Mafia Mod rating system

[Samadhi]

How about:
Did you have fun?
Was the game balanced?
Was the game fair?

[Samadhi]

Well, the critique of a game shouldn't be done by just anyone. I would say that the people who played should fill out a "scorecard." Anyone who was in the game the whole time (or most of, judgement call perhaps by the "panel") could fill out a "scorecard." But the players IMO shouldn't get all the say.
Beyond the players I think it should be very limited, but I do think there should be a "panel" of sorts who would also fill out a "scorecard." DP, mith, IS, Antrax, some few others who are generally recognized as preeminent in the field of mafia. Others could be added to the "panel" by some method or another.
Your mod score would come from:
50% Participants
50% "Panel"
3% Perspiration (ok j/K)

The "scorecard" could be a 1-10 (or whatever) on several different subjects.

• Action
  
• Balance
  
• Continuity
  
• Discretion
  
• Enjoyment

Or whatever preferably adding up to a nice round figure like 20, 50 or 100.

And if a "panel" member is also a player then they only get to fill out one "scorecard" and choose which group it goes in.