need to lynch it anyway. Let me discuss with Who.

The discrepancy's my fault for not being clear. I picked the role that screws with kings, which is hero, not kingmaker.

Kaboom, your reasoning of me being scum is just silly. Like wtf. Why the hell would I even fake my SCUM role submission? And also, doing it before basically EVERYONE else in the thread... this line of thought makes literally no sense. The correct answer to "siv's post here is weird" is I ACTUALLY jumbled up which of the alien psychos did what and which I'd submitted, not that it was some elaborate scum plan.

VOTE: kaboom

This reads like scum mad at being caught for the wrong reasons, IMO.

-Jackal

PEdit- Cool. We still need to discuss though.

[All is Who]

Because there's a possible redirector in play that could make us all target you.

Also, Oka thought claiming his role would be a good thing to promote discussion. Unless it actually benefits town, I see no reason for him to claim "to promote discussion." If he wants to discuss things, he can come up with reads on the more prominent players, which he has yet to actually do.

And it appears he's doing nothing. So that's out the window.

This, basically. Black goo + mass redirector is stupid broken in favor of cult. I was kind of trying not to say that outright though. If we let it go to night without lynching you, the game goes stupid in favor of cult, assuming redirector got chosen. Siv's basically already claimed he'd shoot you, making a cultafia, so we're definitely lynching out of you/siv, and I doubt any other mafias would choose not to kill. The question is did someone get redirector.

[All is Who]

Also, Oka, the only claim I want from you is a scumclaim. Would you like to scumclaim?

[All is Who]

Can we not give reasons for optimal scumplay in the thread? Please? I'll be happy to discuss this in the dead thread or post game, but I don't want to give advice to the enemy.

Pay no attention to the man behind the hydra.

-ETL

[All is Who]

I like to think I'm responsible somehow.

[All is Who]

The ironic thing is if we kept werewolf man alive town could've won ;_;

Not unless you lynched Jackel or Anatole.

It didn't even matter if you redirected to jackal or someone else. We were goomaker. So long as you used your ability that night the game was fucked.

It's just bad luck that Alien Mass Redirector and Black goo ended up in the same game.

I thought the mod said it didn't take effect until the next night phase?

Ah. Reading comprehension. We probably should've waited a night then. Still, there is no shame in this defeat nor glory in victory. Only fun and goodtimes to be had by all. We'll have to give All is Who another go sometime.

[All is Who]

Except Armageddon. You should be ashamed of your play this game. 0 posts. Really?

[All is Who]

The ironic thing is if we kept werewolf man alive town could've won ;_;

Not unless you lynched Jackel or Anatole.

It didn't even matter if you redirected to jackal or someone else. We were goomaker. So long as you used your ability that night the game was fucked.

It's just bad luck that Alien Mass Redirector and Black goo ended up in the same game.

I thought the mod said it didn't take effect until the next night phase?

Ah. Reading comprehension. We probably should've waited a night then. Still, there is no shame in this defeat nor glory in victory. Only fun and goodtimes to be had by all. We'll have to give All is Who another go sometime.

Eh?

Waiting a night would be even worse because it would mean less time the goo was there.

But I agree, we should play another game with this.