Micro 588: High Risk High Reward mafia (Game over)

[oath2order]

Oath who do you think is scum

Does it matter now

Anyways scummiest dwlee

Occam's razor states jmo is town

[Sméagol]

E

n

d

o

f

d

a

y

2

F

i

n

a

l

v

o

t

e

c

o

u

n

t

Dwlee99 [

1

]

:

oath2order

oath2order [

3

]

:

GuiltyLion

/

Dwlee99

/

jmo16mla

There are 4 active players.
Absolute majority is

3

.

Majority has been reached.

Previous vote count

C

a

s

u

a

l

t

y

r

e

p

o

r

t

oath2order

-

citizen

- Lynched.

S

t

a

r

t

o

f

n

i

g

h

t

2

There are 3 active players.

Spoiler: Current player list

[1]

Dwlee99

[2]

jmo16mla

[3] lane0168 -

citizen

- Ate a poisoned sandwich. [1]

[4]

GuiltyLion

[5] Mirhawk -

terrorist

- Lynched.

[6] Lowell -

citizen

- Shot once. [1]

[7] SarasaKat -

citizen

- Drowned in a sea of gummybears. [1]

[8] N e s s -

citizen

- Shot once. [1]

[9] oath2order -

citizen

- Lynched.

Deadline is

16-03-2016 00:00:00 CET

((expired on 2016-03-16 00:00:00))

[Sméagol]

C

o

m

m

e

n

t

By the way; if all 3 of you prefer a shorter nightphase, let me know. Get your actions in, or if you don't want to take action, I'd appreciate a "no action" PM.

Edit:

I have all the PMs I need. If it weren't for the fact I was about to go to bed, I could end it now, but I'm tired, and I want to do all the proper formatting . Write-up ready tomorrow at midnight CET, but probably earlier.

[Sméagol]

E

n

d

o

f

n

i

g

h

t

2

"I don't care which one, they've got to die."

"I'll let him take care of the rest."

"Shit.. Who do I shoot? I think he's the scumnag.."

C

a

s

u

a

l

t

y

r

e

p

o

r

t

jmo16mla

-

citizen

- Blown up with fireworks. [

1

]

..

And..

Dwlee99

-

terrorist

- Shot once. [

1

]

C

o

n

g

r

a

t

u

l

a

t

i

o

n

s

c

i

t

i

z

e

n

s

!

W

i

n

n

e

r

s

a

r

e

y

o

u

!

W

h

a

t

a

s

h

a

m

e

t

e

r

r

o

r

i

s

t

s

.

Y

o

u

a

n

d

y

o

u

r

f

r

i

e

n

d

s

a

r

e

d

e

a

d

.

Spoiler: Endgame player list

[1] Dwlee99 -

terrorist

- Shot once. [1]

[2] jmo16mla -

citizen

- Blown up with fireworks. [1]

[3] lane0168 -

citizen

- Ate a poisoned sandwich. [1]

[4]

GuiltyLion

-

citizen

- Endgame.

[5] Mirhawk -

terrorist

- Lynched.

[6] Lowell -

citizen

- Shot once. [1]

[7] SarasaKat -

citizen

- Drowned in a sea of gummybears. [1]

[8] N e s s -

citizen

- Shot once. [1]

[9] oath2order -

citizen

- Lynched.

T

h

i

s

h

a

s

b

e

e

n

H

i

g

h

R

i

s

k

H

i

g

h

R

e

w

a

r

d

m

a

f

i

a

.

T

h

a

n

k

s

f

o

r

p

l

a

y

i

n

g

!

C

o

m

m

e

n

t

Ok, the video doesn't

totally

match up, but it was too cool to pass up.

Other stuff incoming.

[Sméagol]

First of all, some questions:

- Most importantly, did you guys have

fun?

- I'm not that worried by the balance, though I think it would have helped the terrorists if I didn't disclose the actual ratio (just like when I originally ran it off-site), regardless of which ratio I'd have chosen. Some more paranoia would have helped. Any thoughts of your own on balance?
- With the first game, I considered listing the victims of anyone killed in the write-up. Would you have liked this info?

