Title Fairy: Abuse of Mooglepower!

[Oman]

Going to the Front Page:

Faraday

...Should I Be Here?

Basically I liked the "mistaken" ones, but it wasn't enough of an issue that when Faraday weighed in I had any intention of going against his preference.

Furcolow

To Be Frank

I like the length, it's got a great flow, highlights both the joke and the play reference etc etc. I think we've been on this long enough.

Nachomamma8

Devil in the Details

Pretty well received overall.

DemonHybrid

And Another Thing...

Not my favourite title, but DH digs it, others dig it.

EDIT: NobodySpecial

It's Midnight Somewhere

Discussion continues on:

Thor

NordIC/MythIC

etc
If I made a decision now, it would probably make a lot of people feel like I've made the wrong decision, and I don't like that as a barometer. I would love to push this into a compromise though, if one can be reached without ruining the title.
How do people feel about

NordIC Myth

? Be advised that if I made a decision today, it would be

MythIC Beard

or just

NordIC

Scummies

And the Me Goes To...

I like this, anyone got a real issue. Khan, I considered what you were saying about the Scummies, and I think that it's lighthearted enough that giving it a fun title adds to it, while a rare enough account that we're not overbearing anything. Considering the Scummies' mix of professional recognition and goofy community, a title seems like a good opportunity to add to them (because really, that's what titles are professionalism and goof).

Mute

Anything But

Not bad. Hard road getting to it, but worth a chat.

Sharkfinn

Hammerhead

I really don't dig this. That said there is a pretty big push behind it. I merely ask if this has any sort of staying power, or was it just a fad? There are so many titles being suggested for hammering or hammerers.

Mastin/2

things about tiny text

Don't encourage this, guys.

Also deleted a lot of posts. Deal with that.

[SleepyKrew]

NordIC Myth is terrible.

[Nobody Special]

For Mute, I'd prefer:

...not really

[Mr. Flay]

The whole Mute thing is terribad.

If we're down to those two/three choices, I vastly prefer NordIC to to either of the others. MythIC Beard is second, Mafia Scum is third, then NordIC Myth.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Why does everyone hate on

Beard of Wisdom

? Sigh ...

And I love the Scummies suggestion ... very funny and approps

+1

[Tragedy]

Or why not

IC ====[ ]

?
It's funny on certain perspectives.

Agreeing with the Scummies' 100%. Though it doesn't generally make sense grammatically. So you can just change it to

I'm going to you,

[Mr. Flay]

Vastly prefer

And the award goes to

, with or without ellipses. "and the Me" is cutesy dreck.

[Mute]

Agreeing with the Scummies' 100%. Though it doesn't generally make sense grammatically. So you can just change it to

I'm going to you,

Oh hey you speak Na'Vi?
that's what comes to mind when I read that. -1

[Tragedy]

Vastly prefer

And the award goes to

, with or without ellipses. "and the Me" is cutesy dreck.

Or that.

[CSL]

MythIC Beard

I agree with Flay about the title attempt on Mute. It's terribad.

And the award goes to...

is good.

Hammerhead

needs to either go or stay. Regardless, Shark is v/la, so...

[ReaperCharlie]

NordIC Myth is terrible.

Agreed.

Also,

Beard of Wisdom

.

[mastin2]

I don't think its title worthy.
Its based off the fact that his username is "Mute".

If his username wasn't "Mute" then you wouldn't have ever considered giving him a title for posting a lot.

So its username based, and I don't really see Mute as posting a lot. There is so many more people with higher posts per day and overall posts.

You ignore the part where I said it USED to be an appropriate name. How he used to be not talking much, both by not posting, and not posting much. (*sigh*. Do I need to get the links?)

He got better.

...

Muuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuch

better.
...A little

too

much better. Becoming quite talkative, in stark contrast to his Once-Appropriate-Username.
(Both by the number of posts, and the length of said posts--there is no way, no tool that I know of, which can magically determine "longest posts". "Most posts", sure, but never "longest posts". And since you can't measure that, you also can't measure a combination of them. "Most talkative overall".
I've done my homework, and found Mute was quite talkative, both with number, AND length in posts.

[Maybe not THE most. But he's certainly among the top names, as this thread demonstrates. It's not just this thread, though--it's also in his games. Go do your research; I've done mine.]

And I was there, to see that contrast to how he used to be, how he used to not be very talkative, barely posting and not posting a lot when he did.
Have you done your homework?)


So, yes. I would have. He could've called himself Martin, and I'd still be suggesting a title for the notable change I saw in him. (Granted, it'd be a slightly different nomination, but the reasons would remain the same.)

Also,

Mute Anything But Not bad.

[CSL]

NordIC Myth is terrible.

Agreed.

Also,

Beard of Wisdom

.

That is out of the picture. Settle for the

MythIC Beard

one. It still has the Beard in it...

[mastin2]

For Mute, I'd prefer:

...not really

It's kinda sad how I just now got this, despite having read it earlier.

[SpyreX]

Scummies And the Me Goes To... I like this, anyone got a real issue. Khan, I considered what you were saying about the Scummies, and I think that it's lighthearted enough that giving it a fun title adds to it, while a rare enough account that we're not overbearing anything. Considering the Scummies' mix of professional recognition and goofy community, a title seems like a good opportunity to add to them (because really, that's what titles are professionalism and goof).

If it were in that context I think:

And I go to....

Sounds better.

Thor I like either one word (NordIC / MythIC). The others don't have that jazzy flow.

[Mist7676]

For Scummie why not...

And I go to...

[ReaperCharlie]

Aside from the fact that SpyreX just suggested

that very thing

....

...it's pretty stupid.

[Mute]

Mastin, I appreciate the nom, and while I admit I like it, I don't feel I should get a title. I've been here, what, the bare minimum amount of time? Feels... inappropriate.

Though that newbie game Drench modded I played.. hoo boy. That one post I made against workdawg.. that was hell.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Aside from the fact that SpyreX just suggested

that very thing

....

...it's pretty stupid.

No. Just no.

And I go to

is vastly superior to the uber-generic

And the award goes to

or varation of.

[Mist7676]

Oh wow didn't see that.

[mastin2]

Actually, Mute. Today (June 20th) is your eight-month anniversary (of October 20th). Not six. So, not bare minimum.

[ReaperCharlie]

Aside from the fact that SpyreX just suggested

that very thing

....

...it's pretty stupid.

No. Just no.

And I go to

is vastly superior to the uber-generic

And the award goes to

or varation of.

Yes.

But

Mafia Scum

is still the best.

[Robocopter87]

Look mastin2,

I understand perfectly what you are saying.
And I agree that Mute has done a bit of posting. And that it does show.
and I understand there has been a contrast.

But what I'm saying is,

Is it really worthy to be put into title position?

Do you know how many people have a bunch of posts in particular topics?
A Lot.
A lot of people have A LOT of posts.

I think that the only reason that Mute's posting is special is simply because of his username.

If his username was "Zebronic", would you still suggest this title for him?

[Kublai Khan]

I think that the only reason that Mute's posting is special is simply because of his username.

If his username was "Zebronic", would you still suggest this title for him?

I'd nominate Zebronic for

Read all over

.

[mastin2]

Is it really worthy to be put into title position?

Do you know how many people have a bunch of posts in particular topics?
A Lot.
A lot of people have A LOT of posts.

My title. Unabridged. I got that because I posted a lot of walls. (Essentially.)

Is that unique to me?
Heck no.

Was it still title-worthy?
Apparently.

Yes. I think Mute's posting habits are title worthy, ESPECIALLY with the contrast from what he used to be. It's part of who he is, contrasting with who he was.

Why WOULDN'T it be title-worthy?