TNA Wrestling (WWE Dead Thread)

[DodgeTheSaint]

Yep that happened.

[DodgeTheSaint]

Final predictions...

RAW scum equals AC, Nero, and Malp

SD scum = Titus, massive, and...I dunno zefiend I guess

You don't have to spoil me, I'm fine with spectating for now. I have more things to say, but not now.

[DodgeTheSaint]

Surprised by Leon, not surprised by anyone else (except Nero I guess). I was rooting for you Titus, you so deserved this one.

[DodgeTheSaint]

1. Did you enjoy yourself? How much so on a scale of 1-10?
2. What am I doing right? (This would help so I can continue doing it.)
3. What am I doing wrong? (So I know to stop doing it.)
4. Would you like a sequel to this game?

1. Yeah it was alright. I actually really liked the brand split, as it allowed for less chaos in the games. If all 26 of us were in the same thread, this game would be 300 pages, and half the posts would come from Titus, myself, Mathblade, and Maria. Which while extremely productive for scum, would have probably allowed the scumteam to trounce the game more than they have so far.

2. The mechanic was good, as I explained above.

3. I don't know all the roles yet, but on first glance it seems very swingy. Swingyness can be okay, and admittedly I don't know what Chara's alignment is yet, so I'll reserve judgment there. The extra vote related powers didn't seem to serve any purpose and would have probably been best to be reworked in some manner. Unless the purpose was to just give you an excuse to post youtube vids, in which case B+

4. There are probably things you can do to evolve the set-up. Sure.

[DodgeTheSaint]

Almost and Malp methinks

[DodgeTheSaint]

I think I'll claim an assist too, arguing very loudly for you to not be drafted

[DodgeTheSaint]

lol Math

I'll take it I guess. I still doubt scum knew who the scum were on the other brand initially.

Really, really hard to buy AC as town at this point. I would be shocked.

[DodgeTheSaint]

If both managers were scum, then I have to question how the game was balanced. That's the only reason I couldn't see them both being scum. I really do wanna know how it was balanced after the game, because I can't see how. Managers both being scum make it far too scum-slanted in every possible way, and we never got answers as to what happens if we lynch a manager. I'm curious about all that now.

Scum-scum managers are incredibly balanced. So are town-town managers. The only thing that is unbalanced is scum-town managers. This makes no sense.

[DodgeTheSaint]

Hilariously though we did get scum-town managers (I think) and it ended up not affecting the game in a negative way, because the town manager was the one who drafted scum. But in terms of balance, only the scum-town dichotomy had a chance to break the game's balance.

Scum-scum managers mean the two managers have to compete against each other as much as against the town. There's no way for cooperation, because the scum manager is stuck on their brand no matter what. It actually allows for a really interesting meta-game that we were unable to see.

Town-town managers is obviously balanced because neither manager will ever know who the scum are.

Town-scum are not balanced. All it takes is for the scum manager to draft one scum and it effectively ends the game on both brands by N2. Hilariously, (if AC is scum) the town manager managed to draft scum. But I think that was the least likely scenario. (of course if AC is town then this particular speculation is pointless)

[DodgeTheSaint]

Note: I'm not criticizing Kurio if we ended up with the town-scum split if he did alignments randomly as he claimed.

[DodgeTheSaint]

I'm very experienced with Nero doing that to me.

[DodgeTheSaint]

Probably AC and Malp

[DodgeTheSaint]

Also Almost literally dropped a scumtell in his first post of Day 4.

[DodgeTheSaint]

lol mastina

[DodgeTheSaint]

I do feel bad for Math though. I've never seen a player so comically wrong on everything in a single game. They's gonna be really upset with themself when the game finishes.

[DodgeTheSaint]

Yeah SD scum won regardless.

[DodgeTheSaint]

At this point though I think Almost should begin crafting their LyLo with their gladiator. All they need is KMD plus Math/Columbo to win. So gladiate them, kill McMenno, and KMD eats out of their hands for the win.

[DodgeTheSaint]

Titus, you won already, right?
You don't need the scumteam in Raw to win, so you can fully root for the town unless I'm mistaken about wincons.

In my mind, we're all one team until the end. We just took Leonshade on loan. I meant very much that we should shoot for winning both threads and that the spoilering between threads was powerful as fuck.

Only scum used it well.

I even told Almost who our buddies were. I don't know if they caught it.

Well DUH, that's why I argued against that pro-scum move

[DodgeTheSaint]

You were fine. You just got so stuck in the incorrect assumptions you made about the set-up that you got locked into bad reads because of it. I'd suggest being more fluid on your assumptions in the future.