Anyway, like mentioned, I ran this game first on another site, where we are much more casual than here (which is why you probably won't actually see me playing here anytime soon). I wanted to try modding something more hardcore there, back then I thought this was the kind of thing that would go over well here too, with practically no info. Now I know better, but I still was curious if there would be interest anyway, and if you'd match my expectations. With a day 1 scumnag lynch, I'd say you definitely did. But I thought Dwlee surviving night 1 was pretty miraculous, haha.

Anyway, the original game had a 9-4 ratio. 3 terrorists were killed on day 1, with 2 of them shooting each other. The last terrorist managed to secure a victory anyway by acting the pacifist.

[Sméagol]

Actions

Night 1

N e s s

kills

lane0168

// poisoned sandwich

Dwlee99

kills

N e s s

// no flavour

Lowell

kills

SarasaKat

// drowning in gummybears

oath2order

performs no action.

jmo16mla

kills

Lowell

// no flavour

Night 2

Dwlee99

kills

jmo16mla

// blown up with fireworks

GuiltyLion

kills

Dwlee99

// no flavour

jmo16mla

performs no action.

[lane0168]

Nice job jmo! Happy I didn't shoot you for sure.

[jmo16mla]

I thought I was dead for sure lane! Lol

I was shocked when I saw that I was alive.

I'm much better at this game after flips. Day one has never been my strong suit.

I've got to give it to guilty lion seeing that no lynching wasn't the optimal situation. I wouldn't have seen that without him.

[Dwlee99]

I was playing like a serial killer not knowing my partners. Idk how reads were really possible but I guess you guys caught me lol

[jmo16mla]

Oath was really town towards the end and I wanted you lynched instead but no one hopped on. So I had to go back to oath.

[GuiltyLion]

oh man Dwlee your 321 and 347 almost _almost_ had me change my mind. I think you played very well D1/D2 (I had you as a solid townread D1), you just got unlucky that jmo towned it up to a sufficient degree that I couldn't convince myself he was scum. Well done by jmo.

Also I think Lowell played very well in D1, calling out mirhawk as assertively as he did. Made it easy to sheep him

Smeagol, I had a ton of fun. Thank you for modding!

I think 6-3 would probably be slightly more balanced, or at least it would be better undisclosed to create that paranoia. Flipping a terrorist D1 and knowing it was 7-2 made me feel like we were very likely to win, especially once I realized we could effectively do LYLO twice by lynching and then shooting at night as well.

[Sméagol]

Achievements

Dwlee99

-

Riddles in the dark

/

String 'm up

/

Prod dodge

/

Here to stay

/

Headshot

/

Double kill

jmo16mla

-

Riddles in the dark

/

Nifty fifty

/

Hammer time

/

Prod dodge

/

Here to stay

/

Victorious

lane0168

-

Riddles in the dark

/

Hammer time

/

String 'm up

/

Prod dodge

/

Here to stay

/

Late to the party

/

Victorious

GuiltyLion

-

Riddles in the dark

/

String 'm up

/

Prod dodge

/

Here to stay

/

Victorious

/

Match winning kill

/

Headshot

/

Avenger

Mirhawk

-

Riddles in the dark

/

Prod dodge

/

Here to stay

Lowell

-

Riddles in the dark

/

String 'm up

/

Prod dodge

/

Here to stay

/

Victorious

SarasaKat

-

Riddles in the dark

/

Here to stay

/

Victorious

N e s s

-

Riddles in the dark

/

Nifty fifty

/

String 'm up

/

Prod dodge

/

Here to stay

/

Victorious

/

First blood

oath2order

-

Riddles in the dark

/

Nifty fifty

/

Prod dodge

/

Here to stay

/

Victorious

Spoiler: explanations

Riddles in the dark

- Thanks for partaking in a game by me, Sméagol!

// post (can't replace out)

Nifty Fifty

- Make 50 posts.

// public

Hammer time

- Hammer a lynch.

// public

Living on the edge

- Got to L-1, yet got to live another day.

// public

String 'm up

- Succesfully lynch someone not from your faction.

