In post 3, zoraster wrote:
That said, we are looking into adding an award that captures some of what we like about Best Role Claim: namely that it recognizes good play in an individual thread that doesn't require being good year round. We're still discussing what the best way to implement this is, however.
Best Gambit has been suggested before, but it's just not a good award. While I don't really believe Best Role Claim causes bad behavior, Best Gambit may well do so.
There already is one. "Most Cunning Manipulation" can be for scum with good claims and town with [fake] claims that net scum but I think it should be a single game award and not a body of work.
We could have something like a "Leader of Scum" that would be a body of work for excellent performances as scum/third party.
I like the golden fendoa award as a lifetime achievment award for great mafia play throughout the years.