Mafia 126 - Lovers Mafia! [Game Over]

[GreyICE]

Grey, please talk sense into your partner. That's some of the worst lylo logic ever.

"Reck has been making good posts... but his partners have been bad" (Reck is town, but his lurky partner's who have pretty much just parroted him are somehow worse)
"I can only think of two scumteams" (even though plenty of others have been presented)
"I'm not going to explain why these are the only two I can think of"
"I'm not comfortable with Reck's 100% town reads" (even though I just said in the same post that I like Reck's posting)

I HAVE NO FUCKING CLUE

I REALLY DON'T

HE SEEMS TO HAVE COME UP WITH THIS ONE ALL ON ITS OWN.

APPARENTLY SHEEPING OBVSCUM IS THE NEW HOTNESS

[GreyICE]

How about I ignore the QT since it's been a barren wasteland of content since we decided to try and hold off on eating Vezok for the reads to see if they'd out the other werewolves.

WHAT THE FUCK SORT OF FUCKING LOGIC IS THAT DH

WHY IS HE SCUM

GIMME SOMETHING THAT MAKES A LICK OF FUCKING SENSE

[GreyICE]

DH CANNOT MISLYNCH YOU IN LYLO THANK GOD

BECAUSE IT TAKES 6 TO LYNCH

AND I WILL MOVE MY VOTE TO YOU SOMETIME AFTER THE SUN SPUTTERS OUT INTO A BROWN DWARFT

[GreyICE]

DH

RECKONER IS OBVTOWN ON PAGE ONE.

PLEASE START HERE:
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 2#p2765552

THEN TELL ME WHY IN A MONTH OF SUNDAYS A SCUMBAG WRITES THAT POST

[GreyICE]

OR ANY OF THOSE POSTS.

IT WAS A NICE GAME STARTING FIGHT, BUT IT WAS FUCKING TOWN AS SHIT

[GreyICE]

DH

RECKONER IS OBVTOWN ON PAGE ONE.

PLEASE START HERE:
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 2#p2765552

THEN TELL ME WHY IN A MONTH OF SUNDAYS A SCUMBAG WRITES THAT POST

I don't get what you're saying here. A player of ANY alignment could write that post in that very situation. What makes it a townish thing to post?

Dude
The entire argument SCREAMED town.

He thought I was scum trying to do something that was pro-scum. He didn't even consider it. He slammed into me straight off the bat with full force.

Not only would scum Reck not be incompetent and checked the 4 man QT (and thus figured out they had no NKs), he'd have let me be the fall guy for a plan he thought was pro-scum.

Why would some nonsensical partner theory trump the fact that he's TOWN you fucking derp

[GreyICE]

Zito

Not that you didn't basically confirm yourself scum the moment you voted for Reck... but did you read the entire day 1 with the kill/no-kill shit?

[GreyICE]

Damn it, DH wins.

[GreyICE]

On the plus side Fate was still OBVSCUM I just had PZ as his partner

[GreyICE]

Dude Reck

You ran me

For four months.

I am seriously fucking impressed. This was 100% YOU. Fate is ALWAYS obvscum, and the sad part is you STILL would have won if I'd lynched him, because you could have lynched ANY of us.

[GreyICE]

And before Fate is like 'trolololol'

http://www.quicktopic.com/45/H/8LQiG6fYpp68c

[GreyICE]

100% RECK FATE

YOU HAD ME FOR ABOUT FIVE POSTS

BUT YOU'RE SUCH A PAIN IN THE ASS TO LYNCH YOU GIVE GREAT READS

TOO BAD RECK JUST OUTPLAYED THE ENTIRE THREAD

[GreyICE]

Couldn't have done it without you, GI!

No, you could have.

Who wanted to lynch you after day 1?

[GreyICE]

Yeah you played me well. You jumped off mislynches onto lynches I liked. Fought to keep town alive.

It was insane.

[GreyICE]

New rule... I just vote my strongest town read in LyLo every time.

[GreyICE]

seems counterproductive

Never.

You're alive in LyLo for a reason

[GreyICE]

But... every day? Day 1? 2? 3? 4? All of that? Vezok? PO and Espy? All of that shit we went through? Yeah. You're good. And I get played easily apparently.

[GreyICE]

Yeah new alliance. Mastin+GreyICE, we lynch our strong town reads, they flip scum.

[GreyICE]

And btw, yes. I reread the entire game. Mariyta and Tragedy were scummy. PZ was scummy. Reckoner was town as hell. Fate was scum as shit. Ashblade+Llamarble were town.

I didn't see how it would go wrong, except RECK WAS SCUM.

[GreyICE]

I played shitty, but dram was still very obviously scum that game (along with PO town, and Ice town, and PZ town). I just knew that no one would listen to me unless I lynched his partner first. Also completely called Fate scum in QT from his first post which was horribad. Another one of those things though that no one would listen to due to all the yelling, which I am coming closer and closer to policy lynching due to the amount of damage they do.

My lord, make the damn case instead of sitting there and poking obvtown marble and obvtown ashblade.

[GreyICE]

That would explain why you were poking Llamarble and Ashblade

[GreyICE]

Also, for the record, why did you think a loverclaim bad in this setup?

It allows for more natural attacks and defenses. In this game, whether you like it or not knowing whos partnered to who will create bias in the read of the second person. A perfect example of how that could have changed the game is the reck/NC slot. If people were willing to scrutinize NC more, it could have changed the direction of the early game instead of simply giving the player a pass.

Having nothing be off limits allows for town to scumhunt without the bias an misconceptions that this type of game will naturally create. Any time that those things come into play, scum who know what to do can just feed off it indefinantly and protect/push of people that would not normally be up. This is one of those odd situations (like polygamist, just less so) where the less information the town knows, the better.

Also how did NO ONE go back and do

vote count

analysis? Seriously?

Im thinking next game I get into with "rage posting" I am going to push for a policy lynch. Its really got to such a point where its destroying the fun of the game while hurting the town. People who do it (Im looking at you Fate) need to realize it makes the game miserable for a majority of the people, and eventually I know I just end up not reading anything you post.

Vote counts?