Micro 530: Auction Mafia II Final!

[Peptobislawl]

VOTE: All Alone
Now you're not alone!

[Peptobislawl]

"just do everyone knows"

But what if i don't want to do everyone?

[Peptobislawl]

Evening all,

VOTE: Hellbringer

Scum confirmed!

@Lucky - Nice, 4 items this time! ^^

Someone wants my attention.

Don't pick on the newb.

I don't like that first post without a RVS vote.
VOTE: Flubbernugget

Who's the newb?

Hellbringer, by the looks of it. Only 2 posts.

[Peptobislawl]

It's a hydra. And I hope you'll only be answering questions when you think it's so obvious there would be no consequences to answering for the one the question is intended

It Is? Oh... The the newb is probably me.

Yeah I didn't think this question was (overly) game related. I've played mafia elsewhere so i know better than to answer accusations not meant for me.

[Peptobislawl]

Well orknight has 2 votes, we could talk about that.

[Peptobislawl]

one's random, and the other is yours.

[Peptobislawl]

Well orknight has 2 votes, we could talk about that.

He actually has 3.

Remind me to check the WHOLE thread when i count votes.

The other other vote is also random.

[Peptobislawl]

No, and no. but a no content vote D1 seems like RVS to me. I'd ask him though, just to be sure.

[Peptobislawl]

How do you go about finding scum in the beginning of a game with nothing to base anything off of... teach us

Sure-

The fact that the mafia have to fake scum hunt and the rest of the players do not creates a gap in the scum players ability to judge how certain they should be on their reads.
For a townie its simple- You read a player and your conclusion is honest and based off that information
For a scum its hard- They already know who the scum is so they instead poke things they believe they can read as scummy and have to feign their amount of certainty on their read.

There are other methods but this is one I believe is very effective. I can give examples of it working as well as references where the technique has been debated but regardless- You can effectively scum hunt D1 if you get the players to actually contribute and shake that troll fluff nonsense.

I'm all for it, but you have to get players to talk when there's nothing to talk about. That's why the RVS exists, to create something to talk about.

[Peptobislawl]

Wait, who suggested it last time, was it scum or town? I think it was Red, right?

He was actually town. Why did you assume that he was scum and that is what I said?

I think its pretty global that Red=Scum, Green=Town in the majority of setups. These quotes speak for themselves

Although just to humor you I saw your comments as pushing against my proposed idea. In line with the other comments it just makes sense that you were insinuating it would be a scum driven plan. I am a little curious about you now. Some of your comments seem out of place. As if you are floating on the edge of looking like you are contributing while staying vague enough to back track. Nobody can call it a slip if you float in that grey area of neither outright supporting or opposing a plan right?

I agree with the rest, but Red is a name, Redcoyote.

[Peptobislawl]

Well I see it.

Lucky

is orange.

[Peptobislawl]

Well all alone just threw a vote on him and left, he hasn't said a word in this game that wasn't in vote tags. Other than that, Lane's vote is the first and thus far only serious vote.

Then again there's 3 posters who have posted minimal content and a vote (Ricastle, Ork himself, and Alone), plus Tetaes who hasn't posted at all. Alone is only notable in that he's on the biggest wagon right now. So maybe the serious vote is the only notable thing at the moment.

[Peptobislawl]

So yeah, that role is less useful. Good for late game claims though.

That role is completely useless.not just "less" useful.

It would tell you who bought a certain power, if you pick right.

[Peptobislawl]

I agree with fire. Whoever gets it should hang on to it.. It is effectively worthless D1 and not really useful later. Role abilities do not give us anything to suggest alignment.

Player List

H. Role powers last during the following night phase and forfeited at the beginning of the next day phase. Unless specified otherwise.

You can't hold on to it. you buy it you have to use it N1 or lose it.

[Peptobislawl]

Well all alone just threw a vote on him and left, he hasn't said a word in this game that wasn't in vote tags. Other than that, Lane's vote is the first and thus far only serious vote.

