Micro 664: The Walking Dead S2E1 GAME OVER

[knightmare]

VOTE: Elmer Bugs FTW

Excited to play in one of these games. I skimmed a few of the previous ones in the series while waiting for this one to go out so I think I've got a good feel for things.

Let's rumble

[knightmare]

VOTE: Elmer Bugs FTW

Bugs made a really nice hossenfeffer.

Locking my vote in.

GG

[knightmare]

The VC is cut off for me too.

P-edit: Gotta make it thru this game first Gamma

[knightmare]

I guess I'll do RQS so others have something to read whenever they join the thread.

1) I was looking for a small game to join and I like the theme.
2) I don't know anyone here so can't really say.
3) Any roles that return negative results.

[knightmare]

@Gamma - why BBT if you say you don't know them that well?

[knightmare]

@Jin - those are a few examples. Or like Gamma said, a bus driver. Godfathers, millers, etc. Basically anything that can screw up or provide false investigative reports.

@Gamma - based on what you say I'd think they wouldn't be a good choice then, no?

[knightmare]

My posts are:
Filler
RQS
And me saying you might be a good player.
How is any of that super scummy? The filler is iffy but I won't deny that it's filler.

It's the third point that is the problem imo.

Read to me like pandering

[knightmare]

Hello all!

For the record, Elmer was my alt. I asked to switch back as I didn't like going back and forth between different accounts.

Ftr Bugs is still better

everybody has confirmed.

VOTE: ARCHANGEL

I would have expected her to have posted by now. If she has indeed comfirmed she would probably have a post of some-kind. Unless she is lurking scum.
(Have I got gender right?)

How serious was this post?

[knightmare]

@BBT - do you have a legit reason?

[knightmare]

Yes. His posts are not sitting well with me but I can't put my finger on why yet.

Ok. I think I have a general idea of what you mean but I don't know what's normal for them. The comment I referred to as pandering kind of pings for me.

@Creeps - which is exactly why I'm asking you. So?

UNVOTE:

[knightmare]

Damnit. How do you unvote?

Sorry for double posting.

[knightmare]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Creeps

[knightmare]

I think I get where BBT is coming from on Gamma

More specifically?

@Creeps - I don't like that you're not giving me a straight answer. I also think your reason, if legit, is NAI for ArcAngel. Confirming without posting doesn't mean anything. Maybe they're busy and confirmed because they got the email notification.

[knightmare]

That's a cop out. Read back a page if you can't remember something you posted a couple hours ago.

Why do you think someone confirming but not posting is more likely to be scum?

[knightmare]

I've made a few comments now and questioned Gamma over something specific already. If that's not it then I'd prefer you to explain so we can get some actual discussion going.

Also fwiw @Jin - I agree with Cakez here. What page of the thread we're on is irrelevant. You can generate content by offering up your own thoughts or pushing others for their's. Continuing RQS is what doesn't yield AI type posts.

[knightmare]

That's a cop out. Read back a page if you can't remember something you posted a couple hours ago.

Why do you think someone confirming but not posting is more likely to be scum?

Because I am half-crazy half of the time.

I am willing to guess that it was that he (or she) lacked any contrubution when she revealed to have read her role PM. I had a feeling that she is active elsewhere (I guess) so my mind went to a scum PT.

If that's your support evidence you should probably verify that first

Just saying

[knightmare]

RED ALERT!
I find SAJ's talking down of early game reads very scummy based on past games.
VOTE: Secret Agent Jin

Examples please?

[knightmare]

I generally don't have any bad thoughts about the Gamma wagon as I can see why it's there to some extent. One of his explanations was awkward imo. I'm not bothered by BBT pushing it either because I don't think he's being totally serious. Still would like Cakez to answer me.

P-edit: I need more context Gamma.

[knightmare]

Meh that's a bit too broad of a brush stroke if you ask me. You're generalizing meta from different players in a different game and trying to apply it here as an absolute truth. Definitely a stretch.

Better question: if you think Jin is downplaying early reads, do you think there's worth while content ITT so far? And if so then what and what have you taken away from it?

[knightmare]

That's not what I asked.

I asked what have YOU taken from the thread so far.

[knightmare]

BBT probtown
SAJ scummy
ArcAngel might be lurkerscum

Ok that's a start

Agree w BBT

Is AA a meta thing? You're the second to mention lurkscum now

@Cakez - answer my question?

[knightmare]

I'm of the same opinion as was stated previously: she confirmed without posting which is suspicious.

We'll just have to agree to disagree on that one. Unless they're posting elsewhere or it's like unwritten site meta that it's a scum tell I would call it NAI

[knightmare]

Pretty much the only person I wouldn't want to lynch atp is BBT

Need moar townies to start town posting plz

[knightmare]

Well shit.

[knightmare]

I didn't have real bad feelings about BBT before but the hammer kind of screws that up. There was a VC on the same page and Joshz put him at L-1 right after the mod posted it

Joshz looks bad for poor content
Jin approaching "why me" scum tell territory
Gamma pushing bad angles for scum reads
Angel is AWOL

2/4 of those are scum imo unless BBT comes back guilty or something. Gamma/Jin should never be scum together

[knightmare]

Was hoping to get that post from ThinkBig before phase change - I had forgotten about him.

[knightmare]

Well there goes that I guess.

Still nothing from AA either

This sucks :/

[knightmare]

#forevertwilight

[knightmare]

VOTE: Gamma

This is a much better wagon imo.

Creeps getting speed hammered after Jin was ran up should be a good enough reason

Looking forward to seeing what the subs bring to the table

[knightmare]

Ah shit, I got mixed up.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Jin

[knightmare]

#drunkmafiaTM

[knightmare]

I am being coached?

lol I have probably 100 games under my belt both played or modded and have been playing Mafia for 3-4 years. If anyone is coaching, it's me.

Can you give me some examples that gave you that impression?

[knightmare]

Explain Mollie.

You say that I seem coached. I inform you that I am very experience therefore not coached.

Vote stands because ?

[knightmare]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Pirate Mollie

you replaced in for AA correct? I'd like your opinion on the rest of the roster as well.

[knightmare]

Have these games had repeated Role usage typically?

Hated was used already iirc

[knightmare]

lol do you usually shit post?

Firstly, the meta of your previous slot holder means absolutely nothing to me. Now that you are here I want you on record.

Why should I assume your vote on me was role related when your given reason was "I looked coached" which is obviously 1) bad reasoning & a huge assumption on your part and 2) have already proven that wouldn't be the case.

[knightmare]

Oh, and in case it wasn't obvious the vote is to make you accountable for your push.

I asked you for specifics as to what gave you that impression but instead of answering to let me see your POV you just drop your reason but keep the vote.

lol gjge?

[knightmare]

You told them to look at my ISO because I looked coached.

I took that as your reason. Am I incorrect?

And if so - correct me then.

[knightmare]

lol

figured that was the case

just wanted to get you to claim bby

[knightmare]

I should probably mention I'm a BPV townie.

My vest got blown off last Night

Joshz obv lying

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Joshz

[knightmare]

I haven't been hammered yet.

Hurry up and hop on before it's too late

[knightmare]

I was told my BPV got blown off.

It was 1x. Which fits considering the JOAT had a vig shot

[knightmare]

Your mod's handling was not Normal imo

I was told I was shot.

And nothing here dictates the precedent: http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Bulletproof

[knightmare]

Admiring you from afar mostly.

[knightmare]

Did AA submit or was it you?

Or random?