// post

Prod dodge

- Never been prodded.

// post

Here to stay

- Never replaced out.

// post

Late to the party

- Thanks for replacing in!

// public

Victorious

- Winner of Micro 588!

// post

I am error

- Pointed out a mistake the mod made! How dare you.

// public

Set-up specific

First blood

- Get the first kill in HRHR

// private (must be nightkill)

Match winning kill

- Get the last, game ending kill in HRHR

// post (must be nightkill)

Headshot

- Succesfully kill someone of an opposing faction

// post (must be nightkill)

Double kill

- Succesfully kill two players of an opposing faction

// post (must be nightkill)

Avenger

- Succesfully kill someone of the opposing faction, who has killed someone of your faction

// post (must be nightkill)

I believe these are correct. These were a last-minute addition, though I've thought about including these for a long time. Haven't made icons for most of them unfortunately, maybe I will later.

[GuiltyLion]

also oath there was a reason I asked you who you thought was scum, I valued your input, that actually made me slightly more swayed to shoot Dwlee

also Smeagol the achievements are a nice touch. I'll wear my 'match winning kill' badge proudly

[Sméagol]

Thread of the talking dead
Mafia thread
Mod thread

[Dwlee99]

I was hoping you would change your mind about me lol

[Sméagol]

Smeagol, I had a ton of fun. Thank you for modding!

I think 6-3 would probably be slightly more balanced, or at least it would be better undisclosed to create that paranoia. Flipping a terrorist D1 and knowing it was 7-2 made me feel like we were very likely to win, especially once I realized we could effectively do LYLO twice by lynching and then shooting at night as well.

Thanks!

Yeah, in hindsight, I shouldn't have asked, and I should've decided myself, but it doesn't matter too much. I'll keep it in mind for next time, if there's going to be a next time. I won't run a second (or third actually) iteration of this game any time soon. Maybe I'll do it as a mini theme game one day, so I can use 12 or 13 players, and then I can leave the exact ratio up in the air.

[lane0168]

Achievements are always fun!

[oath2order]

First of all, some questions:

- Most importantly, did you guys have

fun?

- I'm not that worried by the balance, though I think it would have helped the terrorists if I didn't disclose the actual ratio (just like when I originally ran it off-site), regardless of which ratio I'd have chosen. Some more paranoia would have helped. Any thoughts of your own on balance?
- With the first game, I considered listing the victims of anyone killed in the write-up. Would you have liked this info?

Anyway, like mentioned, I ran this game first on another site, where we are much more casual than here (which is why you probably won't actually see me playing here anytime soon). I wanted to try modding something more hardcore there, back then I thought this was the kind of thing that would go over well here too, with practically no info. Now I know better, but I still was curious if there would be interest anyway, and if you'd match my expectations. With a day 1 scumnag lynch, I'd say you definitely did. But I thought Dwlee surviving night 1 was pretty miraculous, haha.

Anyway, the original game had a 9-4 ratio. 3 terrorists were killed on day 1, with 2 of them shooting each other. The last terrorist managed to secure a victory anyway by acting the pacifist.

I had fun for my first game here.

Especially since I had to be serious instead of shit-post.

[N e s s]

Oath was incredibly scummy, just going to say real fast.

[oath2order]

Oath was incredibly scummy, just going to say real fast.

Yet you didn't push for my lynch.

Or shoot me.

[jmo16mla]

He's got a point.

[Sméagol]

I thought Oath was doing well enough day 2, but what do I know.

[N e s s]

Oath was incredibly scummy, just going to say real fast.

Yet you didn't push for my lynch.

Or shoot me.

I was considering shooting you tbh

your d1 was weird

[jmo16mla]

I thought Oath was doing well enough day 2, but what do I know.

He was. As I said earlier, I thought oath was town toward the end of the day. But I wasn't about to try to turn the wagon all the way around when we had already won the game.. Maybe I should have done that.

[Lowell]

GG all. Brilliant move by guilty and jmo there on day 2.

But in other news, wtf jmo in killing me! I found the terrorist and townslipped.... I figured I wouldn't survive the night, but to be killed by town? Ouch!