Title Fairy: Abuse of Mooglepower!

[gandalf5166]

Meh. Not feeling it.

I could get behind

79.5% Noise

or something for ani; he's definitely slowly getting better.

[CSL]

Un2nd

Nominate animorpherv1 for 78.3% Noise

That seems about right.

[Kublai Khan]

88.2%

[gandalf5166]

I like CSL's the best.

[Seraphim]

89.4%

Edit: because it's the lowest duh

[CSL]

It's more likely to be correct, duh.

[Mr. Flay]

79.5% uses all the same numbers, though. It's

elegant

.

[Nobody Special]

What have I started......

[RichardGHP]

-1 FTFY

[mastin2]

79.5% uses all the same numbers, though. It's

elegant

.

[animorpherv1]

What have I started......

Depends on your point of view:

1) A discussion on a new title for me.
2) Something good/bad

[gandalf5166]

79.5% uses all the same numbers, though. It's

elegant

.

Hmmmm.... I guess.

[Ythan]

97.5
95.7
79.5
75.9
59.7
57.9

Which of these is most accurate?

[CSL]

75.9

[gandalf5166]

75.9

[Oman]

Thor - gets

Papa Smurf

. This is for a few reasons: one is that minimalism in titles is sexy, but the rest are about Thor. Basically, no matter what I say I'm going to piss someone off here, and I think this discussion has gone on too long for there NOT to be a decision. Papa Smurf is a great title, it has a nice flow, it's funnny, and nacho's stretching even made a beard reference out of it. MythIC was a close second, and Beard of Wisdom was so far down the list that it was on another page.

Poor Thor. People love him so much he'll never get a title.

This is the other option. Of course.

Seraphim - I don't dig the matyr/angel suggestions. Skrew's idea of

Seraphim deserves a title.

is invalid. I honestly don't buy that a title is inherently better than not-title.

silverbullet - Yeah I dig the MSnet Adventures (for those who don't get it, it's a reference to "MSpaint Adventures". Google it). I think it's a great title. Someone disagree, I know you're out there.

Also I suggest that title suggestions based in Forum 62 activity be handled with care, as it necessarily excludes a part of the userbase from getting the reference.

Ohshit. Not this. Okay, yes it's true that almost any title will apply only to a section of the community (those not playing newbies won't get Thor being a good IC, those not in mishmash won't get....a mishmash title - I'm obviously not a masher), and I don't think that Forum 62 is a big this. This is kind of like the Fat and Sassy argument again.

Mastin2 - I don't see the need to give a secondary account like that a title. I dunno, it's just not anything special. I'm glad mastin recognises that it's not necessary.

Hohum -

avatar based titles are wrong and the work of the devil. etc

Not always. Some are great. Plus, plenty already exist.

And if it's a past avatar, that lends a little to the inside-joke-ness of it.

I personally like most avatar-based titles I've seen, unless they're

shamefully

redundant.

No, it makes it outdated and irrelevant. Titles should be accessible, not an inside joke made even more obscure over time. The fact that some exist doesn't lend credence to your argument, either.

Really, Uncle Potbear is getting laughs? What the hell, folks?


Korts - For those unaware, Korts requested his title removed.

Luddite

is great IMO. Anyone got concerns? Korts?

Ani - Okay I like the idea of us changing up the numbers. If it does change, it will be 75.9% so we can stop just posting numbers everywhere now. Instead let's discuss the concept. I mean, if we take it to it's endstate it will be 0, where do we go from there? And the other thing is as it progresses lower, it stops being anything special. Having such a high Noise:Signal was his shtick, 50% ain't special. I am feeling that if it does change the numbers, it will happen ONCE. I don't think this is going to be a regular game.

[Ythan]

Really, Uncle Potbear is getting laughs? What the hell, folks?

It's the pot.

[Korts]

Like I said, the concept is great, but the specific suggestion of Luddite seems like just a straightforward description. It's like if Brandi had Artist or shaft.ed had Funny One-Liners.

re: ani, if his title reaches 0% or, like, an average signal:noise ratio, some new title that reflects how he turned from shitposter to full-on member of the community (hopefully) or perhaps something like an encouragement to other shitposters to improve would be great.

[animorpherv1]

Nominate Korts for That Other Luddite

[Vi]

Really, Uncle Potbear is getting laughs? What the hell, folks?

Who else will you

ever

call Uncle Potbear?
Who else will

we

ever call Uncle Potbear?
Do you deny that he

is

Uncle Potbear?

[Mr. Flay]

I am feeling that if it does change the numbers, it will happen ONCE. I don't think this is going to be a regular game.

Agreed.

Also, Thor's title is implemented, as are the rest on the first post.

[Ythan]

In that case how about 57.9%?

[Mist7676]

How about

99.99999999999999%

[RichardGHP]

If Mastin2 gets an alt-title, it should be something funny, in much the same way that '

Empking's Alt's Alt

' provides subtle humour, but also succinctly explains itself within its own constraints, with no prior knowledge of him being necessary. In my opinion,

Unabridged2

does not fulfill that criterion and is therefore not a particularly good title.

How about

99.99999999999999%

No.

[CSL]

It's already decided to be 75.9% Noise for ani. Quit your arguing.