Then again there's 3 posters who have posted minimal content and a vote (Ricastle, Ork himself, and Alone), plus Tetaes who hasn't posted at all. Alone is only notable in that he's on the biggest wagon right now. So maybe the serious vote is the only notable thing at the moment.

I am probably going to kill you tonight

Do I even need to point out what is wrong with this reply?

[Peptobislawl]

It's late and i don't really have anything to add that I see right now, so I'll re-look over the thread tomorrow when i have more time.

[Peptobislawl]

My vote for Alone was RVS, but i guess it can stay there until more leads come up. Hate to sheep but this early flubb's post sums up

All

that makes me suspicious of

Alone

.

See what I did there?




I'll be in the corner.

[Peptobislawl]

Your post looked very genuine to me and I agreed with pretty much everything you said. You seem to be looking at the game from a near-identical angle to me, which is a great indicator as well.

Coming to that conclusion after one post? Don't you think you're jumping the gun a little?

Not only that, but if you think all those same things, why didn't YOU say them? You were obviously around before Tetaes was, so you had the chance.

[Peptobislawl]

I don't get that logic at all. Get had posted, what, twice before re declared him ovetown? One scumhunting post does no ovetown make. It reads lime re is trying to buddy up with some random downy at the slightest hint of townyness (or however you spell that).

I admit I should have typed more in the origional post, but I had a bus to catch.

[Peptobislawl]

Errr.. I mean.. Ignore that. Im like, Not here and shit. Because 'reasons' : P

What the hell are you on about here, I think it was a recastle FOS but hen this and Whaaaaaaaaaa?

[Peptobislawl]

I don't get that logic at all. Get had posted, what, twice before re declared him ovetown? One scumhunting post does no ovetown make. It reads lime re is trying to buddy up with some random downy at the slightest hint of townyness (or however you spell that).

I admit I should have typed more in the origional post, but I had a bus to catch.

So what's the minimum number of posts before town can townread someone?????

"Coming to that conclusion after one post? Don't you think you're jumping the gun a little?" reads more like you think Ricastle is town playing badly than scum playing maliciously. I don't think this is a genuine read, I think you're looking for town "mistakes" to capitalize on.

Townread and Ovetown are very difrent things. Besides, I never voted for him, I just was trying to pressure him for information. To tell if he's town playing badly or scum playing maliciously.

[Peptobislawl]

I know an obvtown when I see one, son. I didn't say all of what Tetaes did earlier because I didn't see sufficient need to, as I have already conveyed the majority of what I have wanted to. Besides, if I had laid my thoughts completely out already, I wouldn't have been able to get this read.

You stood by your read, which is good. Scum might fold under pressure, but standing your ground is more likely to be town. I still think your jumping the gun here, but I don't think it's scummy, just overzealous. Other than that, you haven't said
much else in regards to it, which is fine. Better than dwelling on trying to justify it and wastin

[Peptobislawl]

I hate phonepostibg so much

[Peptobislawl]

Well he sure was quick to defend Ricastle for Ovetown-ing someone after minimal posts. Plus he hasen't explained his townread on vedith when asked and a general lack of content. It's not great, but there isn't that much to go on so he's my top scumread for now.

[Peptobislawl]

Can anyone explain the Veditih wagon? I really don't see him as scum right now.

[Peptobislawl]

I'm okay with either HB or Ricastle lynch. Also not against an All Alone lynch

UNVOTE: HB
VOTE: Ricastle

Pept is confirmed town since both are on his wagon.

Oh maybe this is why he's scumread. I fully admit that I have been lurking in this game, mostly as a result of being in WAY to many games at once, so having some town votes on me is to be expected.

I don't really like declaring me conftown without me earning it, so by extension I don't really like him right now.VOTE: vedith, he's L-2 now.

[Peptobislawl]

Really all I can say in my defense is that this game is getting shafted due to overextention on my part, and I'm sorry.

[Peptobislawl]

Well this game coulda gone better. Never let me play in 7 games at the same tome ever again.

[Peptobislawl]

I'm here, more or less. Yeah I'll flip Mafia.