The Mystery... The Mayhem (Good or Bad?)

[Cadmium]

I

voted: Surprises are okay, but give the setup. Players should know how many mafia/cops/docs etc. there are.

I don't really like to be messed with by the mod. Surprises are okay, like the one in Improbable Role Mafia. I liked the twist that there's a chance that a voter could be killed as well (that didn't turn out too well for me btw). But when you get a role, and the E-mailed description is different from the true role you got, I think it sucks. I've had it more than once.
So, surprises during the game are okay, but don't say anything that turns out to be different (I don't like lies, unless I'm mafia).

This is just my opinion! I think it's up to the mod what to put in his game. After all, it's his/her game.

[Cadmium]

I just wanted to say I also think that Querci's Mafia 3 is a great game. In fact, I think it's my favorite game so far. I had

the

most fun!
I agree with Sketchwick about the roles. They shouldn't be too important for a game. It only makes everybody to dependant to these persons. You still can add funny stuff to a role but it shouldn't make too much of an impact on a game.