First off Shiny, the reason why I thought you were scummy was that you started off by offering analysis and with Dr. dolittle's post you seem to have dropped it and didn't expand on what you meant and instead shifted away from it (to a vote that I didn't understand at all). I had not realized that there were multiple people posting under the same account and now understand why the change was so jarring. You also have thoroughly explained your feelings on the wagon and enomis and they appear genuine for someone who is worried about the speed of a wagon.
And to answer your question R, I had thought you dropped the idea since you didn't refute Dr. dolittle's analysis and the next post moved away from those suspicions. I agree with Dr. Dolittle, discarding a mafia card doesn't mean it's for a better mafia card. More influential roles are preferred choice, and in my case I feel that the traitor cop is the second worse role in the game next to tree stump.
I want to ask though, Why is the joat discard null but the mafia discard isn't? I thought you meant that analysis of discards were a bad idea in general.
Shiny's other posts have been fine, strong resistance to a poorly reasoned wagon is points in their favor and I don't feel their behavior is forced. “Trying to act useful” is a silly tell for someone who has been throwing out every thought they have. They're pressuring players with clear reasons so I'm happy with them now.
Right now I'm looking at marquis and lucky as scumspects. Marquis reason as he explained originally was about the odds mostly (in post 80), but in post 147 he backtracks and starts talking about disliking the early reactions. Isn't his reactions what you expected out of him if he was town, that he said he had a better town role? and to say your not moving your vote even though you consider him null feels like you're just adamant about it. Complaining about how the hydra is being to confusing while throwing suspicions about them in post 82 and 147 rub me in the wrong way. Which is it, scummy or confusing? I also have not seen whether or not you said made the same mistake as Dr and eno, and as a part of that wagon you should be more open about your read on disturbed.
Vote: Marquis
Lucky isn't a very strong read, some of his earlier posts were just unhelpful asides and some things in post 150 disagree with me, like saying have 3 scum reads is questionable. When you make your reads post, I wanna know what makes marquis different from your scum read on enomis and dr. dolittle.
As for other reads, Dr. dolittle's mistake is pretty genuine IMO and enomis i believe as well, but I want to see what he thinks now about disturbed and the rest of us. I think disturbed handled his wagon well, and everyone else is null.
