Moderation 101

[Luna]

Macors, you might as well just post yours. This thing is going slow (and I'm not really sure what you meant by one of your roles anyway).

Let's see...

My "standard" (i.e. I've run 1 game with it ) 20 player game would be something like:

4 Mafia A (godfather optional)
4 Mafia B (godfather optional)
4-5 Cops (Usually 2 Sane, 1 Insane, 1 Paranoid, 1 Naive; or 2 Sane, 2 Insane)
2 Docs
4 Masons
1 Serial Killer
1 Extra role if only using 4 Cops (such as Vigilante, Traitor of some sort, Ninja , etc.)

Of course, I never stick to the formula; for one thing, if everyone knows what types of Cops there are, it's easier for the Cops to figure stuff out.

If I was going to do a one family game, I'd go with:

4 Mafia
5 Cops (see above)
3 Masons
2 Docs
1 Serial Killer
5 Townies

or something similar.

I'll provide feedback on the above setups later.

[Luna]

Yeah, I think they're pretty balanced. Either could turn into a easy win by any side, of course, but on the average, I would guess that they're pretty fair. I'd like to get a working sim to test that, of course.