we don't have 5 players yet, unless there's some way of randomly determining who gets what role without any of us knowing what role we got. tragic but beautiful ;_;
actually wait I have the best idea: 5p vengeful where each player chooses a scum partner in advance if they die and then posts an encrypted message stating who their scum partner is, and then once someone is lynched we roll a d5 to figure out what their role was, and if they're scum, the person they secretly chose as their partner also becomes scum
actually now that I think about it that maybe has legitimate merit as an interesting game. it's definitely Not Real Mafia® but it
would
allow for interesting choices, especially because (hypothetically) 4 players can all choose the same person as their potential scum partner
maybe this would be better if generally being lynched as a godfather day 1 wasn't actually possible? although all the methods that come to mind for determining which situations you'd come up as a godfather require moderator intervention to determine. also I guess this requires the person who gets lynched to send a message to the person who is now the godfather saying "hey good luck day 2 buddy, you're scum now"
can't believe I'm shitposting new variant setups in a dead thread